I’ve never been more fearful about what the future of crypto might look like.
After the Binance hack, I took a day off to reflect on everything that’s happened over the last couple of years and the industry’s continuous quest to bring crypto mainstream.
One thing I couldn’t get out of my head is how most of the major crypto stories that make it beyond our little bubble are almost always negative.
Think about what the average person outside crypto has been exposed to.
They’ve heard about Logan Paul’s CryptoZoo scandal, Justin Bieber spending $2M on a Bored Ape that’s now worth around $10K, endless memecoin rugs, billions of dollars lost to hacks and exploits, and now another major security incident involving Binance.
The few times crypto makes mainstream headlines for something positive, it often comes with its own baggage. Trump’s memecoin was probably one of the biggest examples of crypto breaking into mainstream conversations, and we all know how that story unfolded.
I sometimes wonder what kind of impression all of this leaves on someone who has never interacted with crypto.
Imagine being an outsider. Every time you hear about this industry, someone has lost money, a project has rugged, an exchange has been hacked, or another high-profile individual has been caught up in some controversy.
At what point do you become comfortable putting your money into something like that?
This is what worries me about the whole mass adoption conversation.
We’ve spent years talking about bringing the next billion people into crypto, but I don’t think we spend enough time thinking about what those people currently associate with the industry.
Trust takes a long time to build, and unfortunately, it doesn’t take much to destroy it.
I honestly can’t say how we get past this or whether mass adoption is even possible with the level of fear and uncertainty surrounding the industry right now.
For now, a lot of what keeps people believing in crypto is hope that things will eventually get better.
And I hope that belief isn’t misplaced.
Introducing Pocket, the first-ever collection to live in your Apple or Google Wallet.
Pocket Pad is a marketplace built to set a new standard for digital ownership.
Touch grass later. This is going to change your world. 🧵
This shows how on-chain infrastructure is starting to attract attention from established financial institutions and investors.
The bigger opportunity is what happens when onchain infrastructure starts powering products people already want to use.
I am excited to be an investor in trade(xyz) as they partner with ICE to bring 24/7 perpetual futures on Hyperliquid to the United States. As a market participant, I am looking forward to to using their innovative product to enhance my investment process.
I think wallets becoming super apps is an interesting idea, but I have a slightly different view of where the real opportunity lies.
The part that interests me most is the amount of data a wallet can accumulate over time. It knows which assets you hold, which protocols you interact with, what you trade, how you move funds and, eventually, what your onchain behavior says about you as a user.
With enough data, a wallet could build a remarkably detailed picture of how people behave onchain. And I think this is where the real business opportunity lies.
Look at the AI industry. AI models are becoming part of people’s everyday lives, and every interaction creates opportunities to understand user preferences, behavior and intent. That information can become valuable to businesses looking to build better products, personalize their services or reach specific audiences.
Wallets could develop a similar position within crypto.
Imagine a wallet accumulating years of behavioral data across millions of users. DeFi protocols could use aggregated insights to understand user activity. Exchanges could identify different types of traders. Consumer apps could figure out which users are most likely to need their products. Institutions could use onchain behavioral patterns to build better risk models and financial services.
The wallet sits at the point where all these activities happen, which gives it a potentially valuable view of the market that individual applications may never have on their own.
IMO, this creates an opportunity for wallets to become data infrastructure for the entire crypto ecosystem. They could build the systems that collect, organize and interpret onchain behavior, then make useful insights available to businesses that know how to turn those insights into products and services.
And this is where I disagree slightly with the super-app thesis.
Building recommendations, social networks, reputation systems and dozens of other features might sound attractive, but each comes with its own product requirements, competition and execution challenges. A wallet trying to become everything risks spreading its resources across too many businesses.
We’ve seen this pattern repeatedly in Web3, where companies expand into every adjacent opportunity instead of strengthening the business they already have.
I think the bigger opportunity is for wallets to become exceptionally good at understanding onchain activity and building infrastructure around that knowledge. Other companies can build the recommendation engines, financial products and social experiences on top of it.
Of course, monetizing this data won’t be straightforward. Much of onchain activity is already public, and users will rightly care about privacy, consent and how their information is used. A wallet’s advantage would have to come from organizing that activity across users, interpreting it in context and making the resulting insights useful to businesses.
The wallet could become the institution that understands onchain behavior, while an entire ecosystem of companies builds businesses around that understanding.
That’s a business model I find much more compelling than every wallet competing to become the next super app.
wallets becoming super apps feels kinda inevitable from here imo
the wallet already knows what you own, what you use and eventually what your onchain reputation looks like
thats an insanely powerful distribution + personalization layer
it can:
- recommend apps based on your history
- give you advantages based on reputation
- connect you with people with same profile
basically becoming the homepage of crypto, personalized around you
A team can generate revenue, use a portion of it to purchase and burn tokens, and create a recurring source of buying pressure. Traders see this and begin pricing in future buybacks. Some will hold because they believe in the project, while others will hold because they expect the team to keep buying.
Both groups contribute to demand, but they are holding for different reasons.
And if the buyback becomes the primary reason people want the token, the team has created an expectation it must continue to satisfy. What happens when revenue declines, the market turns or the team decides that the money would be better spent on product development?
This is where I think the argument gets complicated.
Take Hyperliquid and HYPE, for example. Hyperliquid has built a highly competitive onchain perpetual futures exchange that generates substantial revenue from actual trading activity. The platform has demonstrated that people are willing to use its technology.
Yet the success of the exchange and the question of how much value should accrue to HYPE are two separate things. The buyback mechanism helps connect the economic activity of the platform to demand for its token, giving holders a reason to care about the revenue the business generates.
I understand why this makes sense. If a platform generates substantial revenue, holders naturally want to know how they benefit from that success.
But it also raises a question: how much of HYPE’s investment appeal comes from the platform’s technology, ecosystem and future potential, and how much comes from expectations surrounding future buybacks?
Those things can coexist. The existence of buybacks doesn’t mean HYPE holders lack conviction in the project. It simply means we should distinguish between demand driven by the product and demand driven by the token’s economic mechanism.
And to be clear, I don’t think teams should be allowed to generate revenue while ignoring the economic interests of their token holders indefinitely. If people provide capital and take on risk, they have every reason to question why the business is succeeding while the token struggles to capture any of that success.
However, I also think there is a danger in expecting every project to prove its commitment to holders through buybacks.
A new project needs room to experiment, find product-market fit and build something people genuinely want to use. If the team is already expected to dedicate revenue to buying tokens, that money comes with an opportunity cost. It could have gone towards hiring better developers, improving the product, attracting users or expanding the ecosystem.
The decision should depend on the stage of the project, the strength of its business and what it needs to accomplish next.
With the benefit of hindsight, I think the bigger question crypto needs to answer is how to create tokens that people have compelling reasons to own as the underlying technology becomes more useful.
Buybacks can be part of that answer. They can align incentives, create demand and return economic value to holders. But they can also attract capital that is primarily interested in the buyback itself.
For me, the goal should be to build projects where the technology creates real demand, the business generates sustainable revenue and the token has a credible way to capture some of that economic success.
The strongest position, IMO, is one where people have reasons to hold the token even when the team isn’t buying it.
That’s the kind of token economy I’d like to see more of in crypto.
I’ve been thinking about the whole debate around token buybacks, and I think both sides have a valid argument.
On one hand, holders want to see the projects they support return some of the value they help create. On the other hand, there are people who believe buybacks are a short-term mechanism that doesn’t necessarily contribute to the long-term success of a project.
IMO, the underlying issue is a lot more interesting than whether buybacks are good or bad.
One thing I’ve always found interesting about Ethereum and Solana is that their tokens have had years to develop their own economic roles through the growth of their respective ecosystems. ETH is used to pay for transactions and secure Ethereum through staking, while SOL is used to pay fees and participate in Solana’s network economy.
Both networks have managed to attract users, developers and capital without making recurring revenue-funded token buybacks the central reason to hold their tokens.
Imagine if these networks had started with a buyback mechanism as a core part of their investment thesis. Would people have spent as much time exploring what they could build on these networks, or would a larger part of the conversation have revolved around how much revenue was being generated and how many tokens were being bought and burned?
Obviously, we can’t know the answer. But I think it’s worth asking whether introducing buybacks too early can influence the kind of people a project attracts before its technology has had enough time to prove itself.
This brings me to what I consider the biggest problem with buybacks.