@KhalilAndani@sarkar_280@sphinx_seven Its not circular, you are just assuming your conclusion and stripping will of all its meaning. If Gods will is free it is sufficient.
@sarkar_280@KhalilAndani@sphinx_seven wisdom provides the reasons for a choice, but it does not necessitate the choice. im just gonna tell you rn you cant do it bro.
@KhalilAndani@sarkar_280@sphinx_seven that just assumes causal activity must be temporally indexed within God. which again, needs to be shown to be contradictory... preferably without question begging and assuming the conclusion.
@sarkar_280@sphinx_seven@KhalilAndani a timeless necessary being can eternally possess the active power to freely specify contingent effects without undergoing change, composition, or imperfection in essence. prove otherwise.
@sarkar_280@sphinx_seven@KhalilAndani didnt agree to anything, dont know what your on. your step 5 assumes it if will = nature then no unrealized potential. this is just saying libertarian choice is impossible in different words. then you "conclude" libertarian choice is impossible. circular and question begging.
@sarkar_280@sphinx_seven@KhalilAndani yeah that is what your arg was trying to prove but you just question beg like the rest of yous... you cant show a contradiction without it.
@sarkar_280@sphinx_seven@KhalilAndani assumes necessitarianism to prove necessitarianism... question begging. you define "unrealized potential" in a way that already presupposes determinism, then act like you derived it.
@YossiKreinin@SuppressedNws1@haaretzcom so by your own logic, Lebanon can annex northern "Israel" since "Israel" has been bombing Lebanese civilians for decades. funny how that principle only ever applies in one direction...
@yesthatvelfi@JesvinGeo@nic0polito Repeating nonsense doesn’t make it true. You cry about a “grudge” while ignoring centuries of Christian destruction of Islamic sites. Yet, a preserved mosque is your issue? This isn’t ignorance—it’s historical reality. Stay in your feelings.
@yesthatvelfi@JesvinGeo@nic0polito Akhiruzzaman? Don’t act like you hold exclusive knowledge. The Prophet (saw) himself repurposed places of worship. The Ottomans did the same—without desecration. If you’re so concerned, where’s your outrage over churches turned into clubs and mosques erased from existence?
@CptReality@JesvinGeo@nic0polito “Living” isn’t the same as living freely. By your logic, any oppressed population that hasn’t been fully wiped out isn’t actually oppressed. That’s an absurd argument. Get your brain checked.
@CptReality@JesvinGeo@nic0polito Egypt has the largest Christian population in the Middle East, with churches everywhere, a national holiday for Coptic Christmas, and government funding for church restorations. If Egypt “massacres” Christians, explain how millions still live, work, and worship there freely.
@CptReality@JesvinGeo@nic0polito Ah yes, cherry-picking incidents to paint an entire country as intolerant—classic bad faith argument. By that logic, no country on Earth coexists peacefully, since religious violence exists everywhere, including in so-called “secular” and “Christian” nations.