🩸THIS DREADFUL PLACE🩸
Brynn never thought she'd want her old life back. But when she appears centuries after her time in a divided world where one side wants to kill her and the other to use her, she'll do whatever it takes to go home. #PitLight
Comp titles are a pain. Like, we already hate writing query letters. Having to choose actual existing books that capture the essence of our manuscript just makes the whole process even more miserable.
Despite the misery, there are some things you can do to ensure that your comps are actually helpful for agents:
Tip #1: Understand the POINT of Comps
It will simplify the process if you know what agents are thinking when reading your comp titles. It's basically two things: 1.) "If I'm going to sell this to publishers, do these comps give me a clear idea of what kind of book I might be selling?" and 2.) "Does the author understand the industry enough to know how their book fits into it?"
That's pretty much it. They can get a sense of the concept through the pitch itself, and they can decide for themselves if it has the potential to be a runaway hit. Pick comps that give agents what they're actually looking for, and you'll save yourself a ton of headaches.
Tip #2: Read Widely in Your Genre
The more books you read in your genre (RECENT books, especially), the more you're going to have a sense of what's been selling and how your book might compare.
I always tell writers to make sure that at least ONE of their comps is a book published in the past three years. If you're going to do that, you should be reading recently published books in your genre.
Tip #3: Be Reasonable
I have seen The Fourth Wing used as a comp title probably twenty times since the summer, so I'm SURE that agents--who read hundreds to thousands of queries each month--are seeing that title used even more than I am.
The Fourth Wing has been on the NYT hardcover fiction list for 73 weeks. I love every single one of you, but the chance of your book repeating that success is almost zero. Try to pick comps from the mid-list--something successful and well-reviewed, but maybe a little south of the best-selling fantasy book of the past two years.
Tip #4: Simplify the "Why"
Many authors include not only the comp titles but also detailed explanations as to why they those comp titles. These explanations can get complicated, though, breaking down themes and characters and plot structures like it's a high school literary analysis essay.
A little explanation is okay, but don't overdo it. You've got precious little real estate in your query letter to sell YOUR book. Don't spend too much of it talking about OTHER PEOPLE'S books!
Tip #5: Ethical Help from A.I.
Like all authors, I despise generative A.I. when it comes to people creating art and literature. There are, however, some ethical ways to use generative A.I. that can help you brainstorm comp titles. Basically, you can use it as a custom Google search to compile a list of potentially similar books for you to explore.
Write a prompt that asks for books published in your genre over the past three years. Ask for titles that were not best-sellers, and clarify that you'd like to see titles that share some important aspects of your own book. Themes are a great place to start, but you could do settings, types of conflicts, character traits, etc.
Once you've got a list, you can pick out a few that you'd like to read in more detail to see if they'll work. It's a great way to get started if you're stuck and have NO clue where to even begin.
***
Most importantly, don't stress TOO much about these comps. Having talked to plenty of agents, I can tell you with certainty that they care most about a unique and interesting concept with clear, exciting stakes. I promise that's what is carrying 90% of the weight in these letters.
Comps are a teeny part of the equation. They're basically just garnish, like parsley. They matter for presentation, but they aren't the main course :)
heres the thing, some books dont have comps. most books i sell, there arent accurate comps. they're bipoc, queer, marginalized authors writing books i cant always find comps for
so if you can't think of a specific book, instead say it'll appeal to fans of x
#amquerying writers with low or no success wondering if it’s the timing or your work? In the last few weeks, I completed 50 opening pages reviews and found that most of them needed moderate to significant development. Reflections below ⬇️ 1/7 #WritingCommunity
There has got to be a better way to query.
🤯paste 5 pages, attach 30 pages, email me the first 4.5 chapters and a 500 words synopsis, pitch your MS in 1 line, or 2 lines, or a paragraph, name your files In This ExacT FormaT.
Only to be form rejected 7 months later 🫠
#amquerying
Hi agents!
I’ve got a twisted Beauty & the Beast retelling where both characters are cursed. It’s packed with depression, forced proximity, betrayal, & survival
If you like This Woven Kingdom x Violet Made of Thorns x The Hedgewitch of Foxhall, this one’s for you!
#amquerying
Hi friends!!
I have a friend who is interested in joining a discord server for writers to see if they can find a small critique group to work with!
Any leads would be helpful!!!
It's both Hoodoo Heratige Month and Black Speculative Fiction Month and fam, I got you. Check out my novelette in All These Sunken Souls for The Conjure Woman.
I was so fortunate to have the amazing @KathrynHAuthor look over some of my writing, and her feedback and suggestions were so incredibly helpful and uplifting. If anyone is in need of a brilliant editor, I highly recommend reaching out to her. 🤩 Thanks again, Kathryn! ❤️
seen a lot of ppl recommend the locked tomb and others ask what to read if they’ve already read it, so i present: some sapphic sff recs to read if you’ve already read gideon the ninth
@RowanBrightonB Try to observe your work patterns: is it a continous flow or spikes? Are certain times of day better for you? Adjust accordingly! It's more rewarding than fighting it all the time.
Both of us are nd and know how hard it can be, so best of luck and feel free to reach out!
As far as we're concerned, her feedback is already helping us improve so...you should consider giving her a follow and checking out her website https://t.co/GMutqHNzgW
Thank you so much to @KathrynHAuthor !!! Just got her feedback and she's completely amazing!
Kathryn doesn't hold back on what she has to say and it feels really good to have some clear advice to follow.