@offgunlovesme I don’t think I understand the point you’re trying to make? Yes, I agree, in real life the term “dubious consent” doesn’t work, that’s just rape. But that’s not what I was talking about. When I read the update the fic was still tagged “no archive warnings apply” and “explicit
some thoughts on no attachments ch. 17 and the conversation around it. this is not to tell anyone how to feel, just working through my own thoughts.
cw: discussion of sexual coercion / non-con, mentions of past abuse.
@alienxsung has happened! Good! Unfortunately some harm was already done as well, and everyone’s gotta decide for themselves how they feel about that and what they will do about it. My response was to write a twitter dissertation I guess 😂
@alienxsung No I think I understand. One of my degrees is in Gender & Sexuality studies and we talked and read a lot about “grey sex” and models of consent - that’s why I said I think the writing was actually pretty good. The tagging of it was not and needed to be improved, which it seems
@hanisabobapearl And that’s more of an opinion about the writing quality, which can absolutely be discussed! Personally I don’t have a horse in that race, my problem was with the (lack of) tagging specifically, which the author seems to have fixed?
@alienxsung because I read fics for different reasons than I read novels, personal essays, or academic papers (I read. a lot.) and I want to know those details ahead of time. Not everyone feels that way, and that’s fine too
@alienxsung Yeah, and I think to an extent that’s a personal comfort zone thing. Authors have the option to use “creator chose not to use archive warnings” to avoid spoilers on topics like rape and MCD, and they should use it if they want. I personally don’t usually read fics with that tag
@AuroraInTheRoom That’s exactly my point - I actually think it was written well, I just read it before the tags were updated and was surprised it went that far, and felt uncomfortable because it’s a sensitive topic for me. My issue is not with the writer or the fic! Just with the tag situation
@hanisabobapearl That’s similar to my perspective, and I’m wondering if the author changed how they were viewing the relationship/situation as they wrote and adjusted accordingly. Which is fine! I just didn’t feel good reading that because I was surprised and it’s a sensitive topic for me.
@DaughterJohns I’m going to assume you meant this in good faith rather than looking for an argument and respond as such - and I agree with you! I think it’s well written and engaged with the topic at hand in a meaningful way. And as I said in my original post, did notice he was being pushy in a
@alienxsung coercion” meant between the main characters of the fic, and maybe that’s on me! At the same time, I’m clearly not the only one that felt a little blindsided, and I think it’s a helpful reminder for any authors considering writing such topics to tag appropriately if possible.
@alienxsung going when they’re writing! What frustrated me was that I took the tags of “no archive warnings apply” and “explicit consent” at face value, and then they were not updated before I read the new chapter. I did read the disclaimer and did not assume “detailed discussions of
@alienxsung I agree, some people are going to engage in bad faith regardless unfortunately. And I don’t want anyone attacking the author or saying they’re a terrible person, I hate that I’m saying that! People should write what they want, or change their minds about the direction a story was
@DaughterJohns My apologies if this came across as getting on a soapbox - I just haven’t seen a lot of good faith discussion about this situation, and to me it reflects a recent trend of authors and readers being antagonistic towards each other and assuming bad faith, which I don’t like to see.
@DaughterJohns space such as AO3 built on tagging for content warnings. The author is not an evil person for not tagging properly at first, and a reader is not an evil person for deciding that made them uncomfortable and they don’t wish to continue with the fic.