Indian middle class general category male
* Born
* Study in school, either local medium or some corporate school with rigorous curriculum
* No fancy, colourful dresses as there is no market for boys
* No hobbies, no extra circular activities
* Select doctor or engineering
* Compete with 15L individuals for IIT-JEE without reservation
* Get a job, take personal loan, pay family debt
* Get married, manage expectations between parents and spouse
* Growth in income, 35% tax to FM
* Kid is born, work for their happiness & save for them
* Buy a house in 40s, Pay EMI till 60s
* Realise life is coming to end, work till 60
* Death
#Life
कागज़ भी तुम्हारा है, कलम भी तुम्हारी है,
चला लो जितनी मर्ज़ी, वो स्याही भी तुम्हारी है।
हालातों के पन्नों पर तुम कुछ भी लिख दो मगर,
जो कभी बदल न पाएगी, वो कहानी हमारी है।
My doctor was always 45 mins late, every visit.
No apology it’s just "Take a seat."
Last time I waited 1 hour 20 mins then I left.
Then wrote a google review. I wasn’t mean but just honest: "Always late, brings a book."2 stars.
He called me that night from his personal cell.
"You think I'm late because I don't respect your time?"
I said "...yes?"
The Sacred Cow in Uniform: How the IPS Lobby Perfectly Sabotages Law Enforcement
India’s law enforcement machinery is often described as overburdened, understaffed, and deeply politicized. But there is another dimension - rarely spoken aloud, always understood - that quietly undercuts policing from within: the entrenched IPS lobby. This elite universe operates with a strange, almost divine logic, managing to exert absolute authority while taking minimal responsibility. And it does so with a kind of elegant chaos that would almost be admirable if it weren't so dangerously counterproductive.
A System Designed for Power, Not Policing
The structure of Indian policing resembles a feudal kingdom more than a modern institution. At the top sits the IPS leadership, a cadre that enjoys disproportionate influence over all aspects of policing - recruitments, postings, promotions, procurements, intelligence, and, of course, the indispensable PR machinery.
Crime control, community policing, modernization, and scientific investigation often remain secondary pursuits, discussed sincerely only in conferences and seminars. The real currency lies elsewhere - political proximity, bureaucratic hierarchy, accumulation of (disproportionate)assets (plus management), pilferage of official resources, and internal lobbying.
The brilliance of the system lies in its inherent asymmetry:
'If crime rises, the constabulary failed.
If crime drops, the leadership succeeded.'
A flawlessly rigged accountability loop.
Command Without Competence
One of the system’s most ironic features is its deep-seated belief in generalism.
A single examination taken at age 22 apparently qualifies an officer - forever - to lead everything from cybercrime units to anti-Maoist operations to forensic modernization. Meanwhile, state police officers (as well as CAPF Officers) with 20-30 years of field experience are relegated to logistical roles, their practical expertise politely ignored in favour of “command posts” reserved for IPS officers.
The result is a leadership structure heavy on authority yet thin on real-world policing experience.
Innovation flows upward only as far as tradition allows, and tradition insists on hierarchy, not expertise.
The Art of Avoiding Reform
Police reform has been discussed for decades. Committees have recommended sweeping changes; courts have issued landmark verdicts; experts have written reports thicker than case diaries. Yet almost nothing changes.
Why? Because policing reforms require two things:
Political will to relinquish control, and
Senior police leadership willing to accept accountability.
Both are inconvenient. Far more convenient is the current arrangement:
Politicians enjoy pliability, and the IPS lobby enjoys prestige.
The cost of this comfort? An entire nation’s law enforcement capability.
Ground Reality: The Machinery That Barely Moves
Scratch beneath the shining brass and neatly pressed uniforms, and the picture is bleak:
Constables work 14–16 hour shifts with little rest.
70–90% of police time in cities goes to VIP security and protocol.
Forensic and investigative capabilities remain primitive.
Training is outdated.
Community policing models are neglected.
Political interference is rampant.
Conviction rates speak for themselves.
Yet the leadership continues to deliver keynote addresses on “Transformative Policing in the 21st Century,” armed with immaculate PowerPoints and lofty jargon.
Transformation, apparently, is a slide deck.
The Cult of the Lobby
The IPS lobby has mastered the art of survival. It protects its own with remarkable consistency. Even the most controversial postings, the largest law-and-order failures, or the most glaring administrative collapses seldom lead to real accountability. Transfers and reshuffles act as a cleansing ritual.
A failure in Place A becomes a posting in Place B.
A scandal in one ministry becomes a deputation in another.
And before long, medals and commendations resume with predictable regularity.
If medals fought crime, India would be among the safest nations in the world.
The Cost to the Citizen
What does this bureaucratic theatre mean for the average Indian?
It means:
Slower investigations
Poorer policing
Lower public trust
Politicized action
Safety that depends on luck more than law
The structure prioritizes hierarchy over skill, symbolism over substance, and ceremony over competence. Citizens become mere spectators in a system designed to serve itself.
Final Thoughts
The IPS lobby, with its entrenched influence and self-preserving instincts, has effectively turned policing into administrative theatre. The facade remains polished, the ranks remain rigid, and the medals remain shining - but the institution beneath is suffocating.
If India is serious about becoming a safer, modern nation, it must confront the uncomfortable truth: No reform will succeed unless this structural chokehold is loosened.
Until then, crime will continue to evolve, citizens will continue to struggle, and policing will continue to march in place - left, right, left - while the IPS lobby enjoys the applause.
#JaiHind
(The views expressed above are the author's own as a former BSF officer who commanded operational units, expertise in Border Management, CI/CT/LWE Ops & crafted intelligence.)