Jack Lemmon delivers a monologue near the end of Robert Altman’s Short Cuts (🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟) that brought me to my fucking knees. I can’t tell you the last time a piece of acting made me cry that hard. His monologue…it left me breathless. I had to pause the movie because I was crying so hard. And as I paused the movie, I could see my reflection staring back at me through the TV, right next to Lemmon who was sitting there. I was sobbing. In that moment, I felt so connected, not just to Lemmon’s performance, but to this film - this story, these people, and to Robert Altman. I woke up Monday morning a changed person. Not by much? But perhaps by just 1 degree? But this movie was all I could think about. Whoever you are on this planet, wherever you might be reading this post, I pray to God you get a chance to experience Short Cuts the way I just experienced it.
Short Cuts is based on multiple short stories by one of my favorite writers ever - Raymond Carver. It follows the parallel lives of 22 people living in Los Angeles. All of the multiple stories jump from one plot to the next. Loose connections eventually, somehow, someway, find one another. The film features actors like Robert Downey Jr., Julianne Moore, Tim Robbins, Jack Lemmon, Matthew Modine, Angie MacDowell & Lily Tomlin. That’s about as much of the plot as I feel comfortable sharing right now. In other words, you don’t need to know more. Hell, you shouldn’t know more. By now, you’re probably pointing out the countless similarities between Short Cuts and PTA’s 1999 film Magnolia. The two share so much in common & its clear PTA pulled heavily from Short Cuts: both share a large, structural blueprint, they have multiple characters, they explore messy intersections of California life, and they both star Julianne Moore. But if I’m being honest? Short Cuts is better and here’s why.
This film’s cast, as I mentioned, is loaded with heavy hitters. But the biggest star of this film is Altman. Notably, this movie only earned 1 Oscar nomination - a rare achievement for any film, to only receive 1 Oscar nomination that isn’t for acting - but that nomination went to Altman for Best Director. And there is a reason. In the hands of a less experienced, less focused creative, this movie would dissolve in real time. But in Altman’s hands, what we get is a web of humanity that just…makes sense. The long zoom lenses, the constant panning, and incredibly observational tracking from Altman make this feel like you’re observing natural human behavior, not just watching a movie. But Altman’s most daring, boldest decision is his editing. The way he cuts from one incredibly painful story to the next at the exact moment that we an audience need more. THAT is the mustard on the hot dog. THAT is the oil that greases this wheel. Altman manipulates, molds, and manufactures each narrative to his liking & he cuts it with a razor’s edge when you least expect it.
But part of Altman’s genius as a director, perhaps the biggest part, is the way in which he brought the best out of his actors. Altman was the definition of an “actor’s director” and this film is the perfect example. By pushing each narrative so closely to one another - and by daring to even touch on so many narratives in one film to begin with - Altman relies heavily on his actors. And his actors all deliver in spades. Trust is such a key ingredient to the things Altman pulls of here. Keep in mind that this movie is 3.5 hours long and I honestly wanted it to keep going. That’s because Altman knew precisely how to call upon each and every last actor in this film at the right time. Whether it be RDJ, Modine, Robbins, or Chris Penn.
Movies like Short Cuts come around once in a lifetime. The entire experience of starting this on a Sunday morning in actively skipping all of my plans the remainder of the day so I could finish this 3.5 behemoth is a moment in time I’ll never forget. I thought I knew & loved Robert Altman. But then I saw Short Cuts.
Finished watching 'Person of Interest'
What a show fuck. I really did not expect to get this invested in it when I started.
Finch and Reese. And Root. And Shaw. And Fusco. And Bear.