Treating everyone the same way is unconstitutional discrimination. That's what the Supreme Court of Canada says. Some groups are entitled to better terms than others.
My latest for @nationalpost:
https://t.co/Wg4JuDb2FC
Our next entry in our series on the worst Supreme Court decisions comes from @PardyBruce who takes apart the court's Sec 15 reasoning.
Supreme Errors: That time the court said it was unconstitutional to give women the same pension as men https://t.co/TyKd8iYW3I
@colbycosh@CarsonJerema The court interprets the meaning of the constitution. Parliament doesn't get to direct the court in that exercise. The legislation could, however, invoke the Notwithstanding clause to avoid the application of s. 15.
@colbycosh@CarsonJerema That's the way it reads. But thanks to the SCC, that's not what it means. The court has long insisted that section 15(1) and (2) together require substantive equality, otherwise known as equity. Which means some groups have the right to have more preferable or lenient standards.
"Smith said [the Alberta Bill of Rights] would guarantee property rights, protect firearm owners and prohibit vaccine mandates. But the bill does not do these things. Instead, its compromising language enables government action at every turn."
Free Speech Union of Canada Board Member @PardyBruce for the @nationalpost: https://t.co/OWDD9SddjS
Alberta’s ongoing beef has been “neutered.”
Albertans threw away the one card that actually forced Ottawa to listen.
Inside the province the 25% who wanted an independence vote isn’t going away. Expect lasting trouble for Danielle Smith and the UCP.
NEW from @PardyBruce via @WesternStandard:
https://t.co/KZwVSoE9oa
#Alberta #Ottawa #OilAndGas #AlbertaIndependence
This is why, for example, universities can't be fixed by exhortations about "academic freedom" or "institutional neutrality".
Most of the people who get into the academic pipeline are believers.
Recently I told you there are two kinds of people in this system: cynics and believers.
Ursula von der Leyen, I put her with the believers. And that's exactly why you need to understand how the machine works.
Because cynics are very rare. Soros, I put him in that category: he knows exactly what he's doing, and he has never hidden it.
He read Popper, he has a theory of change, and he understood early on something the right still hasn't figured out: you don't change a society by winning an election. You change it by funding, for thirty years, the people who will write the reports, train the lawyers, and advise whoever wins the elections.
$24 billion spent by Open Society since its creation. More than 50,000 grants. In 2015, he wrote in plain text that the EU must accept at least a million asylum seekers a year, and mobilize NGOs, churches and businesses to take them in.
All of it is public. That's the most impressive part.
Here's how the system got hacked, in three steps.
Step one: selection.
Nobody recruits idiots. No need. The money does the selecting on its own.
A grant never goes to the person who doubts. It goes to the person who already believes. Repeat that over thirty years and tens of thousands of grants, and you get an entire ecosystem where the free thinker was filtered out at the door. He wasn't fired. He just never got funded.
What's left: people who are sincere, credentialed, conformist, and whose paycheck depends on the cause.
Step two: funding manufactures conviction.
Try explaining something to someone whose paycheck depends on not getting it.
The NGO produces a report. The report gets cited by an expert. The expert testifies before the Commission. The Commission turns it into a directive. And the NGO guy ends up in a cabinet, then goes back to a foundation.
Everyone knows each other, cites each other, funds each other. It's an echo chamber with a budget.
Step three: emotion.
You never debate results. You debate intentions.
One photo beats a thousand statistics. Every objection backed by numbers becomes a moral failing. And when reality contradicts the narrative, the dissonance always gets resolved the same way:
"It's a necessary evil."
"It's collateral damage."
"The real problem is elsewhere."
Immigration is never a problem. The problem is your perception.
The result: the system doesn't produce corrupt people. It produces NPCs. People reciting a script while convinced they wrote it themselves.
Ursula doesn't need to be bought. She has spent her entire career in an environment where every expert, every report, every "civil society" group tells her the same thing. She is convinced she's on the side of good. And that's what makes her immune to facts.
And the best part of the story: Soros isn't even the system's biggest funder anymore.
You are.
Between 2021 and 2023, €7.4 billion in EU funds went to more than 12,000 NGOs. The European Court of Auditors itself says it can't get a reliable picture of who gets what.
The hack worked so well that the machine now runs on your taxes.
This is not a conspiracy. A conspiracy hides. Here, the amounts are public, the op-eds are public, the recipients are public.
It's an incentive system. And you don't fight an incentive system by insulting the believers. You fight it by cutting off the tap and demanding total transparency: who funds whom, to say what.
As long as it stays opaque, they'll keep shipping believers at scale.
@kpssreality They should end all of it. Why are taxpayers subsidizing the education and salaries of an elite? But that would require changing the model - not just of universities, but of government.
“The question has been asked and answered: will you stay in Canada no matter what? Three-quarters of Alberta’s voters, with Danielle Smith’s help, have surrendered the card without a fight. It’s a heck of a negotiating strategy.”
Bruce, “stay in Canada no matter what” is Smith’s interpretation of the result, which fits with her longstanding position of her having “no or else” in mind, regardless of how badly Alberta is treated by Ottawa. A pathetic position to have.
Many among the 75% may be unsatisfied with Canada and not necessarily committed to remaining “no matter what”, but were bamboozled by Smith into thinking that she could bring about change by remaining in Canada. As you mentioned, they bought into the “fix” that Smith put in.
https://t.co/0m9dWSDynQ
@nualanichols@WesternStandard Part of the plot. An actual independence question would have had to be clear to amount to a mandate for independence. But “a vote for a vote”could be unclear and yet be used as a mandate against independence. The referendum was a fix.
More sleight of hand by Premier Smith aka Arctic Hillary.
Thanks to @PardyBruce for the analysis.
The Premier is clearly beholden to special interests & not her base.
Feel free to gently fan yourself to help get over the shock.