And the people who say that they are Catholic/EO and are pro-abortion also hold the same position as you. You would just say they are wrong. I would say oneness Pentecostals are clearly wrong because I think scripture is abundantly clear on Jesus being fully God. You seem to look at the Bible and go "anyone who just reads the Bible and trusts it can't see that Jesus is fully God." (If you disagree with that assessment of your position then your punt to Oneness Pentecostals would never have been posted.
No, the individual is not the final arbiter. Where are you getting that from? The truth is God's. He is the ultimate final arbiter. We are tasked with apprehending his Word and will and we are fallible.
Consider if two of my kids got in a fight and I'm trying to figure out what happened. I am not the arbiter of truth itself nor the arbiter of meaning and the nature of reality. I AM the arbiter of the current tussle and bear responsibility for my errors before God because there will be times I mess up. But God has given me a specific, fallible authority that he expects me to weild via submission to him.
@ExiledFred@TwiceBornSpirit@sebconverted Now tell me why you think the church is clear on the canon but believe the Bible is utterly unclear on the deity of Christ.
@ExiledFred@TwiceBornSpirit@sebconverted Genuineness has nothing to do with the clarity of scripture. I can show you some very genuine Catholics and EOs that think that abortion is fine and God accepts everybody into heaven. Why is it so unclear to them? Believe it or not, the Bible actually tells you: 2 Peter 3:15-16
The pre-Nicene writers (Justin, Irenaeus, Clement, Tertullian, Origen, Minucius Felix, Lactantius) uniformly reject cult statues and images of God, and several assume Christians have no images at all; most of these texts target pagan idols, so they show that early Christians had no image cult rather than ruling directly on biblical pictures.
This is just scratching the surface but:
Justin Martyr (First Apology 9; ANF vol. 1, Dods/Reith trans.; PD, https://t.co/wjDU8JfvCC): โAnd neither do we honour with many sacrifices and garlands of flowers such deities as men have formed and set in shrines and called gods; since we see that these are soulless and dead, and have not the form of God (for we do not consider that God has such a form as some say that they imitate to His honour).โ
Irenaeus of Lyons (Against Heresies 1.25.6; ANF vol. 1; PD, https://t.co/LbM3sKp3BP): โThey style themselves Gnostics. They also possess images, some of them painted, and others formed from different kinds of material; while they maintain that a likeness of Christ was made by Pilate at that time when Jesus lived among them. They crown these images, and set them up along with the images of the philosophers of the world that is to say, with the images of Pythagoras, and Plato, and Aristotle, and the rest. They have also other modes of honouring these images, after the same manner of the Gentiles.โ
Lactantius (Divine Institutes 2.19; ANF vol. 7, Fletcher trans.; PD, https://t.co/QYgN8u2I3P): โWherefore it is undoubted that there is no religion wherever there is an image. For if religion consists of divine things, and there is nothing divine except in heavenly things; it follows that images are without religion, because there can be nothing heavenly in that which is made from the earth.โ
Eusebius of Caesarea (Letter to Constantia; Greek in PG 20.1545 and Hennephof, Textus byzantinos 42โ44; English: Cyril Mango, The Art of the Byzantine Empire 312โ1453, 1972, copyrighted): โYou also wrote me concerning some supposed image of Christ, which image you wished me to send you. Now what kind of thing is this that you call the image of Christ? ... What sort of image of Christ are you seeking?โ
You can have certainty in the sense that you can have certainty that God says what he does in his Word. The use of the word "certainty" here can be dangerous because of equivocation and that's my only hesitancy. The Bible is clear on many things and I can rest on the comfort of trusting in what God has said. The Bible isn't clear on everything and I can approach those less clear issues by looking to history and other things while staying humble and always returning to the essentials.
@xuhbhv@BebopJosh@BishopJaxi Where are they described in a way that gives grounding for the idea of pope and their inclusion in that category? I will then do the same for the trinity
I think there are some things that are clear that people twist to their own devices, somethings that are unclear and even some of those that get twisted, and somethings under-determinate. I do think that the Holy Spirit guides the whole church but that doesn't mean that a given individual is listening or that God does not keep things less clear for the sake of other ends.
We can go to leaders and authorities to help adjudicate these things. We just recognize that they are fallible and while we may be in roles where we submit, we do not mistake submission or listening for a claim to infallibility.
@JimBondOOSeven@thechurchsplit@DPGBehler Because the best early evidence, the only direct reference, argues vehemently against icons. If it was apostolic and what the church has always done, that is so far from what we would expect as to be insane.
@ExiledFred@TwiceBornSpirit@sebconverted Sometimes it does by clear statements in the text. Sometimes it indicates by indirect means. Sometimes it does not adjudicate at all and we must use other principles to guide us in our decision-making.
We aren't close to agreeing on framework but that has nothing to do with where we are currently arguing. I am putting your philosophy under the crosshairs you have placed other philosophies. In response, you are running. "Oh, we just can't agree." No, we haven't gotten to the point we can decide that, right now we're seeing if you can defend your position at all.
If your positions rests on "I just feel like morality is based on things I don't like" then just say so, but recognize how weak your position is and then refrain from criticizing any other moral philosophy.
Sure. In talking abot God's Word we are taking about God's revelation to humanity. God revealed himself through the prophets and in these last days he has revealed himself through his Son. For the sake of our direct conversation, and given Christ's full divinity, we can proceed with referring to God's Word as divinely inspired scripture (for simplicity).
@Luziditat@jaredhmoore But the nature of the intrinsic thing does affect what can be constructed upon the foundation. A foundation of a moral tri-omni God has a different force than "the chemicals that happen to be moving in my ape brain."