I appreciate that in the immediate lead-up to the UK-EU Summit, this speech had a particular slant and audience. But we will need to hear a much more sophisticated, coherent foreign policy story from the PM to inspire confidence in Britain's strategic and security posture. 5/5
Best bit is the masked "racist losers" prove they're losers by releasing a video showing the unmasked sole woman owning them. Stupid as well as racist. Doh!
Europe has a representative. It’s Kaja Kallas. As long as she remains High Representative, she — and no one else — should be the one talking to Russia.
Why? Because Putin and Trump need to be forced to deal with the EU as an institution.
Nick Robinson at his smart arse worst talking about us bombers being withdrawn from Fairford. They needed them home as they were running out of bombers ?
Putin is playing mind-games when he tells Witkoff/Kushner that Europe must choose peace or war. Europe was at peace till Putin chose war. A new security architecture cannot be built on the basis that Russia gets to dictate future security arrangements in Ukraine.
Putin is playing mind-games when he tells Witkoff/Kushner that Europe must choose peace or war. Europe was at peace till Putin chose war. A new security architecture cannot be built on the basis that Russia gets to dictate future security arrangements in Ukraine.
Lots of discussion on here and elsewhere about the Kushner/Kremlin ideas for a "new European security architecture", but the idea this is the moment to rethink European security is profoundly unrealistic (and un-Realist, for what that's worth). A few points:
🚨 The UK and its NATO allies should consider going “on the offensive” to defend against Russia - put pressure on the Kremlin, cause them a dilemma and create jeopardy - rather than leaving the initiative with Moscow and defending against whatever Russia does, Lord Mark Sedwill, a former Cabinet Secretary and long-serving UK National Security Adviser, has said.
He said this could be done by using conventional or hybrid defences.
Lord Sedwill, a highly regarded and leading voice in the security community, was speaking on the Royal Navy’s flagship aircraft carrier in Norway at the opening of a conference attended by serving military chiefs and ministers as well as members of the defence industry from across Europe and beyond.
Lord Sedwill posed three questions for the attendees.
Firstly, how can the UK and its allies defend effectively the North Sea and the North Atlantic - Britain’s “frontline” with Russia?
Secondly, how can allies defend against Russian, Iranian and other hostile grey zone attacks such as cyber hacks, assassinations and hoax bomb threats?
But his third point was the most strident.
Here is what Lord Sedwill said at the Atlantic Future Forum:
“This is something I really do want to emphasise. It is not just about defence.
“NATO is a defensive alliance but the most effective form of defence is often to cause a dilemma, it is often to go on the offensive against our adversaries.
“So how can we present our Russian adversaries in particular with a set of strategic dilemmas?
“How do we make them feel they are under threat? Not simply leave the initiative to them and defend against it.
“That is true whether we are talking about land, sea and air but it is also true if we are talking about the hybrid space, space, cyber space and indeed in the information space as well.
“I hope we can think that through as well.
“How - whether it is in conventional defence or in hybrid defence - can we put some pressure on the Russians?
“Because deterrence requires not just effective defence, it does require there to be some jeopardy to our adversaries in continuing to probe us.”
‘One of the key tasks of this squadron will be to determine what these small boats are to be used for, and it’s interesting to note that they were bought so fast that this isn’t yet clear’ 🧐
https://t.co/OmjGP1phej
Mark, I think I came across your father ( forgive the perpendicular pronoun) . The end state and achievable mission objective should be the news point. What do the Russians want, and are they really settling for a ten year war ? What possible end state do Trump / Hegseth / Kushner-Witkoff think they can achieve in Iran and the Gulf ?
@_kotelnaya_ Exactly - and in any case the term originally was used for how non-state actors fought state ones (eg, Chechens vs Russians, Hezbollah vs Israel). But it does, by implying this mix of mil/non-mil, always needlessly invoke the "but when are the little green men arriving?" q
@MarkGaleotti Can we have a new name rather than hybrid? For it to be hybrid it has to be a mix of trad and non trad warfare. Russia (or anybody) is not engaged in traditional warfare with any of these countries. So what exactly is it a hybrid of? As a pedant, this has always annoyed me.
Thank you Mark. I was hoping you are writing for the weekend , but we have this piece of ratiocination at least . I struggled to explain to Al Jazeera last night that no safe attribution on the bomb hoaxes has been made so far. But they insisted on banging on about hybrid war, and useless NATO security !
PS: I suppose I should tack on an obligatory bit of self-promotion: I talk about many of the fragilities of this modern world in my book THE WEAPONISATION OF EVERYTHING!
I've been in politics for a quarter century. It's hard to express how staggering it is to see a conversation like this on corporate US media. The Morning Joe panel gobsmacked by the directness of @AbdulElSayed's points.
(clip via @DropSiteNews)