"Stupidity is knowing the truth, seeing the truth but still believing the lies. And that is more infectious than any other disease" - Richard Feynman
"You can't be neutral on a moving train" - Howard Zinn
Ben Tait (Habibi) is not Jewish. Neither is John Woodcock. There are lots and lots of people in the network of actors connected to Tait who are not Jewish, but who have been very comfortable accusing Jews of antisemitism.
Nobody is trying to say Jews control the media, and it's disingenuous and insulting to suggest that is what Byline is trying to do. It demeans you, @Dannythefink to suggest it, not least because so many of Tait's targets ARE Jewish.
This story is not finished. There is lots more to report. I suggest people reserve judgment until it's done.
But what HAS been revealed so far is there's a weird anonymous inflammatory Islamophobic troll account that is ACTUALLY AND IN FACT connected to prominent political figures who have tried to use their influence to crack down on protests, civil liberties and free speech around Gaza; he also happens to be influential in amplifying stories "cancelling" well-loved celebrities who have spoken about Palestine; he has been cited as a source in 45 media articles, almost exclusively in the right-wing and pro-Israel press; and individuals like Ian Austin and Jon Woodcock who claim to be fighting hate and extremism and have condemned other politicians on this basis, have long been working with and/or amplifying a troll spewing vicious bile under cover of anonymity.
This is a man who called a Jewish Holocaust survivor a "stain" and "creepy Jewish fig leaf" and repeatedly defamed Muslim figures as "Islamists" and "extremists." He said Ghada Karmi is "one of the worst racists" in the land. He's called good, kind gentle Muslim community activists and journalists "racists thugs" and "extremists" and "notorious antisemites". Multiple Muslim MPs have now aired their concerns about him.
He repeatedly attacks Jewish figures - including Ed Miliband. He says, over and over, that Jewish activists who have spoken out on Gaza are "champions of antisemites" or similar. He's defamed people so often in my opinion that I can't see how a court could rule honest opinion or public interest.
Surely this must raise questions about the veracity and reliability of media narratives he's helped create? Surely it raises questions about the political judgment of political figures appointed by the government to advise on extremism and racism to be so closely associated with Tait? Surely it must be concerning that our public discourse and government decision-making has been underpinned by smears and Islamophobia?
I find it really striking that so many people don't seem perturbed by the fact that this guy was running an anonymous troll account AT THE SAME TIME that he was part of a campaign group spending £100k attacking the Labour Party, without any indication of where this money is from, alongside two sitting MPs who are then elevated to the House of Lords. I find it amazing people aren't wondering whether Tait's thinking and "research" informed THEIR thinking, underpinning reports calling for massive expansion of police powers to tackle "extremism" - the "extremism" and "hate" identified by Tait, like marching against war crimes.
I'm confused that so many people refuse to acknowledge, let alone care about, the issues of transparency and accountability that are raised.
I doubt that many people who have defended Tait care very much about what I have to say, but here's a fair warning nevertheless: you are going to start looking extremely weird if you defend Tait and think this is all a nothing-burger.
It's mad - MAD - that this troll has had such political influence, driven so much media coverage, infected the minds of our political class and fed into govt proposals about ending free speech and an independent media, the right of assembly and democratic dissent.
It's mad - MAD - that people who have presented themselves as sober experts on hate, extremism and antisemitism are staking their reputations defending this troll and his excretions.
Isn't it - at the very least- interesting to ask why?
@robfordmancs I think you are attibuting words I never said or indicated to me. I read your thread. I probably shouldn't have but had a 12min train ride, so I tries my hardest.
@pippaheylings The LibDems epitomise wasted votes. They have extremely low impact for their 76 MPs. But thanks for the austerity, no PR and student fees.
Well said by @Thelma_DWalker.
@TheGreenParty punch like they've got 72 MPs, while @LibDems act like they've got 6.
And that tells you everything about the state of British politics.
The Greens are standing up for what actually matters. Climate justice. Peace. Human rights. Tackling obscene wealth inequality. Rebuilding our public services. And challenging an economic system that puts private wealth ahead of public good.
Maybe instead of asking Greens to defect, they should be asking themselves why the Greens are increasingly becoming the voice of genuine opposition.
We don't need more of the same politics in different colours.
We need fundamental change.
Join The Green Party:
https://t.co/SFDMmr0Gax
It's important this performative video is met with the scorn that it deserves.
Silence would be unacceptable.
But it's actually worse to have Labour making sad videos whilst continuing to arm a genocide and arrest those who protest. It should be beneath contempt.
Andy Burnham has appointed these US consultants to draw up his 10 Year Plan, hot on the heels of the same company drawing up a Gaza ethnic cleansing plan for Trump.
Mandelson moment for Burnham
https://t.co/Cl8Zj4HerI
Hi @bbclaurak,
Zionism has resulted in the bombing of children & the killing of tens of thousands of innocent people in Gaza.
Again - the actual controversy is the Labour Government are arming that & the BBC 'debate' if it's racist.
How's that for answering the question?