Attorney, landlady, feminist in LA County, fighting for rational rental laws. Former newspaper journo. Non-socialist YIMBY. Grew up in Glendale rental housing.
Activists: "Landlording is inherently abusive and exploitive."
Landlord: (uses the Ellis Act to stop landlording)
Activists: "oh no, we must END THE ELLIS ACT"
The Ellis Act is enemy #1 of tenant groups when you browse their social media pages.
It's what they fear the most. Those units are out of the rental market forever, it's harder to change state law, and the evictions are harder to dismiss.
But it's already far beyond that in California. And the landlord lobby did support the 2019 statewide rent and eviction control laws -- because they thought it would stave off worse things. It didn't IMO. The localities keep restricting further. In my experience, when troublesome tenants know you can't terminate them at-will, their behavior is far worse.
The tenant lobby tried to pass statewide rent control three times through voters, and it was voted down each time.
Finally, the Legislature did it, and the landlord lobby complied in order to have some say in what was passed.
Boggles my mind how many normal, smart people still don't understand that rent control also, always, means eviction control. It means leases can't end, and that a landlord can no longer terminate based on a no-fault 30- or 60-day notice.
Any rent control has to also prohibit leases ending. Otherwise, landlords would get out of rent control by nonrenewal or the no-fault notices when the rent is under market.
I deal with many cases where it's not like that.
Not typically large multifamily, because that doesn't get unsophisticated people. but ADUs, duplexes, triplexes, people who rent out rooms in their own house. Especially with older landlords and long -term tenants.
They think it's no big deal, until it comes time to end the relationship, or they face a financial crunch. Or they die and their heirs need to deal with it.
How do you feel about forcing people to keep rents substantially below market, say, in cases where they've been there a long time, and the landlord just didn't raise their rent for many years?
Landlords who already have market rate rents don't tend to balk much at inflation-based controls (except for the eviction controls). But I don't think that's what the pols and activists are after. The goal is to permanently ensconse the poor at rates that are substantially below market.
@StalkingPMS Fortunately California law bars vacancy control.
I doubt that even with vacancy control, CA would get rid of eviction control. Look at what they're doing to single family properties -- where CA bars rent control.
@xwanyex Yes, when I say I'm a YIMBY, I mean make it easier to build more housing and more multifamily housing, which includes making it easy to rent it out and enforce rental contracts.
Unincorporated LA County has all these same restrictions. But unlike West LA, much of the unincorporated county is rural, still rents for less than $1000, and has open desert within a block.
Imagine letting your loser grandson stay in an old 1BR ADU for a few months in back of your 1950s house in rural Pearblossom for $300/month from his mental health disability check. It's supposed to be temporary while he gets things together, but of course he never does. Now, you want to sell the house so you can afford a retirement home.
LA County says you have to 1) hire him a relocation consultant, and 2) pay him $12,688 relocation (it's higher because he's "low-income," as are nearly all unincorporated Antelope Valley tenants). Also, 3) he's entitled to a one-year extension on his move date, due to his depression and anxiety.
If he takes the money and time, and still doesn't leave? You still have to go through eviction court, and he's still got the right to a jury trial and a free attorney from the county.
If you're dealing with a large property, say, a 4BR house, they're entitled to $21,411. Regardless of what their rent is.
Starting January 2027, almost all single family homes, condos, and new apartments in west LA will have just cause renter protections.
This means that if you lease a home for rent the tenant can stay there forever as long as they pay the rent and don't break the lease.
You can't terminate the lease if it expires and you can't ask the tenant to leave if you want to sell.
That's true for the following cities:
Los Angeles City
LA County unincorporated
Culver City
West Hollywood
Santa Monica
Pasadena
That ain't simple though.
There are very few reasons. The ones there are require jumping through a lot of expensive, time-consuming hoops.
And no matter what reason you give, if the occupant doesn't leave (remember, they don't have to be a tenant), the only recourse is California eviction court, which we've previously discussed
@jayparsons Don't forget Costa-Hawkins though.
They can and will raise your rent through the roof to make you leave a sf-home.
Buys you a little time though.
@WebAgencyJohn@AmusedCynic1982@LA_Multi_Fam Right, that specifically says they can stay after the end date on the lease.
You cannot have a lease just end.
Why do you think that means they *can't* stay after the lease ends?
That California bullshit has been around for decades. All tenant protections trump anything you put in a contract.
And in any rent control jurisdiction, anywhere in the US, you can't have a lease end or terminate without cause. That's because they don't want you being able to evict/nonrenew to get around the rent control.