Other similar models have Pr{right-wing majority} ranging from 22% to 71%. None of these are wrong. They're just making different assumptions. https://t.co/NyaA6hrPqy
Example of the kind of false precision I warn about with simulation-based models of special votes. 38% is not "far more likely" than 28%. Also, these numbers almost certainly reflect model parameter choices, not data. I advise against taking such numbers too seriously.
NEW: Robert Pattinson has been cast as WINSTON PETERS in an upcoming biopic
“He kotuku reranga tahi. The white heron only flies once” Mr Pattinson said after being asked about the casting.
@PronouncedHare@GraemeEdgeler Sorry in fact in 2014 - if you had just got rid of overhangs (so that UF’s seat came off the 120 seats and meant only 119 seats were proportional) then National would’ve NOT been able to form a govt with just ACT. So overhang actually helped National a lot in 2014
@PronouncedHare@GraemeEdgeler In 2014 with/without overhang they could just go with ACT to get majority. It was Northland by-election that changed the maths of which parties were need to form a majority
Fun 2008 piece from @dpfdpf warning against deliberately engineering overhangs - taking issue with some advice Matt McCarten provided.
And correctly noting the unravelling of the game.
https://t.co/8TOqn1EDn4
@rustie5555@nzsd I think Nats will have some incentives to switch cause ultimately they risk other political parties on the right getting much larger. They’d also like to have some list MPs as well. Key players in this are Labour and National
@nzsd@rustie5555 Cross party support very different from a referendum. If user experience of voting doesn’t change and number of electorates don’t change then legally you’d only need 51%. I think in practice you’d probably need some mix of the left and right blocs anyway to get to 51%
@nzsd@rustie5555 Agree - that a regional list PR system (similar to Norway’s) would be great. I guess the question is whether that is politically possible without a referendum and do people actually want a referendum? My feeling is that people like MMP and just want it fixed
The wasted vote normally strongly predicts the degree of distortion: The more wasted vote, the higher the share of seats every party that makes it to Parliament gets
Can you spot the 2026 election?
@josephsconnell@GraemeEdgeler Yea I think particularly for the Māori seats it feels very difficult to know, given idiosyncratic voting patterns and the fact that all candidates with a vague chance of winning are on the left
@rustie5555 I do think it’s a balance sometimes in these interviews between 100% factual statements and getting across an overall vibe that is broadly correct and more easily understood by public
@rustie5555 Hear where you’re coming from (and that would be my ideal system) but 1) that’s a separate comment from Rashbrooke not in the open letter 2) he’s trying to say that in terms of MMP vs SM vs FPP, why would we go to one of those less proportional systems