❀ほしな✿ 🐺🐾💚

20↑｜夢/腐/雑食/DD｜とうらぶ｜あんスタ｜ツイステ｜アイナナ｜恋と深空｜呪術｜HQ｜ブルロ｜文スト｜ブラスタ〖𝒫 〗｜蒼井翔太/声優/2.5次元｜𝒦𝒾𝓈ℯ ℛ𝓎ℴ𝓉𝒶｜🌈🕒(別垢)｜無言フォロー失礼します！

[❀ほしな✿ 🐺🐾💚 @saniwa_kaga_95]

The colour of the moon is just like Valko's eyes 🌕🫶
🐺ＡＷＯＯＯＯＯＯ💚

#BringValkoBack
#ValkoIsLoved

[Serendipity⁷ ⊙⊝⊜ 💜✨ FESTA+ JUNELEB! @boracosmos7]

The way his eyes CHNAGE?!??
HELLO SIR THE LUST IS LETHAAAL

#ValkoIsGoodBoy #valkoreturn #valkols6th

[Angy#bringvalkoback 🍫🐺 @Angysartist]

We can do it valko nation! Lets keep doing what we are doing 🐺 spread love not hate 💗

#全世界都爱敖尹
#ValkoIsLoved #ValkoIsValuable #BringValkoBack

[VALKO'S WIGGLY WAGGLY TAIL 🇹🇼 @anjoolinn]

OMG. DO NOT GO TO CHINESE EMBASSY TO PROTEST. I REPEAT, DO NOT.
#全世界都爱敖尹 #novalkonomoney #bringvalkoback

[Bombalina #ValkoIsLoved 🐺🍎 @BombalinaTears]

"They only know LADS" lol. lmao even.

I want Valko back because I am an otome gamer #全世界都爱敖尹 #BringValkoBack

[壱大 #全世界都爱敖尹 @64018ichi]

【世界中のハンターの仲間たちへ】

​各種プラットフォームの『恋と深空』公式アカウントに動きが見え始めて、数日が経ちました。
8月に実装予定とされている、ホムラ/祁煜/기욱/Rafayelの新規日位思念について、皆さんにお願いがあります。

近日中に公式アカウントより実装の告知がなされた際、ホムラ/祁煜/기욱/Rafayelメインの仲間たちが思念実装を喜び、獲得しようとすることを決して責めたりしないで欲しいのです。
仲間たちが気持ち良くゲームやガチャを楽しめるよう、静かに見守って欲しいのです。

​ロウガ/敖尹/오인혁/VALKOを取り戻すために一緒に頑張っている仲間の中にも、他の5人の男性主人公がメインの方はたくさんいます。
メインはそれぞれ違っても、私たちはロウガ/敖尹/오인혁/VALKOを取り戻す、という同じ気持ちを道標に声を上げ続けている仲間同士です。
お互いの気持ちを思いやり、気遣う心を忘れてしまっては、私たちの間に分断や混乱を生みたい人々の思うつぼです。
そうした不必要な対立に巻き込まれないよう、どうか冷静に思考し、落ち着いて行動するよう、お願いいたします。

​アプローチの仕方も人それぞれです。お互いのやり方を尊重しあいましょう。
ログインしない、課金しない、様々な素晴らしいファンアートの展示をする、ロウガへの愛をポジティブに美しく優しい言葉で発信する。
無理のない範囲で自分に出来ることを、前向きに行っていきましょう。
そうして世界中に私たちの声を響かせ、共鳴し続けましょう。

#全世界都爱敖尹
#ValkoIsLoved
#BringValkoBack

[R. 🐠🐺🍎 @Astareion]

I wanted to do something fun and silly because I saw and joined the one with @0myhearthz.

Come add a Valko？Let’s see how much of the canvas we can fill with #Valko✨

Just a silly activity. Anyone can join!

#ValkoIsLoved #全世界爱敖尹

[Lena In Linkon @LenaInLinkon]

Please focus on the GLOBAL boycott and cut through CN noise. Obviously if someone tells you to boycott outside CN embassies block them lol.

#全世界都爱敖尹 #BringValkoBack #LADSis6 #SpeakUpInfold #ValkoIsLoved #NoValkoNoMoney

[油条 🍎 @tiao_xyz]

can we be real for a sec? PPG didn’t cave to cow dung, funeral wreaths, etc… it was the government, the one thing they can’t ignore. we can’t use hashtags like PPGRCNG bc it sends the EXACT same message to the government that CDGs weaponized to remove valko in the first place.

[七伊 @71yuhsin]

敖尹可能擁有的三種型態？🐺🐾
#BringValkoBack
#keepValkoAlive

[サダヲ @_sada_o_]

🫴🍫

[-🍎🐺 @poranglinosus]

1

#全世界都爱敖尹 #ValkoIsLoved

[Stella Rose 🫧 @loveandstella]

This post is my analysis dump of a lot of claims being thrown around right now and what evidence there is to show PPG intends to bring Valko back or not. Very long, so be warned.

Right now the biggest wild card is PPG's own reputation when it comes to PR crises. This is honestly their Achilles heel and years of bad PR response are now coming back to bite them. If they were known as a trusted developer I don't think there would be nearly this much chaos and speculation during their silence.

Their modus operandi seems to be: explosive change-> stonewall silence & doubling down -> soft capitulation later

So let's look at our examples:

Infinity Nikki
-1.5 launch w retconned opening + aggressive monetization + gamebreaking bugs
-players respond by organizing a boycott and discover the word "boycott" has been heavily blocked on SM
-after 20 days of silence, PPG releases a statement of apology + compensation
-the retcon is never reversed, although quality of game improved

Shaw (MLQC/Love Producer)
-Shaw was suddenly announced as the 5th LI and immediately met with extreme backlash
-PPG nuke his launch and stonewall his supporters, allegedly helping other LI mains to suppress and scatter them
-6 months later Shaw is added as a Special Encounter

Similarities and differences
-Valko is released to extreme backlash. After Shaw, I think PPG expected this. Proof is in the 27.6 statement reaffirming Valko's launch instead of knee-jerk cancelling the way they did with Shaw.
-A coordinated smear campaign is launched with no room to respond; to stop the extreme escalation they nuke Valko's launch

-Going by their playbook from MLQC + IN we should have seen 2 things: immediate take down of all content related to Valko + blacklisting of key terms related to him. We got neither. Even now no terms related to Valko are blacklisted on any of PPG's moderated platforms. The discord server was archived but not deleted, and Valko supporters are freely allowed to discuss in the main server. Reddit has not rejected Valko content, they merely delete comments with hashtags as a matter of course. Other removed comments on other platforms can reasonably be assumed to be taken down from mass reporting or for incitement to escalation

Note: one might argue they are not deleting in order to avoid backlash/keep people pacified, but what would be the reason? The bubble will have to be popped eventually and the backlash would happen regardless. We have seen that the energy and intensity of pro-Valko has not waned that much, due to the collaboration between global and CN (which Shaw did not have btw). By this logic PPG is allowing themself to be harassed for an indeterminate amount of time rather than making a firm move and resolving the issue right away

-We know that they went radio silent after July 1st except for two maintenance posts. We do not know why. There is only speculation. If we follow the playbook set by IN, we should have seen a statement issued after the prolonged silence to clarify the changes in schedule, especially about Rafayel's myth that was promised to release in July. Was this a deliberate non-apology? Frankly, they are not that dumb. They have already angered a subset of players and would likely want to keep good relations with loyal players + pave the way for a successful myth launch.

Now that I've laid out what we know, I will try to answer some speculations and questions.

PPG is icing us out so it will blow over. They don't intend to bring Valko back.
This is possible given their track record. Again, their Achilles heel. However

-according to the 28.6 sealed statement on CN social media, they were aware of the smear campaign and intended to take legal measures to address it. Tbh I am not knowledgeable about Chinese law. I do not know what records are made public when it comes to filing. But we do know it is common for corporations to remain silent about the relevant subject before proceedings. This leaves them in a catch-22. They cannot say anything about Valko. But the players are demanding clarification about Valko. They could speak about something else, but given how their words have been misconstrued, that could backfire. And it also risks alienating Valko supporters who are left to conclude that PPG has moved on. If they respond to no one, there is no conclusion, so it leaves a path open

-silence is an advantage to them. In a highly volatile situation where they are being maliciously targeted, staying silent keeps them in a cloak of secrecy that makes it difficult to anticipate + strike at. If they communicated clearly, that information would be used against them and possibly twisted to fit a certain narrative

If they don't intend to communicate, why release a banner BAU?
PPG is a business and LaDS is their product. Not everyone is boycotting, and they risk also alienating loyal players still willing to stay in the game by either shutting off service or providing no new content. This is a form of protection of their assets.

Why isn't PPG doing anything to help Valko?
They are.

-The schedule was completely overhauled, even though we saw with the multi that they can rely totally on in-game notices to push banners. Whether or not they were under gag order, we saw how the July 1st regular post was the last advertisement outside of banner notices that they have done since.

-Again, nothing about Valko has been banned from any of their social media. Comments are left on for announcement posts.

-The Junior moderator who mass deleted Valko posts on the Weibo super topic was immediately removed and Junior moderation was suspended. Subsequently, the deleted posts were restored

-I can't really speak for Weibo or other CN socials, but from what I can see trending topics can be purchased but it is not always clear who is purchasing the topic. There have also been battles going on between topics, with trending being either pushed or suppressed for various reasons. If PPG is suppressing topics, they are not strictly about Valko (again, nothing related to him has been muted/blacklisted), but things that would likely cause unnecessary escalation that will harm their strategy/operations

Why isn't PPG doing anything about CDG/YTM?
This one is trickier, but I think we can look at a few key points.

-It seems that extreme fanaticism/ idol culture is prevalent in Chinese entertainment, so I don't think they really would do a lot against them. They might target specific bad actors (like the one channel that was issued an official notice on 02.8) but overall seem to treat them like noise, as evidenced in their 27.6 statement reaffirming Valko's release

-the anti-Valko AI and harassment have unfortunately not been taken down yet because it would show favoritism from PPG for Valko, which can be used against them at this stage. Neutrality is a form of silence and they need to keep their advantage by not getting too involved. Any good signs for Valko are left to pure speculation and cannot be proven either way. Direct action from them is verifiable, so needs to be avoided

a few more points for why PPG isn't on CDG side right now:

-Caleb's jersey does not have a number. I don't believe the rectification would include "no numbers allowed" so this was clearly their own decision. They could have used 02, but we all know his jersey is #5, so it may have angered Caleb fans more than no number at all (which can be explained away). Why can't they use 5? Because it can be easily used as an attack on Valko supporters to "prove" PPG gave a "signal" that there are only 5 LIs. In this case, PPG is likely protecting pro-Valko from additional harassment

-9m9 is still at large, which seems like inaction at first, but is likely tactical. At this stage in the battle, a known enemy is more useful than an unknown enemy. Plus, it's known she has a contact on the inside feeding her updates. It would be advantageous to allow her to continue causing trouble (for evidence gathering) and feeding her wrong info. We have actually seen this happen. Twice now Rafayel has trended high on Weibo with no real cause, and on 08.7, there was a push for Valko before the fakeout of ver6.0 on 09.7.

Added note: PPG is at fault for fostering the environment for CDG to run rampant, and I'm sure they're regretting it now. They are also responsible for playing too fast and loose with shock marketing tactics and riding on (initial) negative press for exposure with Valko's launch. I'm sure they're really regretting that now.

What about the suspicious way everything seems to blow up whenever we get aggressive/ hit PPG?
-It's an open secret now that this campaign, while fronted by CDG/minors was not orchestrated or funded by them. This is corporate warfare. We're being used by both sides.

-Some have suggested it's PPG's way of breaking the fandom and forcing ppl to leave, but tbh the numbers don't show that. We still have very high comment engagement on their posts. On twitter we have maintained a very consistent 20k+ comment ratio, with only a 2k drop between Caleb announcement and the most recent maintenance post (24k vs 22k). Weibo still hits 100k+, though how much is authentic is questionable. And while we are divided now in our approach, our goal is completely the same and we will all harrass PPG's socials regardless

-You have to ask yourself who benefits the most from the blow ups? Who is getting hit the hardest? Certainly PPG's reputation keeps taking hits from all sides. Do they benefit? None of the blow ups have actually reduced the pressure on them. Valkotwt was able to trend two positionally opposed tags within 48 hours (one anti-PPG, one pro-Valko) even after the banner announcement shake-up on 03.8. So if we look at who benefits, its anyone against Valko's release and against PPG's success in this crisis. Speculate as you will.

The most important factor for why Valko MUST return
The boycott is very important and we should of course make our grievances known, but I think money is not the main driver for PPG rereleasing Valko. You see, Valko has something that Shaw did not, that Infinity Nikki did not. Love and Deepspace, and Valko by extension, are a National Cultural Export. And global has made it very, very clear that we want that export product. It is in PPG's best interest, both as a recipient of government subsidies, and as a representative for China abroad, to release Valko. We shouldn't use their status to bludgeon them, but as a free ticket of promise. We know they have to. They know they have to. The only question is when. And yeah, we're all impatient to get this over with (they are too) but we don't know exactly what's happening behind the scenes and we don't know when things will be ready.

We've done a lot to lay out the red carpet to help PPG return Valko but tbh? we don't have to. They have a whole marketing team and money they can burn on advertisement. They can take care of paving the way on their own.

Note: I'm sure I missed some points but did my best. This is, again, my personal speculation and analysis. I authorize reposting this to other sites with or without credit.

#BringValkoBack #BringBackValko #AoYin #Valko

[🐺🐦‍⬛ぶぶ漬け(アヌビス神)💚❤️ @Bubuduke_Life]

日本人にも分かりやすようにまとめてみました〜✌️✌️

#ValkoIsLoved
#BringValkoBack
#全世界都爱敖尹

この人の結論は

「Valkoは戻る可能性が高いと思う。ただし、今PPGが黙っているのは戻さないからではなく、今は動けない事情がある可能性が高い」

という考え。

ただし本人も何度も

これは事実ではなく私の分析・推測です

と前置きしている。

⸻

① PPGは昔からPR対応が下手

この人が一番言いたいこと。

PPGは昔から

大炎上する
↓
何週間も無言
↓
後から少しだけ譲歩する

という対応を繰り返している。

つまり

「今無言だから終わり」

とは言えない。

⸻

② Infinity Nikkiでも同じだった

例として

Infinity Nikkiでは

大炎上
ボイコット
SNSで「ボイコット」という言葉まで規制
約20日間沈黙
その後謝罪

という流れ。

だから

沈黙＝終了

ではない。

⸻

③ Shawでも似たことが起きた

MLQCでは

Shawが新キャラとして発表された時

猛烈に叩かれ

PPGは一旦ほぼ存在を消した。

でも

約半年後に正式追加。

つまり

PPGは

「一回引っ込めても後から戻す」

前例がある。

⸻

④ ValkoはShawと少し違う

ここが結構重要。

筆者は

PPGはShawの失敗を学んでいて

今回は

6月27日の声明で

「Valkoは予定通り実装する」

と一度正式に言っている。

だから

最初から消すつもりではなかったと考えている。

⸻

⑤ 本当に削除するならもっと徹底的に消すはず

これが一番面白いポイント。

もしPPGが

「Valko完全終了」

なら

普通は

Valkoという単語NG
SNS削除
Discord削除
Reddit削除

くらいする。

でも実際は

Valko関連ワードは禁止されてない
Discordも残ってる
Redditも普通の投稿はOK
コメントも大量に残ってる

つまり

完全に消そうとしている動きではない。

という分析。

⸻

⑥ じゃあ何で黙ってるの？

ここは完全に推測。

筆者は

中国版で

6月28日に

「誹謗中傷について法的措置を取る」

という声明が出たので

もし本当に法的対応中なら

余計なことを言えない可能性がある

と言っている。

つまり

沈黙＝敗北

ではなく

法務の都合かもしれない。

⸻

⑦ なぜ通常イベントだけ続けるの？

これも

「会社だから。」

ゲームを止めると

普通のプレイヤーまで失う。

だから

通常営業だけは続ける。

これはValkoとは別問題。

⸻

⑧ 「PPGはValkoを助けてない」は違う

筆者は

実はPPGは少し助けていると言う。

例

・ジュニアWeibo管理者がValko投稿を大量削除

↓

即解任

↓

削除投稿復元

これを

PPGが修正した証拠

としている。

⸻

さらに

7月以降

広告投稿も止まり

スケジュールも全部変更。

これは

何か事情がある証拠では？

という考え。

⸻

⑨ CDGを放置してる理由

これも推測。

筆者は

今CDGを大きく処分すると

「PPGはValko側についた！」

と言われて

逆に炎上すると考えている。

だから

今は中立を装っている。

⸻

⑩ Calebのユニフォーム番号が無い理由

ここは面白い考察。

普通なら

Calebは5番。

でも

番号を消した。

筆者は

もし

5

を付けたら

アンチが

「ほら恋と深空は5人しかいない！」

と騒ぐから

わざと番号を消した

と分析している。

これは完全に推測だけど

一応筋は通っている。

⸻

⑪ 9m9を放置してる理由

筆者は

9m9を今すぐ消すより

泳がせた方が

裏の繋がりを調べられる

と考えている。

さらに

フェイク情報を流して

誰が情報を漏らしているか

調べている可能性もある

と言う。

これも完全な推測。

⸻

⑫ 最近何かあるたび炎上する理由

筆者は

これを

PPGがやっているとは思っていない。

むしろ

ライバル会社との企業戦争

だと言っている。

つまり

毎回

PPGが一番ダメージを受けているので

PPG自身が仕掛けているとは考えにくい

という理屈。

⸻

⑬ 一番重要な結論

筆者が最後に一番言いたいこと。

お金も大事だけど

もっと重要なのは

Love and Deepspaceは中国の文化輸出コンテンツだということ。

つまり

中国政府から見ても

海外向け成功作品。

世界中が

「Valkoを出して」

と言っている以上

PPGには

最終的に出す責任がある

という考え。

だから

問題は

「出るかどうか」ではなく

「いつ出せる状態になるか」

だと結論づけている。

⸻

この文章全体を一言でまとめると

この人は、

PPGの過去の対応パターン
現在のSNSでの挙動
削除されていないコンテンツ
法的対応の可能性
企業としての立場

などを総合して、

「現時点では『Valkoは戻らない』と結論づける証拠はなく、むしろ戻すことを前提に慎重に動いている可能性の方が高い」

あくまで臆測や推測も込みだと思ってご覧下さい✨️✌️

[Resh!!🩺 Finals season💔 @reshphobic]

Vogue special 🐺 edition #valko #bringvalkoback

[𝐌𝐨𝐨𝐧 ⋆⁀જ➣ 🍏🐾 @moon_on_satur]

The biggest hopium for me from all of this has been the fact the official LADs topic still allows posts about Valko.
AND if a leech gets in as a moderator and deletes all his posts, they're promptly back after CS is contacted.

WHY do they still allow posts about a cancelled LI? 👀

#ValkoIsLoved #BringValkoBack #全世界都爱敖尹
#NoValkoNoMoney

[Che~ 🌻 𝕝𝕚𝕝𝕪 𝕠𝕗 𝕥𝕙𝕖 𝕧𝕒𝕝𝕝𝕖𝕪 🌻 @Cherrylladygirl]

Qimai updated Day 2 for Caleb's Summer Surge, and the numbers aren't looking much better.

Day 1: 111,752 USD
Day 2: 66,517 USD (-40.5% from Day 1)

Now I'm just wondering... if the revenue keeps dropping like this, do you think they'll still push through with Raf's Myth, or will they finally realize they need to fix the situation first?

[onyx- VALKO I LOVE/MISS YOU @wolfiepips]

✨LaDS: WHATS IN/OUT✨

IN:
✅ Boycotting (no spending or logging in)
✅ Posting about how much we love Valko
✅ Answering gen questions about things
✅ Research, verification, and independent thinking

OUT:
❌ Listening to rumors
❌ Engaging anti
❌ Fear mongering/doomposting

#BringValkoBack #BringBackValko #LadsIs6 #全世界都爱敖尹 #ValkoIsLoved #ValkoIsThe6thLI

[🐺🐦‍⬛ぶぶ漬け(アヌビス神)💚❤️ @Bubuduke_Life]

書道イベント自体は悪くないけど、今の状況では中国側に伝わる頃には『Valkoのため』という目的だけが消え、他キャラの企画として誤解される可能性が高い。だから今はやらない方がいいってことだね！！！

確かにこれは困るね🤔🤔

みんなこれは本当に気をつけたい💦
見た人は良かったら拡散してくれると助かる🙏🙏

「Valkoを応援するために6人全員を書きました」

という企画でも、

中国側に伝わる頃には

「外国人が恋と深空の男性キャラ全員の中国語を書いている」

だけになって、

「Valkoのため」という目的が丸ごと消える

可能性がある

次の🐟（ラファエル）のイベントとも結び付けられる恐れ

コメントでは

次のバナーは🐟で、中国風テーマになる可能性が高い。

だから、

海外ファンが中国語を書き始めると

中国では

「🐟の中国風イベントのおかげで外国人が中国語を書き始めた！」

と誤解される可能性もある、と懸念してる

つまり、

本来はValko応援なのに、別のキャラクターの盛り上がりとして受け取られてしまうかもしれない

他キャラファンとの対立はまだ終わっていない

「6人全員を書けば仲良くなれる」という考えは甘い、と言ってて

まだファンダム同士の対立は残っているので、

「なんで急にうちの推しを利用してるの？」

と思われる可能性があるのね。

うん！！！やめよう!!😂やらん方がいい😂😂

#ValkoIsLoved
#BringValkoBack
#全世界都爱敖尹

[julie ˚୨୧⋆｡˚ ⋆ | MISSING VALKO @dynamicwn]

KOKO please hurry up and come back !!!

#BringValkoBack #Valkoisloved #ValkoisValuable

[壱大 #全世界都爱敖尹 @64018ichi]

【世界中のValkyriesへ】

またデマやリークの情報が出回る可能性がある、というお話が流れてきました。
ですが、如何なる情報も公式からの正式なもの以外は、私たちが信じる必要はありません。

『内部関係者から～と聞いた』『○月に～が行われると聞いた』『運営が仕掛けた罠』『○○をしなければロウガ実装はない』

こんな内容が、これまでにも流れてきましたが、全て眉唾物の、全く根拠のない話ばかりでした。
公式は既に各プラットフォームでの告知を再開出来ています。
私たちの活動や声を止めたいのであれば、このように回りくどい方法を取る必要は一切ありません。

私たちがするべきことは、今後もシンプルです。
根拠のない情報には一切触れず、静かに距離を取ってください。
また、こちらを揶揄したり、煽って怒らせようとするようなポストやコメントも、同様に触れることなく放置しましょう。過度な侮辱表現や行き過ぎた内容のものは、各プラットフォームへ速やかに通報してからブロック・ミュートしてください。

そして、それぞれが無理のない範囲で、お互いのやり方を尊重し合いながらアプローチを続けましょう。
ロウガ/敖尹/오인혁/VALKOへの愛を、美しく、優しく、ポジティブな言葉で紡いで、響かせあって、共鳴し続けましょう。

大丈夫。私たちは絶対にロウガ/敖尹/오인혁/VALKOを取り戻せる。
頑張ろう。頑張りましょう。
彼に『おかえりなさい』と『愛してるよ』を伝える、その日のために。

#全世界都爱敖尹
#ValkoIsLoved
#BringValkoBack