1. Private bank money carries the ultimate promise to settle payments with state money. This makes private bank money a derivative of state money.
The fact that a bank can fulfill a depositor's payment instructions by transferring a deposit liability to another bank via netting or settlement in assets other than state money does not negate the underlying promise to settle at par in state money.
2. I would actually say the deposit system is a derivative bolted to THE BOTTOM of state money.
There would be no private deposit system denominated in the state’s unit of account without the state establishing that unit of account first. We could all theoretically bank, receive, and pay our state tax credits directly to the state without a private deposit system. We could not, however, get and pay our state tax credits without a state. The dependency is one-way. That is why the deposit system is the derivative layer.
The fact that banks can expand their balance sheets horizontally before seeking reserves vertically does not flip the ontological hierarchy.
3. Deposits are only “every bit as good” as central bank money if they're insured by the state. You might be fine with uninsured deposits, most are not.
The fact that the insurance payout does not pay in state money but in another deposit with the same promise is not evidence that deposits are every bit as good as state money. The existence of the insurance, however, is evidence that private bank money is not “every bit as good as” state money.
4. This is NOT to say that private bank deposits are claims on the state. They are, however, “claims on state money” in the same sense that my ticket, bought from a third-party vendor, gives me a claim to a seat in the football stadium.
If I told you that I have a seat for a Sunday night game you would correct me and say: “No, all you have is a promise by the third party vendor to a seat at the game. The stadium has no obligation to you.” You would be technically correct, but few would want to be your friend. 🙂
Then you would go on to say: “But, your third party ticket is every bit as good as a ticket directly bought from the stadium”. You’d be incorrect and have even fewer friends, because now you're inconsistent too.
@jbhearn@Beter_Geld Mosler: govt checks don't bounce
Greenspan: there's nothing to stop the federal govt from creating as much money as it wishes and paying it to someone
Hearn: they're both wrong because I say so.
@Beter_Geld@jbhearn no. Are you capable of reading more than a few lines of text?
If it helps, Warren has written a brief summary of each innocent fraud followed by a 1 paragraph rebuttal of each. You don't need to read the detailed explanations if you don't want to, or prefer not to
@Beter_Geld@jbhearn you asked the wrong MMt-er then.
If you want 7 key points of MMT then helpfully someone has written it all down for you
https://t.co/8ZMMONu7lY
@GeorgeSelgin@AlanDownunder but it is a liability the bank itself creates when it acquires an asset from the non-bank sector. The asset can be reserves, banknotes, loan agreements, securities....or anything.
Why is a liability different if the asset acquired when it was created was reserves or banknotes?
@ChrisPacia@MMTmacrotrader its not a redistribution. Paying interest is functionally no different to any other govt spending. It credits private sector bank accounts.
@GeorgeSelgin so..if the govt (acting through its agents) didn't sell interest bearing bonds, or pay a non-zero interest rate on reserves, the o/n interbank rate would fall to its natural level....which is zero?
@GeorgeSelgin but where does the cash come from that gets deposited into a bank as a 'primary deposit'? It came from being drawn down against another deposit. And that deposit was created by a bank when it extended credit. Deposits, which are bank liabilities, do not 'support lending'
@GeorgeSelgin gains new assets - namely reserves that settled that transfer between banks A and B.
Are you saying that it is this influx of reserves that 'supports lending' of bank B? If so, I absolutely disagree. A bank requires reserves to settle payments out, not for lending.
@GeorgeSelgin a deposit sits on the liability side of the bank's balance sheet. It's an IOU of the bank. A bank can create its own liability whenever it wishes. Doing so, doesn't 'support lending'.
When customers of bank A move their balances to bank B, bank B creates new liabilities and
@cullenroche "who cares".......
Anyone wanting to understand how the monetary system actually works, rather than being fobbed off with handwaving might care......
@cullenroche being insolvent isn't exactly a choice!!
A bank being insolvent highlights the difference between state issued money and bank issued money.
They are not the same. They cannot simply be described as 'money' with no understanding of why they are different
@cullenroche banks in the UK have very similar terms.
I find it very strange that you equate a bank limiting large withdrawals for logistical reasons with a bank having the option to simply default on you.
A bank can limit your daily withdrawals of cash. It cannot simply choose to default
@cullenroche physical currency, yes it might take. little time for the bank to deliver it to you, but what it cannot do is say, 'no you can't have physical currency in exchange for your credit money, here's some credit money instead'
Do you think that makes sense?
@cullenroche can deliver credit money instead of currency in such circumstances is juts plain wrong.
A bank deposit is credit money. It gives the holder the right to use it to clear a debt with the issuer OR to demand an equivalent amount of physical currency.
If you demand your $100k as
@cullenroche they are always a claim on state money. IA movement of reserves is required to settle a tax payment. The bank cannot refuse to do that. And it's also a claim on physical cash. Just because the bank might limit withdrawals for logistic reasons, it cannot refuse to give you 100%