A strategy that loses money can be a winner (+EV) in a prop account.
A -EV strategy:
90% of days +$200, 10% of days −$2,000
EV = −$20/day on your own capital. Net P&L, P&L/DD and Sharpe all say no.
Run it through a challenge ($100 fee, $1,000 target, $2,000 breach, 5 winning days, 80% split):
P(pass) = 0.9^5 ≈ 59%
P(paid) ≈ 34.9%
EV ≈ 0.349 × $800 − $100 ≈ +$179 per attempt
Your loss is capped at the fee and the firm absorbs the tail which flips the EV in your favor.
Searching for or building prop strategies on traditional performance metrics (P&L, Sharpe, Win rate, Profit factor) is flawed.
You need new metrics for a new game. Probability of passing, time to first payout, Expected Net / Attempt and Prop ROI.
The Challenge Finder tests one portfolio across 800+ challenges to find the best fit. Rank by these new metrics before you buy a challenge.
Build Alpha v3.2 update is live. Check your inbox!
What's new:
-MCP. Control BA from your LLM
-Prop Firm Simulator. Test any strategy or portfolio across challenge and funded stage
-Challenge Finder. Test any strategy or portfolio across 800+ prop firm challenges to find the best.
-MT5 data downloader. Export data from MT5 directly into Build Alpha with one-click. All symbol settings included.
Full write up in the first comment. Thank you!
Introducing MCP for Build Alpha
Releasing soon. Control Build Alpha from a prompt.
Build strategies
Create signals
Plot indicators
Automated robustness
Portfolio construction
Prop simulations
Export code
and more...
🫶
Prop Challenge Finder
Find the challenge your portfolio is best for
Pick one portfolio and run it through every challenge in the database of 500+ prop challenges
Then rank each prop firm challenge by
· expected net per attempt
· passing probability
· days to pass
· expected cost to get funded
· Prop ROI
· etc.
And view how each simulation path faired. One portfolio against every challenge.
A strategy or portfolio may fail one firm’s rules but pass another’s.
Blindly buying challenges without knowing which are best suited for your trading style is an avoidable mistake.
I call this the "Challenge Finder". It will ship this week.
Prop Firm Math part 4: two strategies that usually fail a prop challenge can pass together.
Strategy 1 Mean Reversion:
· Makes about $120 on normal days
· Loses $2,000 on crash days (5% of days)
· Wins 69% of days
Strategy 2 Trend:
· Loses about $100 on normal days
· Makes $2,500 on crash days
· Loses 66% of days
Both have positive expectancy on their own.
Run each through LucidFlex 50K rules: $3,000 target, $2,000 trailing drawdown, 50% consistency rule.
20,000 simulations each:
Mean reversion passes 32% ❌
Crash days blow straight through the drawdown.
Trend passes 30% ❌
It bleeds into the trailing drawdown while it waits for big days.
But put both in one account. Same rules, same size.
Passes 84% ✅
Why? They lose on different days. The crash days cancel out, and mean reversion’s steady gains cover the trend bleed. The account rarely gets near the drawdown.
Compare that with running them in two separate accounts: a 53% chance that at least one passes, but you pay two fees. Together: 84% for one fee.
Prop challenges don’t grade your P&L... they grade your path.
Stop judging strategies one at a time looking for the perfect one. Think what does this strategy do to the portfolio’s path?
That’s what the prop firm simulator I’ve built searches for: the combinations that pass.
I am convinced prop firm trading is an entirely different ballgame than trading cash accounts.
Traditional metrics like Sharpe, smooth equity curves and low max drawdown aren’t what you should be optimizing for to maximize prop payouts.
I actually added new fitness functions to find more prop firm compatible strategies
-probability of passing eval
-probability of first payout
-expected return per attempt
It is best to think of prop evals as a call option.
The option premium is the fee
The max loss is the fee
And the upside is essentially unlimited payouts
Options love volatility. Why are you trading the eval like it’s your retirement account?
The best strategy for your own capital is often the wrong one for an eval. Totally different games.
You may not even want the same strategies to pass the challenge as the ones you'll trade once funded.
That's why the prop firm simulator can sort by these different metrics.
I'll be showcasing more of it later this week with a full write up.
A pretty backtest is not evidence of edge.
Search enough combinations, randomness will eventually produce something that looks amazing.
Jaffray Woodriff of QIM discussed this idea in his chapter, The Third Way, in Hedge Fund Market Wizards: don’t just ask whether your strategy looks good but ask whether it looks better than what luck can produce.
That’s the idea behind the Vs Random Test.
Can your strategy beat the best random result? if you're going to data mine or use ai to find strategies this is a requirement.
Because if random signals produce the same Sharpe, P&L/DD, profit factor, or whatever metric you optimized for, then your beautiful equity curve may just be the winner of a noise lottery.
Backtests are easy to make impressive now. Beating luck is harder.
Prop firm math is CRAZY. A losing strategy can become a winning strategy under a prop firm structure.
Imagine a strategy that:
• Wins $200 on 90% of days
• Loses $2,000 on 10% of days
Trading your own capital, its expected daily P&L is:
90% × $200 − 10% × $2,000 = −$20 ❌
Now imagine a hypothetical prop arrangement:
• $100 total fee per attempt
• Five winning days to pass the evaluation
• Five more winning days in the funded account to receive an $800 cash payout
• Any losing day closes the account
• No additional costs or payout restrictions
Assuming independent daily outcomes, the probability of reaching that payout is:
90%^10 = 34.9%
Your personal cash outcomes become:
• Reach payout: $800 − $100 = +$700
• Fail before payout: −$100
Expected profit per attempt:
34.9% × $800 − $100 ≈ +$179 ✅
The strategy has negative trading expectancy, but this hypothetical "prop" contract gives the trader positive cash expectancy.
Why? Because you absorb the evaluation fee instead of the strategy’s full trading losses. This opens up what strategies and portfolios can look like.
It is a completely different design and optimization problem for strategy and portfolio development.
This week I will be sharing more about the prop firm simulator I've built and what it can do.
The last week or so I’ve covered four different signals and filters for context-aware systematic trading. Here’s a recap for wknd readers.
Gamma Exposure: option market maker positioning. Dealers will quiet directional price moves when long gamma and will extend directional price moves when short gamma.
Commitment of Traders Report: understand how different players are positioned. Large speculators are net long and retail is net short is different than large specs net short and retail extremely bullish.
Market Breadth: what’s going on under the hood. Is this rally well supported or only due to a few names. Will there be follow through?
Event Conditioned signals: sequence matters. If last hour yesterday rallied hard, what does that mean for today’s open? How we got here is as important as where we are.
Links in the comment for full explanation and example signals you can test.
If you like this type of content let me know with a comment. I have more haha
A simple strategy I saw posted on here a day or so ago makes a nice example of the flexibility of the new prompt to signal feature.
No judgement on the strategy itself. Tested on QQQ over the last 25 years. Fixed sizing. Worth exploring.
Three entry signals
-RSI(3) less than 22
-EMA(100) higher than 5 bars ago
-Price 1% or more below 10-day rolling VWAP
Exit
-RSI(3) above 55
@buildalpha I’m still learning this amazing software Build Alpha. This morning I discovered Chart with AI, I think this feature deserves a YouTube video
The strategy that would have saved your worst drawdown is sitting in your reject pile.
You threw it out because it looked bad. Nobody keeps an ugly strategy.
This is one of the major flaws in how most strategy development works. We (system traders) typically evaluate strategies on a standalone basis.
Best profit, best sharpe, smoothest equity curve, whatever. Then just mash them together in a portfolio and pray they work together.
It’s why I built Portfolio Search
You pick a saved portfolio and instead of generating the best single strategies, it generates strategies that contribute to what you already have.
The fitness function (optimization goal) becomes marginal contribution to that portfolio instead of the strategy's own backtest.
Portfolio Lift toggles every metric so you can see the percentage improvement from adding each candidate strategy.
Portfolio View lets you click through and watch the combined equity curve change.
The ugly strategy that you discarded but actually need is now discovered on purpose and presented with data. A more thoughtful way to develop.
What if your settings or prompts aren’t good?
That’s the next-gen backtester in Build Alpha.
Connect Claude, GPT, Gemini, Grok, Open Router, etc.
Build Alpha begins generating candidate strategies. The connected model monitors the results
• checks for performance plateaus • changes settings, entries, and filters • authors new signals to try • advances winners to robustness tests • rejects anything that fails • exports code to NT8, MT5, TradeStation, Multicharts, TradingView, ProRealCode or Python
• stores its learnings in local memory so the software gets smarter each time you use it
Some strategies work. Most don’t. You need to find out at computer speed.
Search → test → reject → redirect → repeat. 24/7
This post brought up the idea from a few that it is ok or even a good idea to skip trades when you're not feeling or operating at your best.
This is a discretionary trader trap that the math disagrees with.
You may skip the trades that make your strategy profitable and unknowingly change its expectancy (profitability).
Imagine a simple strategy:
10% chance of a winner that pays +$10
90% chance of a loser that costs -$1
Strategy has positive expectancy.
Imagine you take 9 trades and they all lose: -$9
The next trade is one of the +$10 winners. But you’re sick, distracted, traveling, tired, or just “not feeling it,” so you skip it. Stay at -$9.
You participated in the losses but missed the compensation for them!
Or say you're not at your best and instead of capturing $10 you only made $6.
Instead of being +$1 after 10 trades, you're -$3 (-9+6)
Now what? You go through another 9 losses and are -$12 and your next winner only puts you at -$2. Following this system automatically you'd be at +$2. Difference between winning and losing.
Can you psychologically survive another 9+ losses waiting for the next big winner? What if you miss that one too?
Automation and a data driven approach allows the expectancy to play out over a large sample. There's no sickness, divorce/breakup, hangover, traffic on the way to the office, bathroom break, etc. that alters it.
You don’t know which trade is paying for the others. You can't skip 'em or afford to execute them poorly.