I'm well familiar with the narrative constructs you refer to. Please explain how they would enhance the story around Malfoid? Harry Potter isn't a comedy, which is the way that Shakespeare usually employed this setup. Even if it's not comedy, what does sacrificing Ron and Hermione's relationship, and losing all the ways that we could explore Malfoid's presence improving it, actually gain us if by exchanging it for Ron and Pansy?
You're using "archetype" incorrectly, by the way.
@KatiaEarth "Throw yourself at the ground and miss." Perfection.
I love that Elon is such a geek. The answer to Life, the Universe, and Everything was caught by Mechazilla. These are now immortalized in history as our first step to the stars.
This was absolutely beautiful.
Also I burst out laughing when Malfoid zapped that stupid toy grabbing machine and then had Harry running down the street behind her with a huge armful of all the stuffed toys, those machines suck and I've wanted to do that to every one that I see for most of my life.
I always remember a study I heard decades ago that said the most important sexual characteristic of a man is his voice, while the most important for a woman is her hair. I've never been able to find it again, so I can't offer evidence, but a simple thought experiment is enough to prove it.
Think of the most handsome man you've ever seen. Now imagine him with a nasal, squeaky voice.
Then, think of the most beautiful woman you've ever seen. Now imagine her bald.
Longer hair is better.
Remember, Malfoid's original impact came about because she was the ONE change that made EVERYTHING better. Just her existence gives more motivation and depth to the relationships that were already set out in the books. We can expand the characters from there, and if it makes sense to have Pansy and Millicent and Daphne and Crabbe and Goyle given that same treatment, great. I could even get on board with Ron and Pansy being best frenemies over Harry and Malfoid's relationship. But if you turn them into a romance too, you not only undercut the thematic and archetypal importance of the main character's romance with his main rival, but you are breaking the Ron and Hermione relationship, which already has its own important role in the story that is, again, ENHANCED by Malfoid's presence, for no perceivable gain. What's the point?
@japan_nobunaga This is most likely true. Once mankind gets off this rock and sets foot permanently on other worlds, it'll be because of him. In Star Trek terms, he's basically Zefram Cochrane.
@Sheepfarmer373 I am indeed. And there is a book called The Heroine's Labyrinth that breaks down the yin-oriented archetypes as a mirror and complement of the yang-oriented Hero's Journey.
https://t.co/ugBnxkSgtL
It dilutes the story and point of Malfoid and Harry Potter in the first place.
If someone can give concrete, thematic, and archetypal support for how it actually supports or even enhances that story, I'm all ears. But they are not obvious. And I don't expect many people to be versed enough in archetypes to provide anything convincing.
@schmede_AI What are Lisa and Daphne to each other, anyway? Lisa almost acts like she can't stand her and yet she's stepping in to defend her, helping her get away with her conniving behavior, and getting her Christmas gifts.
@Foyege24 This looks incredible. By this point there's no way to tell that it didn't come from an actual film production. Still feels oddly anime-coded, but that's just a stylistic choice. The execution is FLAWLESS.