I am stepping away from Twitter. The platform lacks compassion and is now tainted by hurtful values and behaviour, and I no longer wish to be part of it. Thank you for all the positive links made here – please follow me here: https://t.co/n8PSVmowbg
I've been invited to participate in this year's Maudsley Debate, supporting the notion: 'This House Believes that Biological Psychiatry has Failed to Deliver Significant Benefit for Patients'.
- Attendance is free - reserve your place below 👇
https://t.co/dvk03GB3DE
"I don’t just think antidepressants are overprescribed, I’m not convinced they’re useful at all. Antidepressants don’t rectify a chemical imbalance or any other biological process, as people were led to believe; they numb emotions"
"The question is, is this useful, and how harmful are they?" 👇
https://t.co/L4OybfIwGS
Was delighted to take part in @BBCRadio4 's Moral Maze this week, which interrogated the medicalisation of depression and distress. https://t.co/WirIN7MZ7j
The paperback of Chemically Imbalanced was released yesterday amid continuing debate about the never-ending rise in antidepressant prescriptions. I argue that medicalising misery is not supported by science and ultimately does more harm than good.
You may be sick of this by now, but it's also important.
I’ve written a Psychology Today piece that looks at the argument Moncrieff, Davies, Johnstone and I made in our recent BMJ response to the aftermath of the ADHD doc.
"ADHD is real” is not a scientific conclusion.
https://t.co/tcxEo0pzXX
The Royal College of Psychiatrists has now formally acknowledged what critics of psychiatric diagnosis have argued for years: people are made to experience problems caused by trauma as though those problems are “inherent to them", which “extends to..psychiatric diagnosis".
That is a big concession; it is an admission that diagnosis can relocate the meaning of suffering from relational & social adversity/trauma (what happened to a person) to what is supposedly wrong with the person (a hypothetical internal dysfunction).
Now that this has been admitted, the claim that psychiatric diagnosis is neutral or "atheoretical" is very hard to sustain.
Much more importantly, it has fully opened the domain of psychiatry to the non-medical forms of understanding that it has so often marginalised by conceding that the experiences gathered under psychiatric diagnoses need not originate in an "internal disorder" at all—indeed, this is why they have been marginalised for so long, because they challenge the medical status quo.
https://t.co/vkIOahGJ29
There is so much I want to say about this landmark apology and admission by the Royal College for Psychiatry, so I will make videos, blogs and record some audio explaining all of this - but for now - here is what you need to know:
1. Psychiatry has been pathologising victims of sexual abuse and child abuse since conception. Victims of abuse are one of the main targets of psychiatric intervention, personality disorder diagnoses and medications.
2. Psychiatrists have relied upon completely fabricated concepts such as ‘false memory syndrome’ for decades and these concepts have been used in family court and criminal court to discredit victims.
3. We now have an official apology and report from the College - admitting these failures and proposing new training and guidance for all psychiatrists and psychiatric services.
4. You can use this new report to challenge professionals and your own psychiatrist if your experience of sexual abuse was pathologised, or you or your children are being accused of having ‘false memory syndrome’.
5. The Royal College for Psychiatry has form for deleting, editing and changing things on their website (chemical imbalance myth, anyone?) so go and download this report now so you can retain the original in case it is ever removed or changed.
6. The RCP has a very very long way to go to address the harms and abuses caused by psychiatry towards victims of abuse - but this is an excellent start
'The experiences classified as ADHD are real and can be profoundly disabling, but the scientific.. status of ADHD as a unified neurodevelopmental disorder has not been demonstrated and remains open to legitimate question' @psychgeist52@JDaviesPhD https://t.co/jL19EeYWVx
Some quotes from this excellent @joannamoncrieff
essay on the @Channel4 ADHD doc:
"The neuro part of the ‘neurodevelopmental’ disorder is just a hypothesis & decades of research have not proven it to be correct..ADHD is a label we apply to a certain set of behaviours & experiences."
This is the simple, scientifically accurate fact.
"So the idea that ADHD presents differently in adults, or in women and girls, is actually nonsensical, because how it presents is what it is, and if it is different, it is not the same! That this is often said reflects how strongly the idea that ADHD represents a consistent, life-long brain condition underpins our current understanding of it."
This captures the fallible, self-confirming nature of psychiatric constructs, which incorporate contradiction and confusion rather than being revised or abandoned.
"Another explanation, which should surely be the default, is that people are different, some struggle more than most with various aspects of daily life and these difficulties may be exacerbated by the demands of the modern world (for organisation, promptness, focus etc)."
We do not need to ascribe to people unestablished neurological disorders in order to recognise that their distress and impairment are real or offer support and help.
"Parents need to be able to make properly informed decisions about what is best for their child. They should not be misled that ADHD is a brain condition that drug treatment can target and reverse, and they should be informed about what stimulants do."
https://t.co/2JrbpRfGxY
The huge increase in distress we have seen that accelerated with the pandemic must not be medicalised. We need to understand and address the social causes, not just medicate people and wipe our hands of it. https://t.co/jEWZwiEIEn
A helpful thread. It's important to realise that lots of things associated with ADHD affect the brain, including social deprivation: https://t.co/HuGNqg9oPG
Hence the subtle differences sometimes found in people with ADHD have not been shown to be due to ADHD itself.
@curioushaggis@joannamoncrieff There seems to be some confusion here. Of course all our behaviours and mental activities have correlates in our brains. But the point is the cluster of symptoms associated with the diagnosis is not necessarily *caused* by a brain disorder. There isn't enough evidence for that.
Sympathetic review of the Ch4 ADHD doc. Highlights the growing industry that is profiting from ADHD, and describes the conclusion of the programme that drug treatment should be a last resort as 'hardly radical'. https://t.co/OMPFgpIFwq
Beyond Medication: What England’s Experience Can Teach Us About Psychosis Care
By Alison Brabban
For over 20 years, NICE in England has recommended that people experiencing psychosis should be offered psychological therapy—not simply medication alone.
https://t.co/f3gyoYMQUc
For years, critics of psychiatry were told they were denying science. Now prominent psychiatrists concede that psychiatric diagnoses are not objective disorders discovered in nature.
So what now justifies psychiatry's jurisdiction over human suffering?
https://t.co/f7Hj4wHvug