🌝

[🌝 @petitgataeri]

ningning is only for hot girls

[gigisll @aerichanlove31]

to everyone making clips of Karina eating five tacos and Giselle only eating one, without giving the context that Giselle had already eaten hotpot before filming the content, while Karina hadn’t eaten anything that day. Please stop making clips that leave out important context

[🌝 @petitgataeri]

@mikasafavx They aren't even a Giselle stan, tard, they're an army. But Lillies are only brave enough to confront the fandom of 5th gen gg. When it comes to armys, y'all practically lick the ground they walk on in fear.

[SMTOWN @SMTOWNGLOBAL]

안녕하세요, SM엔터테인먼트입니다.

소속 아티스트 에스파 윈터를 대상으로 지속적으로 유포되고 있는 악의적인 게시물에 대해 강력한 법적 조치를 취할 것임을 엄중히 경고합니다.

현재 X(구 트위터), 인스타그램, 유튜브, 더쿠, 인스티즈, 디시인사이드, 여성시대, 네이트판 등 각종 플랫폼에서 아티스트에 대한 허위 사실 유포, 명예훼손, 모욕, 악의적인 비방 및 인신공격, 성희롱 등 위법한 게시물과 콘텐츠가 지속적으로 게재되고 있습니다. 이에 당사는 법무법인의 면밀한 검토를 거쳐 고소 등 법적 절차를 단계적으로 진행할 계획입니다.

아울러 당사는 위 언급된 플랫폼 외에도 익명 게시판이나 SNS 등에서 이루어지는 불법행위 역시 예외 없이 대응할 것이며, 국내외를 불문하고 게시물의 작성 및 유포 경로와 작성자 특정에 필요한 자료를 확보하여 관할 수사기관에 수사를 의뢰할 예정입니다. 적발되는 가해자에 대해서는 어떠한 선처나 합의 없이 무관용 원칙에 따라 강력한 법적 책임을 물을 것임을 거듭 강조하오니, 범죄 행위에 가담하는 일이 없도록 각별히 주의해 주시기 바랍니다.

당사는 'KWANGYA 119'를 통한 팬 여러분의 제보와 자체 모니터링을 통해 아티스트의 권익을 침해하는 모든 게시물 및 콘텐츠에 대한 자료를 수시로 수집∙확보하고 있으며, 앞으로도 소속 아티스트의 권익 보호를 위해 악성 게시물에 대한 법적 대응을 지속적으로 강화하겠습니다.

감사합니다.

🔗https://t.co/myV62vYiXn

[fml ⸆⸉ @ciwywfml]

BABI HAHAHAHAHAHA SO YOU WANT TO USE OTHER MEMBERS AFTER SHT TALK THEM BEFORE JUST TO TARGET ANOTHER😂😭 FAKE ASSHOLE😂

[⭑ @jentlelogy]

“That shave jaw” and then proceed to post a woman with a perfectly normal, sharp, defined jawline... The man you stan can’t relate, that’s why you’re mad 😭

[WhatGiselleWears @WhatGiselleWear]

TURNS A BLIND EYE TO THE INSULTS AND RUMORS TARGETING GISELLE 😂

GISELLE DESERVES BETTER.

#TREATGISELLEFAIRLY
#GISELLE_DESERVES_BETTER
@aespa_official @SMTOWNGLOBAL

[🅉🄴🄴 || 🆂🅰🅳🅳🅻🅴 🆄🅿 🐎🐎🐎 @MK0810_02]

I found it funny how it's the same people who insult other member and now using their name

[🐿️💨 @chaenglovesus]

giselle splitting the donut in half and sharing it with winter~

[지젤 ☽ @urmoon_aeri]

GISELLE will reportedly not renew her contract with SM Entertainment.

[🌝 @petitgataeri]

@mena01382 @ihygslle And this was supposed to be a defense? My point remains. The company continues to do nothing for the members, neither for Giselle nor Ningning, even with false allegations of p*do. Winter is doing the thing that SM should be doing for her and the others.

[. @ihygslle]

Giselle really shouldn't even renew after this seven years contract is over like this is so weird that company haven't move a finger for her

[rinnie 🪽 @synkangel]

10 writers working on ‘Natalie Portman’ for lesserafim as we speak

[aespa @aespa_official]

behind the scenes

#aespa #æspa #에스파
#NINGNING #닝닝

[🌝 @petitgataeri]

@succesugs @CMaduuh You're the one playing dumb, acting like you weren't trying to shift the blame for this ad onto Karina when she's not at fault. Even the person you replied to told you that the responsibility isn't hers. There's no point in trying to play dumb.

[🌝 @petitgataeri]

@succesugs @CMaduuh You're mentally challenged. Because your comment makes absolutely no sense in this situation. You're literally trying to shift the blame onto her. Don't play dumb, because nobody here is stupid except you 😭

[🌝 @petitgataeri]

@CMaduuh @yujitas Don't use the "but if it was..." card because your fanfom are literally doing this right now.

[🌝 @petitgataeri]

@succesugs @CMaduuh But in fact, it's not her fault. She's not the creative director of the ad. If you really care about the issue and look into it, you'll see that nobody besides armys are turning this into a kpop fan war.

[🌝 @petitgataeri]

@jky2kluv @deerkarina @rhysdia You're mentally challenged. Karina was just posing in sneakers. The end result was the creative director and editor's decision. She had no choice and no knowledge of it. Sydney read the script about white genes and accepted and made it. Two different cases.

[Mili 🩷 @aespology_]

You guys clearly don’t care about issues regarding racism and purely just see it as an opportunity to use it as gotcha moments. I don’t understand why you’re implying that Karina was at fault when she’s just a model and not on the creative team at all