@Hdj6682@MLBPipeline@Cardinals@memphisredbirds Has nothing to do with his clock and everything to do with the fact that he can’t hit a high fastball, can’t make contact on in zone pitches nearly enough, can’t get on base, and hit .180 in July. He’s not ready
@thatsawinner15@BaseballWRLD_ This season yes, he’s been hit 10 more times this year than last year in 1 less game, but he’s also drawn 8 more walks so far (played 107 last year, 106 so far this year) he’s legit pretty good at getting on base.
@TheRedbirdWay@The_Ryan_Shull I was on that train in June, but July has shown he’s not ready. He still has to work on his game and exposing him to mlb pitching at this point would further set him back. Plus the uncertainty around next is even more reason to leave him in the minors for the rest of the year
@TheRedbirdWay@The_Ryan_Shull Not even trying to be funny but have you not heard how things are going for Baez? In zone contact is abysmal, chase rate, can’t hit high fastball. He has a severe hole in his swing and is hitting 186 in July. He’s nowhere close to promotion
@TheRedbirdWay@The_Ryan_Shull You can’t ever have enough pitching but the cardinals have so much pitching talent close to graduating. Our bigger need is lineup pieces. I don’t see who in the next 2 years would be up with us that would result in Herrera not being in the every day lineup.
@rustyhaiz@TheRedbirdWay@The_Ryan_Shull Only would say this when view form the lens of a cardinals fan. Herrera is in the 80 percentile in batting value during a down year with multiple years of control left. Add to it he’s a rhb which is the most desired thing in baseball right now…he’d get a pretty good return
@kyler416@TortsIllustrtd Agreed. Even if we take him out of the catcher conversation (I’m not yet) who the hell deserves the at bats more than him at DH. Therefore there’s zero crunch on playing time
@vancemeek@kennygsbuttplug The position they play is the “replacement” part of “wins above replacement”…removing defense from the equation and you can replace Sal with half the leagues First basemen and be better off. You can only say that about a few 2B with regards to JJ
@vancemeek@kennygsbuttplug your mind can’t be changed, but wanted to chime in. WAR is not the end all be all, but please
1. look at the OPS+, essentially the same hitter
2. Look at other 1B and look at other 2B. Their value is partly tied to position. JJ 4th best off 2B, Sal middle of the road off 1B
@trey_feathers4@jmjones Don’t want triple lefties at the top of the order (would be 4 in a row counting 9 hole) even if walker 3 and burly 4 you’re still looking at 3 lefties in a row with crooks batting 9th. We have way too many LH bats
@sor13ss@p_bo68@fashion_nfl And they have the worst white out look as well. Kept yellow striping on jersey and pants just to have zero yellow on the helmet. Can’t leave the middle stripe white in that situation
@gregpats04@Cream_Friche Have u looked at walkers sprint speed and his arm strength? People get lost in the fact that he’s 6’5, he’s a legit 4/5 tool guy (kind of hard to give him fielding)
@SuckervilleCity@JeffMcDev In the semifinals Schwarber also got a white ball, the commentators talked about it and you could hear Schwarber talk about with his pitcher afterwards
@maxb9506@PatrickKaplan13@MLB@Cardinals I’m a Herrera fan, I’m just saying if you could include non DH options Herrera does not deserve it over several other guys. JJW, Michael Harris etc
@PatrickKaplan13@MLB@Cardinals 1. It had to be a DH
2. Herrera doesn’t deserve it
3. You’re really arguing for a guy that has .1 more WAR and only 1 point higher in OPS+