@lefty_md all you people do is tell people to read. you can’t answer simple questions! ‘what should we do with a violent rapist’ is a question that would come to mind to anyone if you approached them with the topic of abolition!
@jacqka she’s very clearly talking about these ‘outliers’ you mention. but instead of hand waving them away she’s acknowledging that something will be need to be done with them
the first point is that the claim of abolitionists is that by removing sources of structural inequity we remove the source of power that enables much criminality and victimization
but day and others are pointing out that not every source of power is structural - some is biological, like adults power over children, or the strong over the weak, etc.
second is that a basic material analysis should include things like mental illnesses which contribute to violence and have biological origins that no economic system will be able to fully eliminate.
@cbarrett@FungibleWorker he was disagreeing with the claim that biology is ‘never a factor’. so he’s asserting it’s a factor amongst many, and even then only some of the time. try reading comprehension
one of the things it does is remove that person from society so the victim doesn’t have to live in constant fear that they will come back and offend them again. another is it establishes a precedent that if you rape or SA there will be people from the state to come and find you and take you away. we take these for granted but they’re not guarantees, in many societies now and in the past rapists do roam free and continually reoffend and children and women bore the brunt of that terror
fwiw, every state does have a victim compensation fund and things like anonymous rape hotlines, crisis hotlines, therapy etc. very inadequate but the machinery is there
there are ways to reduce violence and harm outside of criminal justice of course, but the point being argued here is that it will never eliminate it and that we need an enforcement corps and prison to protect people
rape and SA are not rare, about 1 in 6 state prisoners are currently serving time for it. its a huge chunk of the entire criminal justice apparatus
@PeninsulaBrain@asubtlergin if you think the majority of CSA takes place in churches or by teachers then we can stop here, you simply don’t know what you’re talking about. the vast majority is within the family or step-family
@PeninsulaBrain@asubtlergin there are almost a quarter million people in state prisons for rape and SA. i promise you they’re not all catholic bishops or cops. they are mostly normal people who abused a child or romantic partner
ok, so following a rape the society should re-educate the rapist and continue to monitor them. that seems wildly inadequate and doesnt really take the victim serious but regardless - what happens if they re-offend? more education? i genuinely want to know what your thoughts are here
and i don’t think vaguely gesturing at ‘whatever people need to repair’ is a serious attempt here
@blackhawk_exile you people find every possible reason to dodge questions and refuse to articulate your beliefs. the worst thing meagan did was write something longer than a snarky tweet
@PeninsulaBrain@asubtlergin it’s not rare. 1 in 6 state prisoners are serving time for rape or SA. why do you feel the need to discount the amount of sexual violence that gets prepretrated against women