I enjoyed arguing in the Seventh Circuit yesterday on the question whether Illinois's ban on firearm suppressors implicates the plain text of the Second Amendment. Thanks to NIU College of Law for hosting the sitting.
@MorosKostas Note that Mascott gives a preview of the Court's ruling in Williams: "And today, this Court holds in Williams that driving while intoxicated two decades ago does not constitute that kind of ongoing, present threat of violence either."
My seven-year-old sent you a card in the mail to autograph and I believe you sent it back, but the envelope was ripped open and empty - someone must have stolen it. Just thought you may want to know!
New #FirstAmendment case from the Ninth Circuit
May @X sue a nonprofit hate-speech monitor for scraping public posts and publishing reports that drove away advertisers? https://t.co/USE9CK6SRP
I was pleased to present argument on behalf of X in the Ninth Circuit yesterday in X Corp v. CCDH, a case presenting First Amendment and CFAA issues, among other things.
@MorosKostas It really is striking - SBRs weren't in the original bill, and you can tell from the passage that the AG, who was pushing it, didn't really care about them.
@MorosKostas From the legislative history, reason actually was a Senator wanted a safe harbor so hunters wouldn’t unwittingly run afoul of the initial concealable weapons provision.
I have published an article on SCOTUSblog addressing Heller's language about presumptively lawful regulatory measures. From the conclusion:
Heller’s discussion of “presumptively lawful regulatory measures” does not provide a “get out of history free” card allowing the federal or state government to avoid meeting its burden under Bruen’s second step. Which is to say, there are not “safe harbors” of people, place, or status that are exempt from normal Second Amendment scrutiny. While Heller identified categories of historical exceptions to the right, it did not define their scope; rather, the court itself stated that “there will be time enough to expound upon the historical justifications for the exceptions we have mentioned if and when those exceptions come before us.” Until then, it is the government’s burden to demonstrate the historical scope of those exceptions, and to demonstrate that a challenged law fits within that scope. What the government cannot do is point to Heller’s “presumptively lawful” language and end the inquiry there.
I had the pleasure of presenting argument in the Fifth Circuit today on the question whether the federal ban on individuals purchasing handguns outside of their home state violates the Second Amendment.