bread and roses

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@mathanginobili so it’s not what they’re thinking doing or saying it’s really just their ethnicity that you have a problem with? idk what to tell you. congratulations that’s nazi shit

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@YBLUVR696969 @9add10is @ShitlibSupreme @grok https://t.co/Hj0LRPGqmy

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@YBLUVR696969 @9add10is @ShitlibSupreme @grok if you’re interested his basic take is yeah we ethnically cleansed palestine because we had to if they wanted a jewish state (which is 100% true)

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@YBLUVR696969 @9add10is @ShitlibSupreme @grok yeah the historians who dismantled the israeli myth of it’s founding were jewish and israeli. this happened in the 80s. catch up

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@forces_at_work and it can be particularly attractive to leftists because as postone said anti-semitism presents and functions as a fetishized anti-capitalism

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@YBLUVR696969 @9add10is @ShitlibSupreme @grok why should they? arab jewish people were a pretty small minority in that area until a bunch of colonialists who did not live there moved in with a plan to create an ethno state and displace and remove them from the land their families lived on for centuries

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@YBLUVR696969 @9add10is @ShitlibSupreme @grok and syrians and lebanese and jordanians also have overlapping identities. doesn’t change the fundamental right of a people living on the land being able to govern themselves. your distinction without a difference hairsplitting does nothing to change this basic fact

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@YBLUVR696969 @9add10is @ShitlibSupreme @grok i never said that it was their primary identity

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@YBLUVR696969 @9add10is @ShitlibSupreme it “came in contrast” with zionists as soon as a bunch of people who did not live there came with a national project to create an ethno state that did not include the people who currently lived there

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@YBLUVR696969 @9add10is @ShitlibSupreme distinction without a difference and the fact that you think palestinians are the exact same as jordanians sounds like a skill issue for you

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@9add10is @ShitlibSupreme even at partition palestinians were a solid majority of the population and got considerably less of the land. do you think that’s the deal the palestinians should have taken?

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@9add10is @ShitlibSupreme the principle of self determination is that the people who live in an area have the right to govern themselves. palestinians were the ones living in that area

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@9add10is @ShitlibSupreme and fuck not that it matters but people have thought of themselves as palestinians since i don’t know maybe roman times

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@YBLUVR696969 @9add10is @ShitlibSupreme pakistan literally had never existed in any form, even as a census designation, until 1947

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@YBLUVR696969 @9add10is @ShitlibSupreme as i said you’re factually wrong about palestinian nationalism. it goes back as far as most nationalisms. you’re just repeating hasbara cuz you’re a dipshit

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@9add10is @ShitlibSupreme so if you’re willing to accept that pakistanis deserve self determination why not the palestinians

[bread and roses @smurfonastick]

@9add10is @ShitlibSupreme i’ll go slowly. im telling you that a majority of countries existing today did not have any sort of national identity before like 1850 and only a few actually had a state that was controlled by the people who lived there until decolonization in the 20th cent