We have a project on gene expression in the brain of an individual schizophrenia patient with an extremely low SZ-PRS. Here is the thread about it. The story is neither pretty nor complete, but there should be a place for ugly and incomplete stories. 🧵
5/ I tried to build a systems-level analysis on top of the OUTRIDER results. It kinda works. In my case, it correctly detected the patient's ischaemic signature, but the underlying genetic cause of the SZ07’s schizophrenia remains unknown. Disappointing, but a positive result was never guaranteed. Learned a lot doing this.
The argument still stands: Tolkien changed his mind about Orcs multiple times, and we don't know basic things about them.
The reason for this is clear. Sorry for the following theological angle, but Tolkien cherished the Christian idea that evil cannot create anything; it can only corrupt what already exists. This means that Orcs must be a fallen race that was originally good, rather than some soulless demonic creatures. It's a sort of a symmetry: Orcs were originally conceived as fallen Elves, just as Sauron is a fallen angelic being, a counterpart to Gandalf, for example.
But this creates the problem of innate, hereditary moral corruption, which is, of course, a very, very bad idea, not Christian at all. That's why, in your quote, Tolkien still feels the need to place Orcs within the Law. Why else would he bother?
My take is that Tolkien found this contradiction impossible to resolve. He struggled with it and ultimately left it ambiguous. This ambiguity is itself part of the canon.
@OldManBobb@baroneiof He does. Basic facts about the origins and demographics of orcs remain unclear in a world where other aspects were meticulously developed. This is not accidental. It indicates that the author's vision of orcs was never fully developed and this lack of vision itself *is* canon.
@KurakinEgor Мы не знаем точно, что они там исследуют. Замените старение на, например, исследование иммунных маркеров старческой деменции и тогда коллекция станет более осмысленной.
Following the low-key Salvadoran invasion of Haiti, Wilson Joseph, leader of the 400 Mawozo gang of Port-au-Prince, responded with ... a letter to the UN, requesting mediation.