1927

[1927 @rinawife_7]

我都分不清宁艺卓大吧是不是串子了，你们组内能不能严查一下？感觉智商很低，一直烦串不串

[1927 @rinawife_7]

宁艺卓那么low大吧也是low货一个，贯彻饭随正主概念，弯道超车的梦做了六年还不醒，来这里撒泼偷换概念宁艺卓外网几根丝自己心里清楚哈😂走到哪里都被柳智敏压一头的命

[ChinaKarinaBar @ChinaKarinaBar]

@NingNing_Bar自己给自己爱豆母亲照片p上的文案可还行？

[ChinaKarinaBar @ChinaKarinaBar]

@NingNing_Bar 怎么不敢发这条回复微博的完整截图 是不是害怕别人看到她回复的这条微博第一张图就是对柳智敏的羞辱和对她家人的造谣？这样连带家人的造谣和辱骂你们持续了三年多了 还要人怎么忍？

[1927 @rinawife_7]

你们不是喜欢宁艺卓？祝你们遇到宁艺卓这样的人还不高兴这是干啥呀

[1927 @rinawife_7]

做人不要太宁艺卓😂喜欢宁艺卓的给你们接生活里的同事和朋友都是这样的人

[1927 @rinawife_7]

@yanfu615 宁老侃死了知道吗😂

[1927 @rinawife_7]

@evince19891213 你全家死了狗杂种

[1927 @rinawife_7]

倒打一耙还是你们玩得溜

[1927 @rinawife_7]

这说明啥呀，账号都在自己手上想发就发喽，别再自欺欺人不营业是sm不放人了，其实是宁艺卓自己不想发知道吗，能为了柳智敏大粉和泡泡机单发一条微博，却不能转发任务博的大气女人这辈子有了呀😂

[1927 @rinawife_7]

@Clara311i @yuueovo7315 这个团火跟宁艺卓有个毛关系😂

[Karina Protect @kprotecthouse]

FOR THE FANDOM THAT CALLS ITSELF OT4

“This account is normalizing Karina’s mistreatment and inciting hatred toward her subfandom over a misunderstood post which in result makes it even harder than it already is taking these topics (KARINAS MISTREATMENT IN ANY KIND OF FORM AND SHAPE) seriously and acknowledge the lack of fairness when it comes to the leader without receiving an immediate dismissive response from a fandom that’s been doing its best doing anything but protecting her and showing us just how much they truly tolerate Karina.”

Is what I sincerely wanted to write as post to mass report countless of times these past few months even if it may sound ridiculous to y’all (which always is the case anw so 🤩) bcs I’m beyond exhausted of the lack of accountability, discrimination, double standards, deshumanization, bodyshaming and overall just the insensitive dismissive response that results from an internalized hatred and feel of bitterness towarded the most popular member (which has been a threatening notion for most of y’all somehow) but I do have, as a protect account, a responsability to still maintain a composure.

It’s already hard enough managing this acc so when I see the behavior of this self proclaimed ot4 fandom dominated by harmful deluded shippers, that has done nothing but show clear signs of being anti-Karina, it makes it even more penible for me. I might be generalizing but atp I can’t bring myself to care about y’alls (complicit abusers) feelings when in my mind the whole fandom is to condemn and if your feelings have been hurt and you feel guilty over this, just know you’re part of the problem. Instead of coming for me maybe take it as an opportunity to reflect and question yourself.

I’m so done with the hypocrisy and games that y’all keep playing when you twist her words to fit your agendas, trap her subfandom for a gotcha moment, sense of superiority and another opportunity to move the goal post and diminish/disregard the issue, when you pretend not to see the way yourself, SM and antis have been treating her, just know you're no better than her biggest opp.

The way you don’t seem able to put your feelings aside and discern amongst your hatred for a subf and supposed care for Karina (why do you keep silencing loveyus and blaming karinas popularity as reasons to accept and turn a blind eye to her mistreatment by dismissing any point of concern as a subf being dramatic and why it’s only happening with her? why would you rather defend staff members over karina? etc) is what makes it obvious you only consider and use Karina for your own interest. Why do you think most loveyus no longer even try after repeatedly being silenced AND bullied off the app? Play dumb and keep deluding yourself when you’re the one pointing fingers and hunting ppl down for simply speaking up for Karina. This shameless difference in treatment only concerns Karina and I could talk about it for hours; how other members are allowed everything from (mys) reactions to actions while she gets treated less than tolerable. It might just be a fitted excuse atp, keep hating loveyus so you won’t have to admit how terrible you are to the leader, fotg, center, main dancer, lead rapper and sub-vocalist of the group.

If it was up to me you would all get reported and I wrote this on a whim after watching things unfold for years because I need someone to make you realize how much you have wronged Karina. This is not about a specific issue btw, it’s an accumulation of every wrongdoings and a long overdue attempt at setting the record straight after letting things slide for far too long.

We all make mistakes, we all fail short to protect these girls when the company itself is working against them but do you not realize how worrying and alarming it is that MYs showcase the same patterns and difference in treatment as the main abuser? The complicity you share with SM in that regard is a betrayal that eventually made many turn away from this fandom.

[ashrinhela @ashrnhela]

Let me get this right, Karina chinese fans payback what that girl fans did to Karina (exposing her family details), he/she posted that girl mom face & later that girl comment asked that person to take down the post?

Is she blind, cant you what your fans did to Karina. Selfish

[Ashu_Karina @Chigiri6688371]

Ningning
I can't believe that you saw this post at first sight that your fans are insulting your teammates and their families. You just selectively can't see it. You are really a white-eyed wolf. Is Liu Zhimin not good enough to you? Or are other teammates not good enough to you?

[ദ്ദി˶ᵒ ᵕ ˂) @soft4yjm]

"Cô ấy hoàn toàn có thể thu thập chứng cứ, khởi kiện antifan hoặc gửi thư luật sư, chẳng ai ngăn cản cả.

Nhưng rõ ràng có rất nhiều cách xử lý, vậy mà cô ấy lại cố tình chọn cách ngu ngốc nhất và cũng dễ dẫn dắt dư luận nhất.

Cô ấy trực tiếp lên Weibo, tự mình tag đối phương. Bề ngoài thì giống như đang cảnh cáo, nhưng kết quả là fan của cô ấy đồng loạt kéo sang tấn công một người bình thường trên mạng.

Sau đó lại sang Weibo của fan thành viên cùng nhóm để “dạy đời”, bảo mọi người đừng công kích gia đình người khác.

Thế nhưng ngay trong bài đăng gốc, hình đầu tiên lại là nội dung fan của chính cô ấy bịa đặt về đồng đội và còn công khai thông tin gia đình mà đồng đội đã bảo vệ suốt sáu năm.

Đừng có nói kiểu “idol của mày không bảo vệ mày thì đừng than nữa.”

Thứ nhất, idol của tao nếu kiện antifan thì sẽ không lên mạng xã hội diễn trò trước, làm bộ làm tịch rồi mới xử lý.

Thứ hai, mỗi lần idol của tao bị dư luận công kích hay bị chửi, điều đầu tiên cô ấy làm luôn là trấn an fan, bảo fan đừng lo lắng, chứ không phải sau khi bị mắng lại tự mình xuống sân, dẫn dắt dư luận rồi gom antifan với fan của đồng đội vào một nhóm để dạy đời.

Quan trọng nhất là idol của tao không phải người Trung Quốc, không dùng Weibo, nên không thể giống như con nhỏ kia, lên Weibo ăn vạ làm loạn rồi còn có cả fandom của mình hùa vào cổ vũ, tung hô là ngầu và khí chất."

[🍀 @nookowoes]

好想哭啊 一个韩粉回复我的

[1927 @rinawife_7]

@EVANNING66 @ujiminphoria @wntrult 死全家的傻逼

[순간의 카리나 @karinaofmoment]

🤍

[Karina♡ @ujiminphoria]

OMFG KARINA??!? SHE’S SO PRETTY

[CHANEL シャネル @CHANEL_JP]

ラ ムースからはじまるカリナのルーティーン。

うるおいを守りながら肌をすっきりと洗いあげる、カメリア セラミド*配合の洗顔フォーム、ラ ムースで、クリアな素肌へ。

*グリセリン、ユチャ種子油、セラミドＮＰ、フィトスフィンゴシン、水添レシチン（保湿成分ラ ムースからはじまるカリナのルーティーン。

うるおいを守りながら肌をすっきりと洗いあげる、カメリア セラミド*配合の洗顔フォーム、ラ ムースで、クリアな素肌へ。

*グリセリン、ユチャ種子油、セラミドＮＰ、フィトスフィンゴシン、水添レシチン（保湿成分ラ ムースからはじまるカリナのルーティーン。

うるおいを守りながら肌をすっきりと洗いあげる、カメリア セラミド*配合の洗顔フォーム、ラ ムースで、クリアな素肌へ。

*グリセリン、ユチャ種子油、セラミドＮＰ、フィトスフィンゴシン、水添レシチン（保湿成分）