that's where the philosophical disagreement comes in.
the main reason people are transphobic is because they reject the idea gender is a social construct and think evidence points to it being biologically essential.
trans people usually believe that gender is a subjective social construct and is determined by a combination of gender roles, attributes, and expectations placed on people depending on how they're assigned at birth which by standard is a baby's anatomy.
they therefore think gender identity, presentation, and roles can be experimented with, but most trans people have a "limit" to the degree in which someone can throw around labels (i.e. lesbian trans men or he/him lesbians).
some are more like me and share many beliefs with radical queer theories associated with anti-essentialism and gender peformativity which rejects the idea that shared categories have to share one essence and points to how gender is often treated as a natural concept that doesn't change because of how society can treat others.
transsexuals who don't want to be called transgender are almost always truscum that think people should experience gender dysphoria and distress about their sexual characterisrics and at least desire to physically transition if they're unable to. presentation as a man or a woman is very important to them and they tend to exclude many non-binary and gender non-conforming trans identities feeling they're giving the community a bad name and are pretending to be trans for one reason or another.
im a transsexual with gender and sex dysphoria. i experience dysphoria around my gender and my body and want to modify my sexual characteristics, but i dont think i can become the opposite sex.
i dont believe that being a transgender or transsexual can come from anything other than an intrinsic sense of self because while people /might/ dislike their bodies on a hypothetical island where there is no concept of gender, there's no evidence that the dislike would lead to a /gendered idea of dealing with that dysphoria/.
trans people who try to cling to bioessential and binary presentations for validation to distance themselves from the idea their transness isn't from the same subjective feelings as everyone else who is trans because society thinks that would /make more sense/ are simultaneously ignoring that they can't /fully assimilate/ into a cishetero gendered society without betraying the entire concept of trans by itself which subverts ideas of assimilation.
they're merely enforcing a cishetero gender binary, but in the "does everyone here think i look right" way with a trans flag in their bio.
@myxibii@coffinboiiii@bingbongscho@phrayanaga sex = sum of your primary and secondary sex characteristics
i can change some of my markers of sex, but not all of them.
many transsexuals like buck angel, even if i dont agree with him on most things, don't think we can become the opposite sex.
there has never been a clear definition of being transgender at any point in history.
it contains 100s of identities that differ in different cultures which is further proof of how subjective and intrinsic it is.
you may mistake a cis person presenting as gender non-forming for a different gender than they were assigned at birth. are they now trans?
are butch women who a regularly mistaken for men then men? what if she takes HRT and gets top surgery as some butches do, but doesn't claim to be a man. does she have to be a man despite being AFAB, growing up as a biological woman, and identifying as woman?
if you don't admit it's nothing more than a subjective identity based on an intrinsic and personal sense of self you reinforce conservative cisgender standards while also still not being able to meaningfully assimilate into them by the nature of being trans in itself unless you do everything you can, like this trans woman is doing now, to put other trans people under the bus and comply to some caricature feminine presentation of what women should look like.
it's insecurity, transphobia, and misogny combined.
that is not the case. trans people don't agree on what makes someone trans.
i think it's an intrinsic sense of self interacting with a sociocultural environment. there may be genetic predispositions that lead to people being more likely to be trans, but there is no trans gene, and it's rather a subjective identity influeced by the environment.
you thinking it's silly is exactly why trans people look even sillier when they try to say they are "real trans" people because they present a certain way.
it is impossible for it not to then mean being trans is nothing more than how you look, but that suggests cis people who are gender non-conforming aren't cis anymore.
its only logical if it's a /personal intrinsic sense of self/.
what does it mean to present as a woman? im a masc presenting transsexual man who has been on HRT for several years, but hasn't had a strong response to it.
if i wanted to dress in dresses and wear makeup for a year would i be a woman for that year or a trans man presenting as fem?
if cis women who don't present as feminine are women. what makes you a woman?
@moonmi5t@phrayanaga you're a trans woman aren't you? surely you can define what a girl is. if you can be trans and a woman. why can't he be trans and a man?
you both say you're binary and trans. he's taking HRT.
what makes you as a binary trans girl different?
@sexyIoserr@teddybear_blues it makes much more sense to be super careful and be very sure than it does to act on a pattern alone. the majority not doing so isn't indicative that we should copy them or forego things to keep life real and rational.
whatever that means.
@sexyIoserr@teddybear_blues it's kind of important when you're claiming that sapphic spaces are being overrun by a very specific and vulnerable community all unverified.
yes this is odd to do in your version of "the real word." you can't just name a group and throw them under the bus because you think so.
before you say it is important for communities to keep them safe.
of course. that's the part where our identity interacts with our sociocultural environment too.
how you feel can be true and it is also true that community specifics might exclude you.
sometimes reasonably and other times not. say if it was a public queer space versus spaces who are expecting certain presentations.
he isn't invalidating his own pronouns and gender. he actually made them his own if anything and is directly telling you who he is.
you are simply offended by how he is using labels because they "mean something" when the labels themselves don't mean much at all outside of the vacuum.
it's how we apply them and we can mix them anyway we please because it's about how people relate to these labels not about how you do.
you can say that's contradictory and doesn't make sense, but it doesn't have to, and if you knew his story maybe it would make more sense.
not all trans men are trans men for the same reasons and this doesn't invalidate other trans men at all when it's a personal identity. they don't reflect everyone.