@null_ropex hypo generation is cheap
finding tests to distinguish hypos is real work
developing taste to quickly estimate the probability of different ontological planks prior to testing requires dedicated cultivation
what do you think nagel means by the phrase "natural manifestation of consciousness?"
can you articulate examples he would endorse that he thinks would be more probative than generation of language?
i feel like it would be hard to do so, to correctly model his position, and still think he's making a terrible and bizarre argument, to think his argument is not at least plausible, even if flawed
but i'd be excited to be corrected if that's not the case
sure but there's a stronger intuitive response by users to wonder if language generation signals consciousness than image generation, so naturally he's focused on the behavior sparking that intuition, since that's the intuition he takes issue with
and that is an interesting divergence that might be explained in a couple ways
on the one hand, maybe people simply underrate the importance of image generation
alternatively, people might be overrating the evidentiary value of linguistic outputs
he's endorsing this latter resolution and honestly neither seems straightforwardly absurd to me, i suspect he's correct that we will get better evidence about phenomenology by looking at factors that drive internal representations relative to just looking at outputs, because phenomenology, if not an illusion, is an internal property
we had national treasure Frank Capra making explainers in the second one
i genuinely think we became too self conscious about propaganda, we decided it's all evil
but these are works of uplifting art. there is nothing malicious about how they champion an open society and constitutional freedoms
saying this is what america believes in and you should believe in it too is not malevolent brainwashing so long as you don't have censors pre-approving all art to make sure it celebrates the state. in a pluralistic society with free speech guarantees submitting a little propaganda about individual liberty can be a benevolent act
if your read of popper's paradox of tolerance leads you to conclude you can take infinitely harsh measures against those who oppose your values, then certainly you can try out a little competitive speech in the marketplace of ideas, as a start
@teortaxesTex *high achievers was an intentionally absurd euphemism for the time before universal suffrage, but land ownership as a requirement probably filtered iq by a few percent, i don't know what the impact was but owning the most expensive resource probably wasn't negatively correlated
i think it would be weird and hard to predict, high iq political preferences are idiosyncratic. but in the past elections were filtered through a slice of high achievers, probably the median iq of that group was much higher, and it was still raucous and factional and dominated by power considerations instead of good governance
even some of the most philosophically grounded founders like hamilton had a run at being exploitative monopolists when given the chance
politics is hard
it would be interesting to give voters education on unintended consequences in law, both from the econ tradition and from jurisprudence where poorly written laws create all kinds of weird edge cases, maybe that would make people have a little more respect with how hard it is to stick the landing on new policy, without pushing them one way or the other
People are pattern matching on language, but they should be looking for the key to consciousness in the moments we lose it, like how anesthesia desyncs several time linked processes and suddenly our experience goes out like a light
An ai designed to mimic all those systems, even if it had no voice, would worry me much more
@luc_pacioli@kamikazecash yeah so in your purely tax efficient SAHM collective you also have to swap wives it can get a little complicated but with the right community...
I love this Remington-inspired work, your brushwork is amazing. I've been trying to get something with a storm rolling in just as a rider discovers a mangled gap in his fence, hitting at that decision point, thought AI would help, but it's really uneven when you look at all the details
If you ever have anything that can hit on this idea, the tension around not knowing the right time to act, when to take risks and when to fulfill your obligations, I'd find it moving and definitely buy a print
absolute banger paragraph by Engler: some meditators "seem attracted to Buddhist practice as a short-cut solution to the developmental tasks necessary to their stage of life"
"the no-self doctrine is taken to justify their premature abandonment of essential psychosocial tasks"
Related you should configure automatic alerts anytime anyone searches the word password. We've caught probably half a dozen compromises off "Password " alerts.
@tracewoodgrains hey it's fun to hear people's thought processes in development.
i share your anxiety that social media is not a welcoming place for that
but fwiw here you go, you are hereby invited to have as many half or full or trial thoughts on this as you like
Writing is a superpower. It is an exceedingly difficult skill to master. Winston Churchill has some notes to assist us. If you're like me, you didn't learn to write well in primary school. It's not an excuse. The greats show us the way.
judging from bodybuilding forums the answer is just tren
give or take a little work on safety
i'd love for everybody to be able to perfectly tune their baseline sexual desire set point, i'm a transhumanist on this point i guess. i think the freedom would be great and directly help a lot of people
at the individual level anyway
not sure what would happen to society overall...
i'm not sure whether the median person should adjust the dial of their own desires or not. i would brace for it going horribly wrong in perverse ways
i'd still support it (because freedom) but it might... call it 25%... go horribly wrong for everybody