Born on this day in 1632. “He that uses words without any clear and steady meaning, what does he but lead himself and others into errors? And he that designedly does it, ought to be looked on as an enemy to truth and knowledge.”— John Locke
@QuoteNietzsche There is only a perspective seeing, only a perspective 'knowing.' Objectivity isn't a view from nowhere; it is the capacity to employ a multitude of perspectives in the service of knowledge.
@E_IR Having focused my PhD on Foucauldian genealogy and historiography, I find this approach particularly compelling. Reading Foucault through this specific lens offers a genuinely illuminating perspective.
@DusenburyDavid Modernity didn't end apocalyptic thinking; it just replaced the priest with the technocrat and salvation with perpetual progress. Koselleck and Taubes diagnosed the core architecture of our current political theology decades ago.
A common criticism historians level at Foucault is: "You write history, yet there is no subject."
This misses two fundamental points:
Foucault never claimed to be a conventional historian; he was mapping the archaeology of knowledge and discourses.
The traditional 'subject' historians desperately search for is not a neutral given—it is an institutionally constructed artifact of power itself.
The state doesn't just record history; it defines what is allowed to be remembered. 'Archive fever' was never about preserving the past, but about institutionalizing power. As long as we reduce human history to simplistic cause-and-effect narratives taught by state institutions, we aren’t studying history—we are merely reciting official ideology
It really depends on the intent. In a purist sense, a writer’s voice—down to their rhythm and punctuation—should be entirely their own; otherwise, writing loses its soul beyond commercial utility. That said, as someone whose thoughts can be chaotic (I might give José Saramago a run for his money with punctuation), I see nothing wrong with using AI as an editorial mirror. If it simply distills and clarifies your own raw ideas without replacing them, it’s a completely valid tool. Also hi
@jonathanbfine Countless reasons, but the most disheartening is academia’s descent into pure performativity. Institutions that claim the legacy of the Humboldtian ideal now measure the worth of scholarship almost exclusively through immediate marketability and profit-driven metrics.
A common criticism historians level at Foucault is: "You write history, yet there is no subject."
This misses two fundamental points:
Foucault never claimed to be a conventional historian; he was mapping the archaeology of knowledge and discourses.
The traditional 'subject' historians desperately search for is not a neutral given—it is an institutionally constructed artifact of power itself.
@gregcatarino1 Even worse, aesthetic appreciation has been entirely outsourced to institutional validation. Most people wouldn't look twice at a masterpiece on the street; they only revere it in a museum because the venue gives them social permission to perform reverence.
@IThaListener Not that I've seen so far. While there is often a tricky divide between historical contextualism and pure philosophical analysis, Quentin Skinner’s work was genuinely transformative for my understanding of Machiavelli.
@PhiloCasey Indeed, his clarity surfaces whenever he chooses. Yet, I see his academic corpus more as an open-ended experiment, one where meanings intentionally shift and refuse to remain static.