Personally don’t think Scotland were as bad across 3 games as the reaction, some of it toxic, suggests.
You can’t miss that many have, some understandable, gripes with the manager over tactical outlook, team selection and personal demeanour in media interviews.
I sympathise with some of that, but there can be no mistaking this was a brutally tough group.
Brazil are Brazil. Morocco are ranked higher than the Dutch and Germans for a reason. Haiti are no mugs and their off the cuff style is problematic to manage.
If anything, Clarke tried too hard to play out and be positive last night in his selections. Most punters and media were happy with the line-up before kick off. For sure, he tried to play football.
We are simply not capable of doing so and winning against the quality of opposition faced in Miami. If you played that game 100 times, how many are Scotland grabbing a result?
In retrospect, I bet Clarke wishes he stuck to his guns and went 5-4-1, stunk the place out and got the 1-0 defeat that likely puts us through. He would have been crucified, but we might just be closer to the last 32
Whatever Clarke did or didn’t do, there’s not much any manager can do about catastrophic individual errors.
We had three of them and each cost a goal. That’s on the players. Hanley, McKenna and Robertson are all experienced professionals who know the game inside out. The captain is a Champions League winner and needs no instruction in such circumstances.
For the third tournament in a row, many of these guys failed to show their club form, yet seldom few ask if there’s a reason for that.
As Ange Postecoglou said the other night in his ITV analysis of Scotland, our best players all excel in their leagues primarily through physicality. Thats the main reason they’re at top five league teams, not consistent technical mastery.
There’s bigger issues at play here, a much wider picture and only long-term strategic planning to produce more talent will help. A long road.
For me, if we are serious about a national team that consistency makes these tournaments and competes, the pathway needs to start with rules that force Premiership clubs to rear and play their talent. When virtually no Premiership side plays their kids with consistency, what chance have we really got?
Heartbreaking sign of what happens when people lacking in intelligence get radicalised by Facebook comment sections.
Choosing not to vaccinate your kids because you don't like Cycle lanes and couldn't go the pub for a few weeks 5 years ago, and this is where it spirals too.
Lin Yu-Ting is female and has been female since childhood.
What is terrifying is that J.K. Rowling, wielding her influence and always using a frantic approach, completely disregards the possibility of making mistakes and relentlessly attacks our athlete.
Yesterday, the incident involved an Italian athlete who felt that the punches from Algerian athlete Khalif were too heavy and said she "did not want to compete against a male," so she withdrew. Khalif is one of the athletes who had disputed biochemical data in their previous IBA tests with Lin Yu-Ting.
However, in the current International Olympic Committee (IOC) examination, both athletes were found to be completely normal. The IBA, which had previously disqualified them, has been suspended due to issues with unfair judging and corruption. The IBA was stripped of the status by the International Olympic Committee in June 2023.
Moreover, the IBA president "claimed" that these two athletes have XY chromosomes, but they "never actually tested chromosomes" and only "tested biochemical data."
So the IBA president was "guessing."
How can someone with XY chromosomes have normal testosterone levels in the Paris Olympics and other events, including the Tokyo Olympics?
Did they somehow remove their testes during blood tests and then put them back in for the competition?
It is natural for athletes to not be allowed to administer additional testosterone, so normal blood tests before the competition are expected. What more do you want to question?
Additionally, testosterone levels in females can naturally increase without medication, including a condition called DSD (Differences in Sex Development). Studies suggest that 7 out of every 1,000 female track athletes have DSD, with higher testosterone levels than typical females. However, medicine has yet to prove that testosterone levels are the absolute key to winning in sports. [1]
Next, let's talk about chromosomes. Did you know that some people's cells have a "45,X/46,XY mosaicism" ? [2]
Furthermore, men can lose Y chromosomes from many cells with age. This phenomenon is considered increasingly common. [3]
While you are defaming athletes who have been female since childhood, some of your cells might be silently undergoing changes you aren't aware of.
Rules for the world's highest-level competitions are not determined by novelists but by professional medical teams and the Olympic Boxing Working Group (PBU).
Our athletes are competing legally and in compliance with regulations. I will continue to support them, and Lin Yu-Ting also needs your efforts to debunk the rumors and full support! Go Yu-Ting!
[1] Controversies surrounding female athletes with differences in sexual development, Ahmed Khattab, Ian Marshall, Sally Radovick, J Clin Invest. 2020 Jun 1; 130(6): 2738–2740.
[2] Sex Chromosome Mosaicism, Penn Clinical Manual of Urology (Third Edition) 2024, Pages 879-914.e1 CHAPTER 25 - Embryology and differences of sex development, Katherine M. Fischer MD, Thomas F. Kolon MD, MS
[3] Zhou W, Machiela MJ, Freedman ND, Rothman N, Malats N, Dagnall C, et al. (2016). "Mosaic loss of chromosome Y is associated with common variation near TCL1A". Nat Genet. 48 (5): 563–8. doi:10.1038/ng.3545. PMC 4848121. PMID 27064253.
Article by Chengche Tu, MD.
When I met boxer Lin Yu-ting 林郁婷, I saw an athlete who is fearless in the face of challenges, whether they come from inside or outside the ring.
Today, when she represents #Taiwan on the Olympic stage, we will be behind her & all the Taiwanese Olympians making us proud.
It's Angus' last day on ScotRail twitter! It's not difficult to recognise how much he has influence public transport in Scotland - he's reached legend status.
Let's take a look at some of the best tweets;
This is actually the perfect representation of the "debate" about trans healthcare because one of these books is edited by two medical doctors and the other is written by a former Wall St Journal columnist who went on Joe Rogan