@SatishKTM@SwarnimWagle My concern is what’s the arithmetic here? Formalization argument is weak as the previous rate was above the mean earnings! Essentially translates to: more debt, for whose benefit, and at what cost?
@SatishKTM@SwarnimWagle If the goal was genuinely formalisation or pro-poor relief, you raise to NPR 6-7 lakh, watch registration data for two years, then adjust. What is there to hurry ? Gradual, evidence-based, fiscally defensible!
@SatishKTM@SwarnimWagle Yes, exactly. And that makes it worse, not better.If the old threshold was already above average income, most formal workers were paying little to nothing anyway. The formalisation argument was already partially captured. So who benefits from jumping to NPR 10 lakh in one move?
7/7 are we accepting short-term direct tax revenue loss in exchange for a broader indirect tax base over a 3-5 year horizon assuming it happens? How do we ensure this hole does not mean translate to increased debt burden beyound our capacity to handle debt ?
6/7 VAT at current compliance rates? Customs from an economy running a structural trade deficit? Electricity surcharge ? Equity and education levies
Agreed this is to get the informal sector in formal economy but could it not have been more gradual than rampant?
5/7The question @SwarnimWagle may need to answer is : what is the short-medium-term revenue path? Which tax handle replaces the income tax base that has just been removed?
4/7 Fair, Nepal is pegged to INR, capital account mostly closed. So the market punishment does not show up in bond yields or exchange rate. But it bleeds out slowly through reserve drawdown, domestic borrowing from NRB, and crowding out of capital expenditure.
3/7 This is the same structure as Kwasi Kwarteng’s September 2022 UK mini-budget. £45bn in unfunded tax cuts, no OBR costing, market reaction within hours. Gilt yields up 120bps in three days. Chancellor gone in 38 days. PM gone shortly after.
Those who celebrate @elonmusk's $1 trillion fortune need to be reminded of a simple and vital truth:
That there is a fundamental tension between extreme wealth and the very possibility of democracy.
Economics has never been, and never will be, a value-free science.
At its core, economics is shaped by ideologies, value judgements, competing interests, social norms, and political priorities.
Adam Smith and Karl Marx — two of the most important figures in the history of economics — both treated it as an inherently political subject. They didn't even call it "economics." They called it political economy.
For Smith, the study of wealth creation was inseparable from questions about the state, social class, and moral philosophy. For Marx, the economy was a system of power relations.
Yet most introductory economics textbooks relegate politics, power, and history to footnotes. Technical models fill the space instead, abstractions that describe an imaginary economy more than the real one.
My newsletter's most popular piece is on how economics became a discipline detached from politics — despite the fact that it is intrinsically and unavoidably political.
Link to the full piece in the comments.
As far as I know, this is the correct list of 38 PMs of Nepal in historical order. Interesting or ironical to note is that except for the 27th PM, Marich Man Singh Shrestha, all hail from Brahmin and Chhetri castes of Khas-Arya nationality !
यथास्थितिविरूद्ध असन्तुष्टी र आक्रोश राम्रो कुरा हो।त्यसले नै नयाॅ विकल्पको खोजीलाई अभिप्रेरित गर्छ।तर नेतृत्वले असन्तुष्टीलाई सुविचारित अग्रगामी दिशा दिन सकेन भने स्वस्फूर्त आक्रोश दक्षिणपन्थी वा उग्रवामपन्थी पपुलिज्म वा अराजकतावादमा परिणत हुनसक्छ!कराइबाट उम्केर भूंग्रोमा नफसौं!