@TheSevenSermons@Ap3x16 I’m not arguing Kobe wasn’t elite. I’m arguing that cherry-picking Kobe’s best series and comparing it to Shaq’s different series doesn’t prove Kobe was better. If Kobe was objectively better than Shaq in those championship runs, why did Shaq win Finals MVP both years?
@TheSevenSermons@Ap3x16 In the 2001 Western Conference Finals, Kobe averaged 33.3/7/7 and Shaq averaged 27/13. Credit to Kobe, he was incredible. But in the actual NBA Finals against Philadelphia, Shaq averaged 33/15.8/4.8 on 57.3% shooting. Kobe averaged 24.6/7.8/5.8 on 41.5% shooting.
@TheSevenSermons@Ap3x16 Shaq also won Finals MVP in BOTH championship runs. In the 2001 Finals, he averaged 33 and 15.8. In 2002, he averaged 36.3 and 12.3. And saying “lots of people had Kobe over Shaq” doesn’t establish that he was objectively better.
@TheSevenSermons@Ap3x16 Nobody is denying Kobe was phenomenal in 2001 and 2002. But you’re confusing leading scorer in individual games with being the most valuable player over an entire playoff run. Shaq averaged 30.4 PPG, 15.4 RPG and 2.4 BPG in the 2001 playoffs. Kobe averaged 29.4, 7.3 and 0.8.
@TheSevenSermons@Ap3x16 So yes, Kobe has one more ring. But if we’re discussing individual greatness, why are you counting championships without considering who was actually the best player on those championship teams?
@TheSevenSermons@Ap3x16 And the extra ring argument needs context. Kobe has 5 championships, LeBron has 4. But Kobe won 2 Finals MVPs while LeBron won 4. Kobe also won 3 of his championships alongside Shaq, who was the Finals MVP in all three.
@TheSevenSermons@Ap3x16 And remember, this is ONLY comparing championship runs. It doesn’t account for their entire playoff careers, MVPs, longevity, consistency, or overall body of work.
@TheSevenSermons@Ap3x16 So you’re using a comparison of four championship runs to argue Kobe was the better winner, scorer, and overall player, but the numbers show LeBron was significantly more efficient and contributed more across the board.
@TheSevenSermons@Ap3x16 and ignoring individual responsibility for those championships? Which opponents? What years? And wdym better competition. What were their supporting casts? Are you counting regular season or playoffs? Head-to-head records without context don’t prove individual superiority.
@TheSevenSermons@Ap3x16 You’re making four claims, but you’re not actually explaining them. Kobe won 5 championships, LeBron won 4. But LeBron has 4 Finals MVPs to Kobe’s 2, more Finals appearances (10 vs. 7), and more playoff wins. If we’re measuring winning, why are you only counting championships
@TheSevenSermons@Ap3x16 Not just one category,
But if we’re evaluating winning, offense, defense, prime, peak, era dominance, and overall resume, how exactly is Kobe a lock over LeBron?
@TheSevenSermons@Ap3x16 First, nobody is arguing that career totals ALONE determine greatness. The Cliff Robinson vs. Kawhi comparison is a strawman. Kawhi having a better peak, playoff resume, and individual impact doesn’t mean career production is irrelevant. It means you evaluate the entire body.