Minarchist Language Martinet and Computer Geek.
I don't speak for my employer, which is very easy to do because right now I have none. DM me any leads.
@Kontotako@anonpartizan@reggularMike Would the HT coin still have 2 sides?
The issue is that “choose HH, flip H” is twice as likely as “choose HT, flip H”, because only half the HT choices flip H. “There are 2 outcomes, so 1/2” ignores that reality.
@Kontotako@anonpartizan@reggularMike The side doesn’t change the outcome, but every time you choose HH it flips H, while only half the time you choose HT does it flip H. You had twice the chance to get H from HH as from HT. You can’t pretend those are equally likely.
@Mustang5428@multiplanet1 The raw materials are grass, water, medicines and supplements, and the labor of some cowhands and veterinarians, meat-packers and burger-flippers, and the transportation from ranch to restaurant.
@CrankyTRex@TwisteChristian Draw HH and flip H
Draw HT and flip H
Draw HT and flip T
Draw TT and flip T
If these are equally likely, then "Draw HT" is now twice as likely as "Draw HH "or "Draw TT", which can't be right.
We know that the second and third outcomes must sum to 1/3, so each is 1/6.
It's amazing how many people in the comments get this wrong. Many are smart enough to realize that seeing H eliminates both sides of TT, but they fail to account for eliminating the T side of HT.
IF YOU DON'T UNDERSTAND THIS MATH, DON'T BET
There are 3 coins in a box:
Coin 1 has heads on both sides.
Coin 2 has tails on both sides.
Coin 3 is a regular coin (heads/tails).
You randomly pick one coin and flip it.
The result is HEADS.
What is the probability that you picked the coin with heads on both sides?
A) 1/3
B) 1/2
C) 2/3
D) 3/4
What's your answer?
@CrankyTRex@TwisteChristian I'll slow it down.
The original problem gave you that it flipped heads.
I'm playing out the other half of the probability space, and saying that if it flips tails, the question is whether it's TT or HT.
Now apply the "there are only 2 choices" logic, and we have 4 outcomes:
@CrankyTRex@TwisteChristian Clearly, this is false, so by indirect proof, HHfH and HTfH can't have the same probability. HTfH+HTfT=HT=HH=TT=1/3.
Thus HTfH (and HTfT) is half of that, or 1/6, which is 1/3 of the 1/2 represented by fH, and HHfH is the other 2/3.
@CrankyTRex@TwisteChristian I had an epiphany on "tails up".
Suppose it does land on tails.
Now the question is whether you have TT or HT (given flip T). If you think HH and HT (given flip T) are equally likely, then you must also think TTgfT and HTgfT are.
Now add the HTs, and you get 50% instead of 1/3
@MLBHistoryGuy@UniquelyDavid@reggularMike and you know that you only had a 1/3 chance to pick HT before the flip, so by the principle of indirect proof, the assumption of "1/2 HH given flip H" must be incorrect.
You have to make the "HT, given flip H" and "HT, given flip T" add up to the same probability as HHgH /TTgH.
@MLBHistoryGuy@UniquelyDavid@reggularMike I just thought of another.
If it really were 1/2, then what if you flip T instead? The same logic would say that TT and TH, given flipped T would be the same.
So you have 25% chance each of flipping H from HH, H from HT, T from HT, and T from TT. Add the two HTs=50%!
@RyderAnalytics@OfWonk@anonpartizan@reggularMike …and you have
25% Flip H, HH
50% Flip H or T, HT
25% Flip T, TT
So HT had to be twice as likely as HH or TT to result in 50/50 HH/HT given H, and 50/50 TT/HT given T.
@RyderAnalytics@OfWonk@anonpartizan@reggularMike Here's another argument.
Suppose that instead, you flipped T, and I asked you the chance you have TT v. HT. Your argument says they're equally likely.
And flipping H/T are equally likely.
So that gives
4 possibilities:
Flip H, HH
Flip H, HT
Flip T, HT
Flip T, TT
Add them…
@AaronWorthing The biggest impediment to 3rd parties is that voting for anyone other than the top 2 candidates is "wasting your vote" because it doesn't affect the margin of victory.
That's why I don't get the objection to Ranked-Choice Voting. It lets us not waste votes.
@RyderAnalytics@OfWonk@anonpartizan@reggularMike That's not an argument against my logic.
I can see the red and green, while you apparently refuse to see it. You think the HT had the same chance to flip H as the HH had, and ignore the information we got from the fact that it flipped H.
@RyderAnalytics@OfWonk@anonpartizan@reggularMike You could also have flipped the other H on the HH.
Let's say I write a small number on each face of each coin, then cover it with tape so you can't see it.
The coins are
H₁/H₂
H₃/T₄
T₅/T₆
Once you see the T, you've eliminated T₄, T₅, and T₆.
H₁, H₂, and H₃ remain.