@danny___puppy@Julius_Garfield the instant almost every pokemon in the game is foreign it stops quite being about precise ecology in the way eg Brooklet Hill or Union Cave take great care to divide their encounter tables between the parts of them that are freshwater vs marine environments
@danny___puppy@Julius_Garfield oh yeah absolutely there's a reason I said "to an extent"; it's part of the premise of the game that this is happening and a problem. however i don't really think the game examines these issues to the extent it feels like it wanted to and also it isn't quite regular ecology
@Julius_Garfield I would argue that's more the case for biology; ecology has only ever been *subservient* to cool shit once to my knowledge (SwSh......)
@Julius_Garfield canon games do pay a lot of mind to their fictional ecology though (minus rby/half of swsh/z-a to an extent) i think it's fair to want that taken into consideration but as someone who cares about it i feel like i am unusual for that and have never seen anyone else bring it up
@Julius_Garfield Okay tbh I find pokemon in bad habitats much more jarring than too many of them and it's not a deal breaker usually unless its REALLY nonsensical. like if u put idk wailmer in a lake im side eyeing u a bit but only a bit
@FernandoVerd2@fourche_jean@kingpminch Eusine doesn't recognize Kris but Kris talks about knowing Eusine; Kris also doesn't know about the Battle Frontier. She's literally from the Crystal timeline where she was the protag
@hibisilver Pokopia acknowledges Red/Leaf and Lyra/Kris as separate people (and LGPE does the same for Red and Green); it seems more like they exist offscreen and irrelevant (a la opposite gender bw1 protag)
@Bulbagarden what's been going on with your SEO lately? (at least on duckduckgo). it used to be really easy to get bulbapedia pages from searching generally but now i effectively cannot (voltorb used as example but this is consistent)
@UhWittyUsername@gallyxies Fwiw masters had a dev interview at one point where they mentioned all the dialogue gets QAd by gf to make sure it fits in the world and is in character so the info and characterization we get (for non Masters OCs) is canon the events just aren't
@The_Teal_Mask Also another issue is how the concept was expanded upon and continues to be expanded upon and ties back to Zinnia's monologue and people just don't treat the new info as an expansion but rather its own thing
@Julius_Garfield I don't think there should be a cosmic type because of lore reasons; why would there be an element that's only held by non-Earth beings? It implies a flatness to the universe I don't quite like
Plus I feel the design space is represented through Psychic, Fairy, Rock, and Ice
@BoltBeamVGC Mega Dhelmise that becomes a creepy kelp forest (that's actually one strand snaking around the whole thing) ensnaring an entire ship
Or Mega Carnivine as a multi headed hydra with a body that's just a shambling mass of vines. It's too heavy to float but has Bug Flash Fire
@DirtyGlasses23@MikeMartyLOVEY1 Kingler, Clawitzer, Barbaracle, Gliscor, Kabutops, Crawdaunt, Crabominable, Klawf (+Flygon and Bisharp too) are all arthropods and not Bug-type yes, Bug is looser than just "arthropod" even if the majority of Bugs fall into that category
@DirtyGlasses23@MikeMartyLOVEY1 Oh it absolutely is but my point is more "exact accuracy isn't the priority, types are often more thematic than science based". Cradily is based on a sea lily which is a sessile animal and is Grass, Accelgor and Shuckle are Bugs without being arthropods, Flygon *isn't* Bug, etc