You know what, I think this is the end of the conversation.
We won't get anywhere from here.
As I said, women get the exact same right to feel like their identity is at risk by opening up the definition of the word "woman" to also include men, as men do to feel their identity is erased by not being allowed inside it. I guess...
We can cry freedom of speech from here all we want.
You and Hunter have the right to be butt hurt that the word "women" doesn't include men and you can try to force me to change my definition because hunters identity is "being denied" if I don't accept, and I can be about you wanting to change my definition, and not wanting to because I feel women's identity is denied if I do.
Either way we all have the right to feel like our identity is at risk. You can defend your view and I can defend mine all we want. That's freedom of speech right?
Also, you are a man. Why do you get to decide "trans women calling themselves women don't hurt you". You wouldn't even know. You wouldn't get it. Why are we even talking about this.
Women get the same right as Hunter to feel like their identity is threatened if definitions change or they don't.
But as I said, just because I don't include trans women in the definition of women doesn't mean I hate all trans people. I already made my case on that. If you think respecting pronouns which I can and will, but not calling you the word you like, tough shit. You don't get to demand more. You can ask nicely, and I can decline.
Doesn't mean I think you can't exist. Trans women exist, they're out there, for better or worse.
And for me, they'll always be men though.
You didn't answer me before yo. What the hell.
So tell me one thing.
I'm not allowed to say that including transwomen inside the definition of "woman" like is some umbrella term for whomever feels like a woman, erases the identity of biological women.
Cool.
But Hunter or any other trans is allowed to say that me not including them in the definition of woman, erases their own identity and I'm a bigot.
Even though under our first amendment I have the same right to free speech as them.
So they are allowed to impose their definitions, I'm not allowed to keep mine, huh? You can disrespect my beliefs, I can't disrespect yours.
And just like you can't give me a reason as to why not calling a transwoman a woman is an erasure of their idenity, you just "know it to be true", so will I reserve the right to further try to explain why expanding the definition erases that of biological women.
You don't get to decide if changing my definition of "woman" isn't disrespect. That's for me to decide. Juts like it's your call if you decide to get butt hurt if I don't call you the word you want.
@hokkori_buzz I still have a 2004 renault clio!! The poor bastard has so many problems, but it gets from point A to point B. I love that car. It's my moms.
@visegrad24 A Social Democrat PM in Denmark says this out loud while half the GOP was too scared to even say deport.... we lost because we deserved it man
Look, bro.
I didn't say I wanted to kill Hunter or that they shouldn't dress like they want, and I even said that, unless you are dumbass, I will use your pronouns.
Literally, it seems to me, the ONLY thing that we disagree on is me refusing to call transwomen "women", and you telling me that's bigotry, because I don't want to give up basic biology.
That's it.
I said, you wanna be gay, be gay. Bro, I'm and advocate for gay marriage, I think it's one of the best things about western culture, that we undesrtand that dudes marrying dudes and girls kissing girls isn't some existencial threat. That men and women are legally allowed to dress however they want. That we, at least our laws, give soace for things that are objectively not harming anyone. Like, really. Gay people existing won't kill you. I know this very well.
Same goes for quiet "trans" people or cross dressers. I don't care. Wear whatever you want.
By your last reply I understand that we are in agreement in almost everything.
But I will say, women's spaces are for biological women. Period.
I literally said, I will call you by your pronouns because i'd rather that than fight. That's the bare minimum if you'd like, and I'm closed minded, but you are NOT entitled to expect more from me.
I also said that advocacy for trans and pushing it as an ideology is different from being a quiet peaceful trans person, we are in agreement, again.
I did say that Schafer is, or at least was, the former. An advocate, loud trans individual.
I never actually said they shouldn't exist or that I'm willingfully reluctant to say "trans women are women" EXPLICITELY to be hostile.
I'm standing up for what I believe is the truth. The correct definitions.
And if it comes out as hostile, so be it. I'm sorry.
But I'm not being hateful for the sake of being hateful, just as I'm sure you aren't literally trying to be hateful either.
I could easily just call you a hater of women and dismiss your ass and not reply.
So tell me one thing.
I'm not allowed to say that including transwomen inside the definition of "woman" like is some umbrella term for whomever feels like a woman, erases the identity of biological women.
Cool.
But Hunter or any other trans is allowed to say that me not including them in the definition of woman, erases their own identity and I'm a bigot.
Even though under our first amendment I have the same right to free speech as them.
So they are allowed to impose their definitions, I'm not allowed to keep mine, huh? You can disrespect my beliefs, I can't disrespect yours.
And just like you can't give me a reason as to why not calling a transwoman a woman is an erasure of their idenity, you just "know it to be true", so will I reserve the right to further try to explain why expanding the definition erases that of biological women.
You don't get to decide if changing my definition of "woman" isn't disrespect. That's for me to decide. Juts like it's your call if you decide to get butt hurt if I don't call you the word you want.
I didn't dismiss them, even if they seemed like a ChatGPT reaponse, I replies to your arguments, didn't I?
Also, yeah. You've said that. I'm disgusting, a bigot. We established that. If you explained to me why, though, if you had actual arguments as to why I'm wrong, why what I'm saying is so outragious, them we could have a conversation.
Because you calling me a bigot and disgusting but not giving me any actual arguments does nothing to help your case lil' bro, if you can't tell me why.
How does trans not pose a threat to women?
How does changing the definition of woman to accomodate whomever just "happens to feel like a woman" not affect actual biological women?
How does the erasure of women's spaces for just women not affect women?
Okay ChatGPT. I can tell you made this with AI. Maybe I'm wrong but it reads like it lol.
All right, so. What you are saying is that Hunter just get to say "I'm a woman" and all real women have to say "YUP!" ?
People like Hunter area literally DECIDING someone's identity bitch, now you are not a woman, you are a "cis" woman, because this guy wants to larp. Too bad, sorry. Woman as a term doesn't exist anymore! I jsut decided your identity.
But it's fine, I can do it! You can't choose what I am, but I can choose what you are.
WHAT?
So Schaffer can say I'm "cis" -woman, but I can't say "trans" -woman? We all just have to say that we are all the same, and we are all just "women".
Also, my brother, I don't know how to explain this to you. I thought I just did. It's not that I'm hateful against people who are "different" from me, retard.
Hunter is "different" from me, of course, but it is NOT just that. Its not BECAUSE we are different. Way to either pretend you don't understand the argument I'm making, or show everyone how stupid you are.
Also my arguments don't "depend" on me using slurs, they work perfectly fine without them, just replace "fag" for "gay". There., fixed it for you. It's called freedom of expression dumbass. I just talk that way.
My arguments would hold up just fine with no slurs in them. Fucking read. And you know that, too.
@visegrad24 Out of everything on social media they picked tradwife videos as the harmful content?? Women baking bread is the threat now.... Australia man c'mon
If you want to be a fag be a fag. I'll even call you she or he, I will EVEN call you they/them. I will never say you are woman if you aren't or a man if you aren't, though. Don't push it.
Changing a few words from my language doesn't require any real effort from me to use your pronouns.
But activism and pushing this stuff affects women and women's spaces which affects me, when we say things like "trans women are women" and it affects kids by pushing it in schools and can push already mentally unwell kids over the edge.
If you are over 18, want to crossdress and even have a disgusting surgery, fine. Unless you are piece of shit I'll even respect your pronouns, because it's easier than fighting and arguing.
But make no mistake. Trans does affect me. Activism for this stuff affects everyone. Schaffer is or at least was an activist fighting for women to lose women's spaces.
Also, I do, too, understand the people that don't even want to put up with the pronoun shit.
I will because I'm a superior and intelectually enlightened being, but I will defend people's right to not even respect THAT.
It's freedom if speech.
Surely the party of acceptence, inclusion and undesrtansing that just loves free speech can understand, right?