@Cadomafia@Eschatonicism Pagans love to play victim and cry about how the Christians persecuted them. Immeidetly afterwards they will remind us why Christians persecuted them in the first place.
@DillyHussain88@korrathetaymi Both are only considered wrong because of Christianity. I appreciate korras Christian side. Isn't it idiotic she defends Islam which institutionalized this and attacks Christianity which forbade it?
@Nadi_alkhayr@Jahilterminator@AxadJimco if a minority could survive the early periods, they could typically last until the modern era unless some sort of conqueror or tyrant exiled / killed them
@Nadi_alkhayr@Jahilterminator@AxadJimco the jizya was more burdensome early on, and eventually it become much easier to afford. the jizya was typically 1-2-4 dinars per year from umar to the mughals. however wages increased as time went on from inflation and whatever else making it cheaper in relation to wages.
@Nadi_alkhayr@MetalDude142678@Jahilterminator@AxadJimco u have to agree that at the very least its a probable reading that saghirun directly refers to the jizya which legit comes right before it. as most islamic scholars understood it that way.
@MetalDude142678@Jahilterminator@AxadJimco i dont understand what this changes exactly... most garrisons surrender when the war is clearly lost, thats how all wars worked back then. defeat the main armies and fortresses and the rest wont put up a fight.
@MetalDude142678@Jahilterminator@AxadJimco "ok and what does that have to do with anything I said"
it discredits the guy u just brought up... ishoyabb was courting the muslims for their favor
@Nadi_alkhayr@MetalDude142678@Jahilterminator@AxadJimco where does it say "or subdued" the arabic sure dosnt say that
ٱلْجِزْيَةَ عَن يَدٍۢ وَهُمْ صَـٰغِرُونَ
"until they pay the tax, while they are 'saghirun' (humbled/submitted)"
@MetalDude142678@Jahilterminator@AxadJimco isoyab iii said jizya is half a mans possessions too mate while glazing them at the same time. the dude was saying anything to win the favor of the muslims. also there were celts who glazed the romans despite the Romans geocoding their entire race, humans being traitors isnt new
@MetalDude142678@Jahilterminator@AxadJimco heres a challange for you; find me one single piece of archelogical evidence that the brutal terrifying crusaders killed civilians en masse
@MetalDude142678@Jahilterminator@AxadJimco terrible argument from silence from whoever this cucklientilist is. we don't EXPECT to find brutality from them. the Vandals who burned, destroyed, massacred and pillaged their way across africa didnt leave a single piece of archeological evidence of brutality.
@MetalDude142678@Jahilterminator@AxadJimco "The Jews helped us" isnt the flex you think it is... Nevertheless it didnt take long for the Jews to hate yall anyways
https://t.co/JQuKKPMzNU
@Nadi_alkhayr@Jahilterminator@AxadJimco It just depends how you define force then. The conquered had three options; death, Islam or a burdensome tax with constant humiliation.
@Rashiq__Shahzad Dude all history pre 1800s isnt "neat" its piecing together what evidence exists, and the evidence that exists show that as time went on the wages increased while jizya *typically* remained at 1/2/4 (12/24/48) making it much more affordable hence less people had to convert.