When an official BJP ad — promoting and celebrating physical violence against Gen Z students in a classroom as a means of taking part in ‘nations progress’ — is also the sort of ad an anti-BJP person might make to attack this party (the BJP guy slapping the student is exactly what the party’s govt did on July 20), you realise Narendra Modi has hit rock bottom and lumpenism and goondaism is all he has left in his political armoury.
@swadharmah@TrueIndology It's not my list bro. It's from you anti-reservationists' favourite surveyor. The premise of your argument is the numbers. Kindly look at the numbers here. Love how you are all brilliant statisticians when it comes to proving your point.
@keepitrealtill5@TrueIndology Campbell mentioned that e.g. 84% of South Arcot is "Soodra". Now that makes sense only if you include all castes other than Muslims, Vaisyas, Brahmins, and Kshatriyas as Sooder. Hence the Shudra category includes all landed castes like above.
@keepitrealtill5@TrueIndology Those listed as Shudra in this survey do not correspond to Dalits or SCs. Please have a look at the methodology of the survey. The surveyors adopted the phrase "Shudra" from the texts and applied to the ground where instead we have many non-Brahmin castes which are land-owning.
@keepitrealtill5@TrueIndology So the Shudras in this survey correspond to Reddies, Kammas, Nairs, Gowdas, Pillais, Vellalas, Kallars, and other Thevars. Not SCs (or even most OBCs for that matter).
@keepitrealtill5@TrueIndology I am not saying it's because of British. Why is your comprehension so low? I am saying the stats produced by William Adam were made with this end. Why do you anti-reservationists like taking the source so seriously?
@keepitrealtill5@lokeshbag67 Of course. But you said "will be rejected". Maybe some scholar will but people continue practice them. So think twice before citing theory when it means nothing before lived religion.
@CoiledFacts@lokeshbag67 I didn't expect you to get a rhetorical suggestion. I meant to say that any faithful translation would end up saying nearly the same things.
@keepitrealtill5@lokeshbag67 I know what you are saying when you called a stranger 'chutiye'. All I am saying is we do millions of things everyday even while they contradict Veda or Dharmasastras
@keepitrealtill5@lokeshbag67 This is a highly idealistic view of practice. Just look at your own life. How many gods you worship, how many Vratas you practice, how many mantras you utter at rituals are from Vedas/Shruti? The hierarchy of authority that happens to be common to all need not be practiced by all
@MRavinderReddi I think this is based on the benefit of hindsight - knowing what Vishnu would become overtime and in a particular conception of godhood. However we must judge the efficacy of a deity by what powers over human life they are granted. In the case of Vedas: number of suktas.
@Anviksha_ What percentage of movie characters are Hindus, and how many Muslims? Isn't that the more important question?? Majority is always over-represented in films and with them all positive and negative characters. This is common sense.