#Freicoin is one of the most underrated experiments in crypto and in many ways it tackles problems Bitcoin can’t or doesn’t want to touch in my opinion.
Here’s why the Freicoin design is still fascinating for me:
➕ Demurrage
Freicoin applies a small negative interest to idle coins. Sounds scary at first, but it solves a real problem: money should circulate, not sit in cold wallets forever. This pushes capital into productive use instead of endless hoarding
➕ Continuous funding for miners
Unlike Bitcoin, which relies on a subsidy that trends to zero, Freicoin redirects demurrage fees to miners. A long-term, self-sustaining security model... not dependent on unpredictable fee markets
➕ Stronger economic incentives
Demurrage encourages real economic activity: spending, lending, building, investing. Money becomes a tool not a trophy
➕ Fairer distribution & less plutocracy
Hoarding becomes costly. Influence comes from participation not passive accumulation
➕ Gesell-style monetary design
Inspired by Silvio Gesell, Freicoin blends crypto with an economic philosophy focused on velocity and economic health... something Bitcoin intentionally avoids
But there are also disadvantages:
➖ Psychological resistance
People hate the idea of “losing X%,” even if the system benefits. The term “negative interest” triggers strong emotional reactions many instantly associate it with state intervention, central-bank policy, or even “communism.” ...this makes it harder to communicate that Freicoin’s demurrage is fully algorithmic, decentralized, and not controlled by any authority. Optics matter
➖ Bitcoin culture is anti-demurrage
“Number go up” and “never sell” dominate crypto. Freicoin goes the opposite way
➖ Communication is harder
Explaining demurrage is more complex than explaining a fixed cap
➖ Store-of-value trade-off
If saving is your only goal, demurrage feels like a penalty
My personal note:
It honestly took me a long time to understand all this.
What really pushed me into researching Freicoin deeply was discovering the local Chiemgauer a regional currency from 2003, originally created as a student project, using the same principle of demurrage. That was the moment I realized how powerful (and misunderstood) this mechanism really is
So what do you think... do these advantages outweigh the trade-offs or is demurrage fundamentally incompatible with crypto? Curious to hear your view...
I may have moved away from the Chiemgau region but I haven't moved away from its values.
The Chiemgauer is more than a demurrage currency. It's about local strength, trust and people taking responsibility for their community even if it has drawbacks for sure.
Money should serve people, not the other way around.
I’m proud to have been part of it. And I still believe in what it stands for.
People in the Middle Ages built cathedrals over generations because they expected institutions to outlive them. Modern civilization struggles to plan beyond a quarterly earnings report.
Maybe our biggest technological bottleneck isn't engineering... it's rebuilding institutions that can think in centuries.
When talking about Bitcoin and hard money I think the idea of demurrage is worth looking into as well. It goes back to Silvio Gesell and is basically about money slowly losing a small part of its value over time. The idea is to make holding money less attractive and give people more incentive to spend invest and put their capital to work instead of just sitting on it. This could mean more money flowing into businesses new ideas and productive projects which might benefit the wider economy. Of course there are downsides too. It can punish saving lead to bad investment decisions and raises questions about who controls the system. But the concept makes you think: should money mainly reward people for holding on to it or should it encourage people to put it to work? Hard money rewards holding. Demurrage rewards circulation. Both have their trade-offs.
@_Phil_Wilson_ Absolutely legendary!
I feel the same way as when I pulled out my C64 after almost 40 years and fired up Summer Games or Bubble Bobble again... at least that Games still work.
This morning we are releasing the largest proof in the history of mathematics: A formalization of the Classification of Finite Simple Groups (CFSG)! Over 43 million lines of Lean, 715 papers and books, and 100 substantive fixes to the literature, this is truly an enormous theorem. Well done team!
Mathematicians: How do you dare releasing such terrible AI-written proofs before humans checked them!
Also mathematicians: Release the proofs immediately!
The Wära was a German demurrage currency, introduced in 1929 during the Great Depression to help restart a struggling economy.
It lost about 1% of its value each month if not used, encouraging people to spend it.
It worked locally, but the German authorities banned it in 1931 because it operated outside the official currency system.
#Freicoin is one of the most underrated experiments in crypto and in many ways it tackles problems Bitcoin can’t or doesn’t want to touch in my opinion.
Here’s why the Freicoin design is still fascinating for me:
➕ Demurrage
Freicoin applies a small negative interest to idle coins. Sounds scary at first, but it solves a real problem: money should circulate, not sit in cold wallets forever. This pushes capital into productive use instead of endless hoarding
➕ Continuous funding for miners
Unlike Bitcoin, which relies on a subsidy that trends to zero, Freicoin redirects demurrage fees to miners. A long-term, self-sustaining security model... not dependent on unpredictable fee markets
➕ Stronger economic incentives
Demurrage encourages real economic activity: spending, lending, building, investing. Money becomes a tool not a trophy
➕ Fairer distribution & less plutocracy
Hoarding becomes costly. Influence comes from participation not passive accumulation
➕ Gesell-style monetary design
Inspired by Silvio Gesell, Freicoin blends crypto with an economic philosophy focused on velocity and economic health... something Bitcoin intentionally avoids
But there are also disadvantages:
➖ Psychological resistance
People hate the idea of “losing X%,” even if the system benefits. The term “negative interest” triggers strong emotional reactions many instantly associate it with state intervention, central-bank policy, or even “communism.” ...this makes it harder to communicate that Freicoin’s demurrage is fully algorithmic, decentralized, and not controlled by any authority. Optics matter
➖ Bitcoin culture is anti-demurrage
“Number go up” and “never sell” dominate crypto. Freicoin goes the opposite way
➖ Communication is harder
Explaining demurrage is more complex than explaining a fixed cap
➖ Store-of-value trade-off
If saving is your only goal, demurrage feels like a penalty
My personal note:
It honestly took me a long time to understand all this.
What really pushed me into researching Freicoin deeply was discovering the local Chiemgauer a regional currency from 2003, originally created as a student project, using the same principle of demurrage. That was the moment I realized how powerful (and misunderstood) this mechanism really is
So what do you think... do these advantages outweigh the trade-offs or is demurrage fundamentally incompatible with crypto? Curious to hear your view...
"Schuster bleib bei deinen Leisten"
It reminds me to stay within my area of expertise and avoid judging matters I don't truly understand. Even after 30 years working in the fields I know best, I'm still learning every day and I'm still wrong more often than I'd like to admit.