Boles's Nuclear Bargain Looks More Dangerous by the Day
In August, I warned that a proposal to extend Britain's nuclear protection beyond NATO had reached the desk of Jonathan Powell, the National Security Adviser. Nick Boles, the former Conservative MP, wanted Britain to offer that protection as part of a new European Confederation in exchange for access to the EU's single market for goods. Three months later, Vladimir Putin is reportedly demanding that Britain withdraw its existing nuclear protection from European allies as a condition for peace in Ukraine. The contrast could hardly be more revealing.
According to a Russian negotiating document dated 10 November, Moscow wants NATO forces withdrawn from Eastern Europe, restrictions on European nuclear protection and an end to Western military assistance to Ukraine. Reports also describe demands concerning Finland's NATO membership. These proposals revive much of Putin's failed ultimatum of December 2021, issued shortly before he invaded Ukraine. His ambitions plainly extend beyond the territory his armies have occupied.
Britain should reject those demands outright. Our nuclear deterrent has contributed to NATO's collective defence for decades. Putin has no authority to decide which sovereign nations Britain may protect, where NATO may deploy its forces or which countries may join the alliance. Yet the significance of his demands extends beyond Moscow. They demonstrate just how valuable Britain's nuclear protection is to European security, and why its future must never become a bargaining chip.
That brings us back to Burnham's proposed reset with Brussels. For months, his government has pursued closer economic and political relations with the EU. Greater regulatory alignment, access to European markets and deeper cooperation have all featured in the discussion. But the public has heard remarkably little about the full price of that relationship, particularly where defence and national sovereignty are concerned.
Boles's proposal deserves renewed attention. His European Confederation would embrace countries outside NATO, including Ukraine, Switzerland and several Western Balkan states. Britain would commit to spending 3.5 per cent of GDP on defence and extending the benefits of its military capabilities, including nuclear protection, to participating countries. In return, it would gain single-market access for goods while remaining outside the institutions that determine the rules.
Consider the imbalance. Britain would assume potentially grave new security obligations while accepting economic regulations over which it had no direct legislative control. The country providing one of Europe's most powerful strategic guarantees would still be expected to negotiate access to its markets. Whatever the supposed commercial benefits, that is an extraordinary proposition.
The proposal was not government policy when I wrote about it in August. There is no evidence that Burnham has adopted it. But its reported submission to Powell raises a question that deserves a public answer. Has the government considered extending Britain's nuclear commitments as part of its wider negotiations with Brussels, and if so, on what terms?
Burnham has rightly rejected Putin's attempt to dictate Europe's security arrangements. He should apply the same seriousness to decisions being contemplated at home. Britain's existing obligations to NATO must remain firm, while any proposal to extend nuclear protection beyond the alliance demands parliamentary scrutiny and a clear democratic mandate.
Putin's demands have exposed the enormous strategic value of Britain's deterrent. They should also remind Burnham that Britain's nuclear shield is neither a concession for Moscow nor a sweetener for Brussels. Its purpose, reach and ultimate control must remain matters for Britain to decide.
Burnham's EU reset, Boles's nuclear bargain, and Britain's sovereignty at stake.
When I posted yesterday about Andy Burnham’s political machine secretly intercepting public emails to protect his Abu Dhabi property deals, my inbox was flooded by people thanking me for finally calling out what goes on in Manchester.
Well, I woke up this morning and looked at the latest financial disclosures coming out of the Greater Manchester Combined Authority, and the rabbit hole just got so much darker.
Burnham's authority has been caught funnelling nearly £1,000,000 of taxpayer money to completely anonymous beneficiaries in a series of secret payments.
They paid out £83,000 in rent to a hidden landlord. They handed out thousands in anonymous "consultancy fees." Worst of all, they gave a £210,000 capital grant to a property developer and completely redacted the name from the public ledger.
When journalists finally confronted them, the authority claimed hiding the £210,000 developer payout was just a "human error" and blamed the rest of the secrecy on data protection laws.
Look at the terrifying double standard at play here.
If a working citizen misfiles a tax return by fifty pounds or makes a mistake on a local form, the state will investigate their entire life, apply ruthless penalty fines, and threaten them with court.
But when Burnham's regional authority hands a fifth of a million pounds of public cash to an anonymous property developer, they simply shrug and call it a clerical typo.
This is exactly how the modern British political cartel operates. They use the language of bureaucracy and data protection as a legal shield to funnel public wealth to private, hidden corporate interests.
I am sorry, but they are not governing a city. They are running a shadow ledger with your money, and they are terrified of the public finding out who is actually cashing the checks.
Beautiful 1940s colour footage of the Cenotaph in London. Built just 20 years earlier replacing a temporary memorial created at the end of the Great War. Sir Edwin Lutyens waived his fee for its design.
The Red Wall and the coastal areas in the UK are as economically unequal as East & West Germany was in 1990 & it would cost & take the same level of commitment in levelling up the UK as it did the reunification of Germany. So if Andy Burnham believes he'll get away with this he's deluded.
Brexit
Please take 7 minutes to watch this in full. Every single person who believes in sovereignty, particularly in the Labour Party, should see exactly how bad this is for the working person or industry in the UK. The ‘Deep State’s’ destroying this country to save the EU?
@Piers_Corbyn@PaulEmbery@The_TUC@GMB_union@GMBGarySmith
The British Businesses That Will Answer to Brussels Without Ever Trading There
Andy Burnham's Brexit reset contains a remarkable bargain. In exchange for easier trade with the European Union, Britain is preparing to accept rules written in Brussels, including those governing businesses that have never exported a single product to Europe.
Consider the family butcher in Yorkshire, the dairy farmer in Wales or the small food producer supplying local shops. Their customers are British. Their businesses operate under British law. Yet the Government's proposed agrifood agreement would bring them within a regulatory system whose future rules will be decided by institutions in which Britain has no vote.
The Government's own guidance confirms it. The agreement will apply domestically whether businesses trade with the EU or not. As Brussels changes its rules, British regulations will change accordingly. This principle, known as dynamic alignment, reaches far beyond removing paperwork at Dover.
The scope is considerable. Food safety, pesticides, animal health, nutrition labelling, organic production and marketing standards are included. Dozens of EU regulations and directives would fall within the arrangement. Future changes could affect what farmers grow, which products manufacturers use and how food is sold.
Burnham argues that closer alignment will reduce costs and improve trade. Removing unnecessary border checks makes sense. Exporters have faced genuine difficulties since Brexit, and businesses would welcome relief from costly certificates and inspections. But a government surrendering future regulatory freedom should explain precisely what Britain receives in return.
The promised economic prize is £5.1 billion a year by 2040. That is a forecast, dependent on assumptions about future growth. Meanwhile, Britain's financial contribution to Brussels remains unclear. Ministers are asking the public to applaud the benefits before disclosing the full bill.
More troubling is democratic control. Britain would be consulted during the development of relevant EU legislation. Consultation, however, guarantees no influence. We would have no vote in the Council of the European Union, and the European Court of Justice would remain the ultimate authority on questions of EU law covered by the agreement.
Parliament would retain its legal powers. But exercising them against an international agreement could carry consequences, including disputes and retaliatory measures. Future governments might therefore face a choice between laws they oppose and economic penalties for refusing to follow them. That is an extraordinary position for a country whose voters chose to leave the European Union.
Britain also imports food from countries far beyond Europe. Aligning our standards and import controls with Brussels could restrict our freedom to negotiate different arrangements with those suppliers. The Fresh Produce Consortium has warned of substantial additional costs for importers sourcing produce outside the EU. Such warnings deserve examination before commitments become binding.
Brexit never meant Britain should stop trading with Europe or reject sensible cooperation. Restoring national control meant allowing elected British governments to decide which rules best served this country, while remaining answerable to the people who elected them.
Burnham now proposes an arrangement under which future EU decisions could reach into British farms, factories and shops without those affected having a meaningful vote over the lawmakers responsible.
The question Parliament should put to him is simple. Why must a business that never trades with Brussels surrender its regulatory independence for the benefit of one that does?
Until Burnham answers that, his Brexit reset looks less like practical government and more like a transfer of democratic power whose full price remains unknown.
EXCLUSIVE: Burnham’s ‘Supermarket Sweep’ - taking affordable, everyday goods off shelves.
“Customs Union would mean dearer food,” says former Single Market Minister.
Burnham’s Brexit Betrayal confronted with the hard economic facts:
https://t.co/PqrQHdq62f
Pls re-post!