Faith, history, culture and the human condition. Observations, essays, book reviews and occasional prayers. A Christian perspective on a complicated world.
Today is the International Day of Prayer for the Persecuted Church.
For many Christians, publicly professing their faith carries consequences far beyond an uncomfortable conversation.
Worth remembering when we mistake disagreement for persecution (and when genuine persecution barely makes the news)
https://t.co/GmESCDLw1k
After years of treating Christianity as a Republican electoral asset, Democrats have discovered that Christians can also vote Democrat.
An intriguing development. Though the more interesting question remains whether either party is prepared to have its politics corrected by Christianity.
Source: https://t.co/vS4gNyG2b1
I’d encourage you to follow the scholarship on any seeming discrepancies. Most of the time, things seem inconsistent because we’re reading them through 21st-century Western assumptions. It takes a bit of work to understand ancient Jewish and Greco-Roman literary styles. In 2,000 years, the way we write today will probably seem just as unfamiliar!
Keen to understand what it means to be a particle of a supreme being, and what books or people you’re getting that information from?
Sure, if @gavinortlund made an absolute claim, one counterexample would be enough to disprove that specific point and call his use of Hurtado into question.
But to be precise. Are you saying Gavin claimed there was absolutely no evidence of Christians invoking deceased saints in the first 200 years, or no evidence of Jewish appeals to angels and other heavenly figures?
And are you saying Hurtado actually affirmed historical evidence contradicting either claim? Your screenshot shows scholars debating how certain Jewish traditions should be interpreted. It doesn’t establish that Hurtado accepted these as historical practices, or that he acknowledged early Christian invocation of deceased saints.
And even if you establish that Gavin was wrong on this particular point, that’s still a long way from demonstrating your broader accusation that he has a pattern of misrepresenting scholarship to defend Protestant positions.
Once upon a time, Billy Graham got a speeding ticket.
He showed up to court and experienced the most unexpected lesson that mirrors the gospel.
(Shout out to my friend Pastor @Ed_Newton who I heard this illustration from last week!)
Some, sure. But most I’ve seen do the hard work of studying the text before reaching conclusions. I’ve yet to find a serious inconsistency. Happy for you to share any - the example above is quite basic.
What I see more often is people rejecting Christianity first, then accepting any weak argument that tells them they were right. That’s confirmation bias, not critical thinking.
@Brcremer Sounds like the PR material for a particular party. Though one would be hard-pressed to find a party that actually does all this, rather than simply claiming these values when it suits them to one-up the other side.
Yes, absolutely. We should avoid blanket judgments. There are positive testimonies alongside deeply troubling ones, suggesting that some nuns provided genuine care while others may have contributed to the suffering.
But these things can all be true at once: the council failed in its responsibilities, some nuns cared well for the children, others did not, and the Bon Secours Sisters themselves acknowledged their failures.
And taken together, the outcome was an appalling number of dead children. Whatever the distribution of responsibility, we should be going above and beyond to protect the vulnerable, not accepting such outcomes as an unfortunate consequence of difficult circumstances. That seems to be part of what the Sisters themselves recognised in their apology.
In Tuam, DNA is helping restore names to children whose lives ended in the care of a religious institution. 109 sets of infant remains have now been recovered.
There is something particularly horrifying about cruelty and neglect carried out under the banner of the very Jesus who welcomed children and warned against causing them harm.
May the surviving relatives find answers, justice and some measure of peace. Their loved ones deserved better, and their names deserve to be remembered.
Whether you're a Christian, a skeptic, or somewhere in between, we all live by stories.
The question is whether those stories can bear the weight of our lives.
The Stories We Live By invites readers to explore a story that is bigger, truer, and more beautiful.
Available now.
https://t.co/fPxt1GBdCN
—Michael Keller
I take your point about Galway County Council’s responsibility, and it’s an important distinction. But 978 child deaths were recorded at Tuam and its predecessor, with around 9,000 across the 18 institutions investigated nationally.
These deaths cannot simply be attributed to the religious orders, nor did the Bon Secours Sisters run all these homes. But it’s difficult to read their own admission that they failed to live up to their Christianity, failed to show compassion, and participated in the suffering of women and children, and conclude they bear no responsibility either.
https://t.co/ym78bNounf
There’s a wonderful irony in our search for the centre of the universe. Turns out, in a sense, we’re at the centre after all.
First, we thought Earth was the centre of everything. Then the Sun took centre stage, sitting still while the planets orbited it. Later, we discovered that the Sun itself is hurtling around the Milky Way, carrying the planets along, as this animation shared by @PhilosophyOfPhy illustrates.
Each discovery seemed to push us further from centre stage.
Then came relativity, challenging the idea of absolute position in space, and modern cosmology, revealing an extraordinary twist: the universe has no known privileged centre, yet every observer sits at the centre of their own observable universe.
So Earth is at the centre for us after all. Not because we’re special, but because the same is true for an observer anywhere else. Where you stand determines the centre of what you can observe.
We’ve come full circle, just not in the way anyone expected.
We were taught that Earth orbits the Sun in a closed circle. In reality, Earth has never returned to the same point in space once in 4.5 billion years.
Right now, the Sun is carrying Earth and every planet around the center of the Milky Way at 230 km/s (828,000 km/h), more than 18,000 kilometers every 80 seconds.
Because the Solar System is tilted 60.2° to the galactic plane and bobs up and down through the galactic disc roughly every 30 million years, the planets trace open 3D corkscrew helices across deep space rather than flat loops.
The last time the Sun stood where it stands today, one Galactic Year (230 million years) ago, the very first dinosaurs were only beginning to appear on Earth. Since forming 4.6 billion years ago, our Sun has completed only 20 laps.
Moral of the story: life is suffering, grief makes it worse, and love, kindness and relationships make it bearable enough to keep living until we die. All to make an ultimately meaningless existence a little more pleasant. Quite the uplifting philosophy, @rickygervais.
But what if, instead of that bleak view, grief hurts because love is real, people matter beyond the pleasure they bring us, and death is not simply an inconvenience to be made more bearable? Perhaps the things that make life worth living point to something bigger than life itself.
Even if we only considered secular historians, you’d still be going against the overwhelming scholarly consensus. So I’d expect your expertise and evidence to be pretty extraordinary.
What credentials or original research do you bring to the table? Or is this just another angry atheist making money telling other atheists what they want to hear?