@mattyglesias@AsteadWH@MattZeitlin I don’t think you are lying but u aren’t the only moderate Dem operation out there. I think ThirdWay and to a certain extent Chait were just trying to ensure he loses, or wins by as low a margin as possible
@jonathanchait@sunraysunray Haven’t there always been bigots in the coalition, I remember @mattyglesias even writing a column recently that u can’t win an election without bigots or something??
@jonathanchait I think Mehdi was doing idiotic analysis but @MattBruenig is smarter than Jeff and his analysis seemed far superior than whatever Jeff churned out first
@tacourba@jonathanchait I'm paywalled, but I have generally avoided arguing about popularity of ideas because I find issue polling to be a disaster. Not my thing. What tickled me about this election was just that after reading months of content about underperformance, it didn't show in the data.
@ascottmess@MattBruenig@jonathanchait If I were to make the most generous argument of what Chait is trying to get at it’s that Mamdani doesnt seem to evince hostility towards those who disagree w him the way AES does. AES thinks it’s a moral failing if u don’t agree with him about stuff. But it’s still a stretch
@mattyglesias@MattBruenig@jonathanchait I think u have made more restrained & defensible claims. I mostly took issue w the low quality analysis @JeffMightBWrong is churning out & that @jonathanchait is amplifying here. Its crazy to me that Jeff is claiming that Bruenig is the one who’s statistically illiterate here
@MattBruenig@jonathanchait Chait actually used to be more structured in 2010s. I have still not been able to figure out why hes been writing super alarm raising articles about AES these days while hailing Mamdani as “centrist”? What’s the diff btw the two? His commentary doesn’t even make sense anymore
@MattBruenig@jonathanchait Yup I prefer Yglesias as the centrist electoral pundit, @JeffMightBWrong should stick to snarky essays (which he’s good at sometimes). It’s led me to have a lower estimation of him reading such low grade analysis, then him psychoanalyzing why his opponents won’t accept it lol
@MattBruenig@jonathanchait I found it a bit weird that he called your analysis “statistically illiterate”. It’s maybe true for Mehdi but yours was much more statistically sophisticated against a null and given all your other work, I think @JeffMightBWrong is way out of his league here lol
@mattyglesias But you have an ideological preference for moderates even when electability concerns seem minimal so it’s hard to disentangle where you blur electability args with your personal ideological preferences