“You’re not a journalist if you’re taking privacy into account” is quite a statement.
Privacy, public interest and minimizing unnecessary harm are absolutely considerations in responsible journalism.
Ed Oliver is a public figure. His child was not. And being a public figure does not mean every tragedy involving your family immediately becomes public property.
Nobody is arguing that the story could never be reported. The issue is whether there was a compelling public interest in exposing an intensely personal tragedy before Oliver chose to make it public himself.
For nearly seven weeks, people who knew exercised restraint and allowed a grieving father and his family some privacy. I don’t consider that a failure of journalism.
And if exercising independent judgment about whether publishing something causes needless harm makes me a “mouthpiece for the organization,” that’s a fascinating conclusion you’ve made for someone you don’t know.
Sometimes people independently arrive at the same conclusion because it’s the decent one.
We clearly disagree on where that line belongs. I’m perfectly comfortable with where I drew mine.
Knowing something does not automatically create a journalistic obligation to publish it. Journalists make editorial decisions every day about privacy, relevance and legitimate public interest. The death of a player’s young child, while he and his family are privately grieving, had no bearing on football, his job performance or any matter the public needed to know at that moment.
Respecting that boundary doesn’t make someone a “mouthpiece.” It means recognizing that journalism comes with judgment and responsibility, not simply an obligation to publish every piece of private information you happen to learn. If your definition of journalism is “I know it, therefore everyone else should too,” then I think we simply have very different definitions of journalistic integrity.
Yes, because “journalistic integrity” is famously defined as making sure you beat a grieving father to announcing the death of his child.
Silly me.
I thought there was still a distinction between information being available and information the public is entitled to know.
There’s a rather significant difference between “gatekeeping information” and exercising journalistic judgment about whether the public has a legitimate need to know something deeply personal.
The death of someone’s child isn’t a transaction where the first person to hit “post” wins.
Especially when that person is gloating that they “broke” the story all the while supporting a conspiracy narrative on his ability to practice or insinuating something foul occurred.
Bills’ Ed Oliver deserved to grieve his son privately.
I wrote this article this morning totally engulfed in emotion, anger and sadness for a man I don’t know and will never know me.
But that’s our fanbase…our fandom…
https://t.co/DuXA48MTKf
Thanks to @TickPick in less than 2 days a lucky Bills fan will win 2 field level tickets to watch Josh, Diggs, Kincaid and the boys go to battle against the Pittsburgh Steelers. Highmark is going to be electric! Don’t miss out on the opportunity to win. Just retweet the contest👀
GameDay fit for consecutive game 58…got my zubaz Santa hat and my sequin Bills jacket if it gets chilly.
We need this DUB….let’s goooo!
#BillsMafia | @BuffRumblings
🚨🚨 Christmas Giveaway 🚨🚨
To enter to win this signed Diggs jersey:
- Retweet
- Follow me
- Follow @jimmyreu81
Winner will be selected on 12/26!! Good luck!! #BillsMafia
Met up with part of my “minivan mafia” crew in KC… after we took the pic Josh Allen’s dad, Joel, was cracking up behind me cuz he had photobombed our pic…we started talking about New Orleans so I never looked…
I didn’t realize it was EVERY picture we took 😂😂 …Bravo Joel I’m dying 💀😂…see ya for game 57!
#Billsmafia
Ayoooooooooooo🗣️. The Buffalo Bills circled the wagons in Kansas City and the Miami Dolphins just pissed down their legs up 14 with 4:34 left in the game🤣🤣🤣. The December Choke has arrived!!! The Bills will win the AFC East for the 4th year in a row. It’s Go Time #BillsMafia
#BillsMafia be happy Miami lost and our team is alive in the division race still but do not stoop to the petty nonsense level that we received from fins fans after we lost to NYJ and Denver in primetime.
Big week for us but we don’t have to be corny and rub it in.
Make sure y’all download Pregame Rumblings on your favorite podcast platform Sunday at 8am!!
@JSpenceTheKing with an amazing opportunity to interview @HamlinIsland. Check it out! 🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽