@hyper_imagine While there's a certain amount of people creating accounts just to give 100 to OoT and 0 to GTA 6, the vast majority are people review bombing because: female protagonist/woke/cuck, it's nothing like GTA 5, and ADHD idiots not liking the game just because it's slow paced like RDR
@CeeOhOh@toms4098@tony_charlie1@DarkViperAU Perfection as a concept is objective, but my definition can be subjective. For example i think Witcher 3 is the GOAT. If that was the absolute truth no one could disagree with me; and that's not the case. People not liking the game doesn't change the fact that it's a 10/10 to me
@CeeOhOh@toms4098@tony_charlie1@DarkViperAU Just outta curiosity: if 10/10 means perfect what does 0/10 mean to you? Non perfect? Non existent? The worst ever? If it means the worst then a 10/10 means the best, not perfect. You could be the best at something and still not be perfect at it, just better compared to the rest
@CeeOhOh@toms4098@tony_charlie1@DarkViperAU I'm actually in favor or just using a "like/dislike" system and that's it. Everyone has a different interpretation of a 10/10 thing. To some people GTA 6 is a genuine 10 and to other it's not, or it's even a 0. By then it's just better to say you like or you don't like something
@CeeOhOh@toms4098@tony_charlie1@DarkViperAU If you want a definition of a "perfect game" by some sort of logic, it's the one that's Top 1 on the list. Any game releasing in the future that can captivate more people than the number one will become the new standard of "perfection". Even if it's still objectively not perfect
@CeeOhOh@toms4098@tony_charlie1@DarkViperAU I should repeat myself again: Perfection is objective and since it doesn't exist because nothing is perfect, the score becomes completely subjective. You could give 10/10 to something you absolutely love or is the best thing you ever experienced; it still doesn't mean is perfect
@CeeOhOh@toms4098@tony_charlie1@DarkViperAU 10 means the best, not perfect. Perfection don't exist, yet a score of 10 does. Is Shrek remake the best ever or do better games exist? Cause then it's not a 10. The score measures comparison to other games, it doesn't evaluate perfection. It's also subjective and not hard to get
@CeeOhOh@toms4098@tony_charlie1@DarkViperAU That's not what 10/10 means. Since perfection doesn't exist but scoring a 10 does, then it means it's nearly perfect. Also people rate something a 10 when they really like it or is the best thing they ever played. Metacritic states that a 10 means "Universal acclaim", not perfect
@reepmlg@wqeqtd2@CarpPincho Hermano me terminé el OOT remake y me pareció un 10/10, ni de lejos soy fanboy de Rockstar, pero tampoco de Nintendo. Ambos juegos me parecen de lo mejor que ha salido en esta última década
@reepmlg@wqeqtd2@CarpPincho Ni de cerca es la misma cantidad, considerando que Ocarina salió antes y prácticamente nadie fuera del entorno Nintendo estaba tan espectante como con GTA. Además Metacritic tarda un tiempo en filtrar notas de haters. Mirá en IMdb las notas reales de usuarios: GTA 9.5, Zelda 9.7
@presznchampion@lucaskehoe Oh it's gonna be at least 15 for sure. Considering the sheer scale of the game and possibly years and years of online content
@Trojansilverfih@green_squire@HiperOneis_Back@YisusBv14 No existe nada perfecto en el mundo, menos un juego. Si darle un 10/10 a algo significara perfecto entonces no existiría poder puntear eso en primer lugar. El 10/10 es una opinión personal de algo que te gustó muchísimo o lo que más te gustó en la vida a pesar de ser imperfecto
@freeIDGAF0S Estás comparando un juego de PS4 corriendo horriblemente mal en PS5 y PC, y de un juego de Wii U no teniendo 60fps en Switch, la supuesta "nueva generación" de Nintendo del momento. El nivel técnico de gta 6 es imbatible, es un milagro que alcance los 30fps en una consola de 2020
@BlackArdiente@CuervoGFX Exacto, las mecánicas hacen al gameplay y no al revés. Al BG3 tener mecánicas totalmente opuestas a RDR no significa que el gameplay del mismo sea un asco, sino que las mecánicas son distintas. Sin embargo mecánicas complejas no siempre se traducen a gameplay complejo
@BlackArdiente@CuervoGFX El BG3 es un juegazo por dios, pero la gente sigue sin entender la diferencia entre mecanicas y gameplay. Si el gameplay de uno se basa en estrategia entonces el de RDR se basa en habilidad. Es como comparar al fútbol con el ajedrez, no son comparables y no por eso uno es un asco
@Leolaweafome@CuervoGFX Jugué todos los mencionados y son todos buenos, y el gameplay de RDR2 no es un asco. Son géneros distintos y si bien el turn-based no es mi favorito el BG3 es el mejor de ellos. Sin embargo el E33 está muy por debajo de otros como Divinity II, FF, la saga Chrono, etc.