My piece offers something like this: we may need to ask not only what these services accomplish, but whether the same support could be delivered differently, what opportunity costs this model entails, how sustainable it is, and what different approaches we may be overlooking
6/6
4/4 Rather than assuming the answer is more spending and regulation, we should ask whether existing rules and spending are adding to the problem, and which interventions could safely go first.
1/4 The 4-month wait in the ABH report is a self-reported average from 62 MassHealth-contracted clinics—and only those that couldn’t see kids right away. It’s far from a reliable measure of what most Massachusetts children wait for mental health care.
Kids in Massachusetts who need mental health care are waiting four months or more just to be seen.
This report shows why. Our community clinics are losing money and losing staff. 79% are in the red or barely breaking even. For every 10 clinicians they hired in 2024, 29 left.
Massachusetts is doing more than many states. Washington has to step up too.
➡️Protect Medicaid, the largest payer of mental health care for kids
➡️Invest in clinics families rely on
➡️Grow the pipeline so good therapists stay in community care
Our kids shouldn’t have to wait for help.
https://t.co/6jA8cWMXYh
My piece offers something like this: we may need to ask not only what these services accomplish, but whether the same support could be delivered differently, what opportunity costs this model entails, how sustainable it is, and what different approaches we may be overlooking
6/6
@CarolynGorman_ ok but could there be other positive outcomes? how about people in crisis who get connected to services by calling 988? hard to measure.
And human behavioral health clinical capacity is already supply constrained, so it seems important be especially careful about programs that draw on scarce workforce capacity or redirect resources away from other forms of care.
5/6
@DrJGiddensRN@988Lifeline That seems like a clear picture of the realities many people report while navigating fragmented behavioral-health and social-service systems.
Those needs deserve real solutions.
I wonder about a change in scope, too, and which needs might be better served by other institutions.
Suicide prevention hotlines are great in theory but in practice do not seem to reduce suicide rates & they rob precious $$s & staff from desperately underfunded treatment services that would do more good.
4 years ago the 988 National Suicide Prevention Hotline was rolled out to great fanfare.
$4 billion later, the effects appear to be a resounding ..."womp womp."
An NBER working paper finds that hotline operations have been substantially expanded, but nonetheless saw no detectable reduction in suicide mortality, per @PatrickNDempsey, who has firsthand experience at a call center.
No improvements were found in other population mental health outcomes, either.
It's been an earnest effort, but fed and state govt's must acknowledge the evidence and redirect attention and funding toward other potential solutions that could be more effective.
Impressive of Dempsey to take such a clear-eyed view.
https://t.co/6BrWQZj9sc
988 has scaled fast, but the strongest study so far finds no detectable drop in mortality. I’m not arguing to shut it down tomorrow; people rely on it and many get real relief. But it’s very resource-intensive, with big opportunity costs. #HealthPolicy#MentalHealth
The government’s 988 line was created as a hot line to prevent suicides. While the intentions behind it might be good, there is no evidence that it actually succeeds in reducing the number of people who take their own lives. | Patrick N. Dempsey
https://t.co/NHP3NtqOoT
The tax exclusion for employer-sponsored health insurance distorts healthcare for everyone, but it has particularly bad effects for individuals who seek care in the area of behavioral health. https://t.co/J8ZGlIe45d
My latest op-ed is out.
IL will be trying to expand behavioral health care access for some by imposing reimbursement floors on many commercial plans.
This will backfire. There are better ways to do this without creating so many harms and distortions.
https://t.co/y03yhICwrf