I'm convinced gridlock energy drinks exist as a discipline method to keep the working class in line. No reason to drink this shit except poverty and punishment. I am on number 3 today.
@bicanis_baddog@DFv5v7xbqf9h@DogeXiaoping Reading comprehension, I'm saying that the view that if you believe these ever were socialist countries how could a change in the leadership of the CPSU/CPC be so complete? What happened to the parties Mao/Lenin/Stalin built? Where was the civil war? The 1991?
@bicanis_baddog@DFv5v7xbqf9h@DogeXiaoping Did Bernstein and Kautsky take part in a socialist revolution, establish a socialist state, and make it through successive periods of Communist party politics? The SPD is hardly the CPC.
@bicanis_baddog@DFv5v7xbqf9h@DogeXiaoping "The CPC contained massive numbers of cadres who were secretly against socialism the whole time or were bought off by having a bicycle and a slightly larger apartment." Makes total sense ๐
@Kamn_Krtz Workers AND oppressed of the world unite, it was the fundamental break of the comintern with the 2nd international, and you still don't get it lol
@hellaclitean@DogeXiaoping I mean it could be confusion around how we do embrace a lot of MZT but idk yeah I'm not from NOLA, great people doing great work though!
@hellaclitean@DogeXiaoping *dialectical analysis
Like the revolution does occur in the superstructure, but the institutions like the PLA don't just evaporate because the party swings to the right. This becomes important in moments like 1989, where people actually pushing restoration were defeated/purged
@hellaclitean@DogeXiaoping Nah we just actually use the dialectical we all read about so we don't take all those 'developments' uncritically. We also don't claim to be maoist like anywhere lol
@DFv5v7xbqf9h@DogeXiaoping In retrospect that delusion split the socialist world and saw the worst set back for the world proletarian revolution since the fall of the commune. The revolution is in the superstructure, that's real, not the idea that a change in the party bureaucracy undoes the revolution.
@redstreetcat@Fairtermfree@kingofthedregs Tbf most trot groups in America do call China imperialist and capitalist and self-righteously claim to be purer socialist revolutionaries than the actual workers states that exist today. That you do not is good, but you can't expect MLs to specify cliffites or northites lol
@redstreetcat I mean Stalin wrote his theory on the national question while he and Lenin were in the same faction and actively corresponding. At the time I believe Trotsky was doing his centrist thing so I can't really fault a trotskyist for being confused on this
The amount of slander and lies about our line on the national question is genuinely crazy to me because we write about it so goddamn much. Like read what we wrote! Where do we say nations are permanent? Where do we say white people are nation? Or that every 'ethnicity' gets...
Not arguing with no faceless profiles, [redacted] or [redacted] tokens about land my ancestors built under the boot of chattel slavery.
This ainโt no theoretical question for academics to ponder over. This is a question about self determination for Black people in the South.
@kingofthedregs Essentially yes but I get the sense that a minority (no pun intended) faction upholds that old line. Tbh people dunking on them for that dumb line didn't read enough gay lib stuff from the 1970s because that was unfortunately way to common, they just kept it lol
tbc I don't agree with this lol, I just think it needs to be explained that these incorrect lines today (that China is capitalist/imperialist) that the ultra-left and rightists both embrace emerged from an entirely incorrect analysis of soviet conditions.
This is the basis for the "China/USSR" restored capitalism in 1956/1976 line. Revisionism in political power = Capitalist Restoration because the economic base of socialism is just highly developed capitalism with the revolution in the superstructure opening the path to socialism
Now how they justify the position that these almost bloodless "coups" (inner party political struggles) overturned the entireity of the communist party and socialist state that it took world historic revolutions to create is still a mystery to me