If this graphic made sense to you, then context officially died on football Twitter.
This comparison claims
Amorim โ 38 games, 42 points
Carrick โ 25 games, 44 points
Sounds smartโฆ until you apply basic football logic.
First of all, "Ruben Amorim did NOT manage 38 league games".
The Premier League has 38 games TOTAL. He 'did not start the season'. He took over mid-season, with United already sitting 14th, after multiple managers and months of damage. Blaming him for points dropped before he arrived is simply dishonest.
Amorim actually managed 27 league games, not 38. (24/25)
Now letโs talk context.
Before Amorim took over, United had 3 wins in 11 games, low confidence, no structure, and an unbalanced squad. Yet those early dropped points are magically assigned to him now? Thatโs not analysis, thatโs narrative pushing.
Carrick has done well. No one is denying that.
But Carrick did not inherit the same situation. He didnโt walk into a side already buried in the table, didnโt carry Europa League pressure at the same time, and didnโt have to undo months of instability. Adding Amorimโs rebuilding work into Carrickโs point total is football math fraud.
Another convenient omission, Europe.
Under Amorim, United went unbeaten in Europe (8W, 2D, 0L) until the final and we all know that's on Onana . Squad rotation, workload, and pressure mattered, but theyโre ignored because they donโt fit the agenda.
This graphic isnโt accidental.
Itโs designed to simplify complexity, remove takeover context, inflate one manager, and bury another.
You can praise Carrick without lying about Amorim.
You can enjoy momentum without rewriting history.
Football is about phases, inheritance, and context.
Remove those, and you donโt get clarity, you get propaganda.
And this graphic?
Pure propaganda.
In football, I support Manchester United
In American Football, I support New Orleans Saints
The manager of United and Head Coach of the Saints have been fired within the same week (might be a day difference)
That is how fun this season has been for me ๐๐ญ
I'm sick and tired of the Gary Neville slander
Would he cope in modern football, probably not
But you look at consistency he performed at...
That's what you want from a full back