@dont_be_common @JustinRWalton @KnowingBetterYT Again, the meaning of mandate is that EVERYONE MUST DO IT. If only SOME homeschoolers are required to take the test then your sample is still not comparable to ALL PUBLIC SCHOOLERS. You’re still comparing an unrepresentative subset with a set. This is a massive no-no.
@JustinRWalton @DeeJzNuts@KnowingBetterYT They cannot show homeschoolers outpacing public school students if NOT ALL HOMESCHOOLERS TAKE THE TESTS BUT ALL PUBLIC SCHOOLERS DO. That’s what sampling bias means and the fact you can’t grasp it is insane. All data which control for sampling bias show no difference.
@JustinRWalton @DeeJzNuts@KnowingBetterYT No testing at all - 25 states
Parent chooses test - 8 states (this is not “taking the same test as public school students” making comparison difficult)
Testing or portfolio - 16 states
Tennessee is closest to mandating homeschoolers take the same test but still has alternative
@MikeArchrr@Drinky_time@KnowingBetterYT No, homeschool might not be worse than public school. That is the best the data can argue. Even then it is difficult because there is significantly less and significantly worse data on homeschoolers because they so successfully evade all accountability.
@MikeArchrr@Drinky_time@KnowingBetterYT No, because a peer with the same family background but who attends public school performs similarly. This is very basic statistics. It means that the causal variable is NOT homeschool v public school.
@MikeArchrr@Drinky_time@KnowingBetterYT The best argument homeschoolers can make on the basis of the data we have and rigorous research standards is that it might not be worse than public school.
@DeeJzNuts @JustinRWalton @KnowingBetterYT No, in every case the state offers alternative options. This is what it means to not be mandated and this makes unbiased sampling impossible. This is such a notorious problem in education research because there are not equivalent levels of state accountability.
@JustinRWalton @KnowingBetterYT There is not a single state which mandates that every homeschooler take the exact same standardized tests as their equivalent public school cohort.
@Drinky_time@KnowingBetterYT All research data which controls for the socioeconomic position of the student and their family, there is basically no discernible difference in outcome.
@_celia_bedelia_ She doesn’t leave her alone with the doctor, doesn’t send her to school with other children, and keeps her on a ranch far away from other people. It’s like she wants her to be as susceptible to abuse as possible.
🇺🇸🇦🇱 Former NYC Mayor Eric Adams is now officially Albanian.
He has been granted citizenship and has received an Albanian passport by a special decree issued by the Albanian president.