Shanksuuu

[Shanksuuu @Schanksu]

@ShamoDiyar @Shahrwaraz1 @SemireXalti @Ezidixr @DrRebin93 you say that his umayyad origins were controversial among Islamic writers. this is not the case with ibn taymiyya. can you give any other examples of such alleged writers?

[Shanksuuu @Schanksu]

@ShamoDiyar @Shahrwaraz1 @SemireXalti @Ezidixr @DrRebin93 ibn taymiyya only criticizes the family tree spread by his followers, just as he criticized the silsila of him. but the umayyad origin is not rejected as such. ibn taymiyya elsewhere praises sheikh adi as "adi ibn musafir the umayyad". he did not deny his umayyad origins.

[Shanksuuu @Schanksu]

@ShamoDiyar @Shahrwaraz1 @SemireXalti @Ezidixr @DrRebin93 thanks, can you please send me a link to it?

[Shanksuuu @Schanksu]

@ShamoDiyar @Shahrwaraz1 @SemireXalti @Ezidixr @DrRebin93 van you show where ibn vaymiyye denies an umayyad origin? please provide an exact source