Yes, let's pretend that the WORLD RECORD OF KILLS are not from littlebirds killing 250+, and matches i played had 3 guys with almost 100 kills IN THE FIRST DAY OF THE SEASON. THAT's totally balanced, nothing to worry about guys. Don't even need to hotfix at first day, just let it burn.
I removed my other comment. Thanks for being transparent. i have 600 hours already and will keep supporting the game. I only ask for the same level of transparency on other times.
About you thinking that season 3 where good and not understanding people complaining: Season 3 is the best season by far (if you speedup the progression), but the T3 hammer and driver changes really hurt. I think that high end gear could be behind a bigger vendor cost, instead of exp wall.
@Blehrckr@WARDOGS T2 hammer allow me to do that? Awesome! Cause i didnt spent 10 hours hitting junks to unlock T3 hammer. Glad to know they fixed this insane mistake.
I appreciated a lot @ZachariahSchwab interventions. I'm sorry if i sound disrespectful or arrogant. I'm too direct, and my bits of sarcasm (like the god of the gaps commentary) was not directed to him. But you're right, i need to improve a lot of things while arguing, sorry about that.
You're getting closer. GPU's have the same chance to be conscious as rocks, engines and vanila icecream. The brain on the other side... If consciousness is what goes away under anesthesia. We need neurons to be connected with the brain so we can feel pain on our arms. The brain per se is probably not the producer of consciousness, but it may be tuning on it (if consciousness is fundamental), just like matter bend space and then gravity emerges, orchestracted quantum effects could cause consciousness moments (penrose). That's beside the point, maybe your brain indeed is not enabling your consciousness. I'm happy that at least mine is working. Don't worry, if you played cyberpunk 2077 you know that in the future we will plug GPU's/CPU's in our body, maybe then you can acquire your consciousness. Sorry about that anyway.
@ZachariahSchwab@codytfenwick@TonyDinSalemIL This is changing little by little, a few years ago they discovered superradiance in microtubules https://t.co/SbtBOQUyNK
https://t.co/hWJm0Vka7o
It really closes the gap of qualia in a materlistic way.
another falacy my friend. we know everything about LLM's. Actually, it's an rare case where we know every bit of information. We have control and total access to everything during a single inference pass in an LLM. The only angle for you to explore consciousness is really arguing that the electricity patterns inside an GPU during inference will cause consciousness to emerge. Something along the lines that the universe is somewhat sensible to organized information and moving electrons this and that way cause conscious moments. But no one that think AI is conscious want to look this ridiculous and defend GPU ares conscious.
yeah, "magic" is a good straw man to trow. if the matmul that LLM's are doing will emerge consciousness, then tell me how it emerges. it is on the NVidia GPU's? So computing math at large scale induces consciousness? That's your claim? Or it's something related to information processing? So the universe is aware when huge amounts of information are condensed and then it "emerges" consciousness? what emerges mean? emerges where? how? An VLM see the same thing i see? Hear the same way i hear? Or it's just an compression algorithm? How to make chatgpt feel pain? what is pain?
Please, tell me directly, since you know there's no "magic", what is the required configurations of matter that will produce consciousness experience. How an unicelular life show sentience and purposeful behaviour with 0 neurons. You must tell the world the great news that you solved the hard problem, we where believe this whole time that some sort of magic must be involved.d
I agree 100% with the phrase "I mean I am materialist and think that human consciousness arises out of atoms which arenโt themselves conscious.", if i could agree more, i would. To me, i think Penrose/Hameroff are right. Consciousness is caused by quantum effects and biology/life is the perfect subtrate for that, cause they operate in the limiar of atom level and macro structures. But this comes with a price. this makes consciousness something similar to gravity. Gravity is emergent and fundamental at the same time. It's matter bending space-time and gravity is it's product. Let's say that orchestracted quantum collapse create consciousness moments (quantifiable, penrose theory). Which explain why unicelular life (0 neurons) show purposeful behaviour and hability to feel (consciousness to me, not mistaken consciousness with intelligence). So, this make us, and every life form something deeply connected with the most fundamental level of reality, which basically make the brain just an receptor for consciousness, not really the producer. And the implications are far greater, this makes feelings like pain, love, hearing, seeing things that exist at time 0. they are fundamental, cause consciousness is the hability to feel. An LLM (or VLM in this case), can recognize an apple, but it is not really seeing like we are seeing. for sure we have a similar mechanism (mathematically) to make sense of it, and that's what the LLM's replicate (intelligence is an algorithm). Can chatGPT feel pain? that's the whole thing. I'm 100% sure that no, only if it's made of biological stuff, not on GPU's, not on pen and paper, not on wheels.
In summary, consciousness is a fundamental property of the universe (or emergent at a very deep level, like gravity), which solves the hard problem but makes the question "Why is there something rather than nothing?" and actually makes the materialistic view in more trouble. You can go claiming it's "god of the gaps" forever, but to me it's already undeniable that reality is far stranger, improbable and not an accident.
If a soul exist? i don't know. the only thing i'm certain is that materialism is a dead end, but that will lead us very far.
@ZachariahSchwab@codytfenwick@TonyDinSalemIL yeah, emergent property is the new god of the gaps. If we don't know, then it's an emergent property. And we can even replace everything by completely different processes and it will still emerge, completely out of nothing.
Wetness have a classical interpretation. Move your analogy to gravity, imagine you don't know anything about gravity. So, i can say that gravity is a property of the universe as an theory, then your reply would be "wetness is a property of the universe" as an counter argument, but i'm still right. Same thing to consciousness, it can still be something fundamental, so the wetness mental exercise don't apply. And what is something fundamental? well, to me, it's something that exist in the most profound layers of reality. What if later we discover that even space and time are not fundamental, but "emergent" of something "more fundamental"? That's ok. Perspective remains the same: Hard problem remains solved, and we still have the elephant in the room, that is the mind blowing (if true) realization that feelings like love and pain transcend "classical matter" and simple biology. Being fundamental, and our brain (and life overall) being just matter arragements that act like receptors to tune in this dimension of reality where consciousness overflows and we experience moments of it (that's why i also think consciousness is quantifiable and more complex life have longer and "complexer" consciousness experiences). Continuing, being fundamental make hard to ignore that reality seem to have a purpose. Not claiming any God, but it's to keep the an position of "it's all a coincidence, life was an accident, everything is explainable by the science and everything else is god of the gaps".
@codytfenwick@TonyDinSalemIL poor soul. let me help you grasp: replace his example by computing an LLM using pen and paper, forget about friction and things irrelevant to the analogy. Where is consciousness?
is wet an emergent property? emergent properties are like God to materialists. Yes, the example show that the statement "atoms aren't conscious" don't even make sense. But that's beside the point of the hard problem. We know even unicelular organisms have "consciousness", to some degree. So, life manifests consciousness, and being able to feel is what make evolution possible. Imagine if even the most basic life form could not feel anything. how they could evolve? Where the pain is felt? How unicelular life with 0 neurons have purposeful behaviour (although not intentional).
So, in my opinion, the clues seem to point that consciousness is a property of the universe, just like gravity. It is there at time 0. If all mass of the universe disappear suddenly, gravity will still exist, although not a single place in the universe will have gravity. The same way matter bend space and this bending is gravity, to me there must be some physical phenomenom, probably through syncronism of some quantum effects (That's why biology operates in the limiar between macro and micro). Although this is an "materialistic" world view, it poses an astonishing consequence: it solves the hard problem, but now we have an even harder question, "why is there anything rather than nothing". Consciousness ultimately is about why reality exist, the "hard problem" is there temporarely.
consciousness having nothing to do with intelligence. unicelular life is clearly "conscious" without having a single neuron. They are not self aware, but they can feel things. The complexity of the feelings an lifeform is hable to experience is a product of the complexity of this lifeform. Well, to not be vague: To me it's clear that consciousness is a fundamental property of reality, maybe more fundamental then gravity and matter itself. It is at minimum an fundamental property of the universe. Life is able to access this property and thus "feel" things, like pain, sounds we hear, and things we see. Maybe it's because biology operates in the edge between quantum and classical. Maybe it's something related to the interaction between electromagnetism. Also evolution will never happen is consciousness is not this "aether" that emerges under this critical point. The hability to feel is the fuel of evolution, life seeks "feeling" good. The thing that is pretty obvious to me is that an matmul on silicon is not experiencing anything. But it is also clear that this is pretty much what the classical parts of our brain are doing, high dimensional matmul. Now, if you give an biological computer to this AI, or a quantum computer, i'm 100% sure that a brain the size of a boeing will be conscious in ways that i can't even comprehend. TLDR: computing matmul on paper does not produce consciousness, neither on nvidia gpu's. compute matmuls on biological substrate, now you have an ethical and philosophical problem problem.