@gran_archist@RealDianeYap I am enjoying this late-night dorm debate but unfortunately I'm way past college (!) and it's very late here. I do recognize there is a feminist debate over the value of child raising vs self-actualization. The OP was taking a provocative stance. That is what I was challenging.
@gran_archist@RealDianeYap You're reading that into her words. As written, it's a blanket claim. I was puncturing her balloon of certainty that "hey, not everyone thinks full-time moms are whiners". I wasn't disputing some careful claim that "many people say".
@gran_archist@RealDianeYap That's a Panglossian view of it. Take Steinem for example. She was quite negative on women who chose to raise children, saying they were sacrificing their potential. An "opera singer on a podcast" I believe she said.
@gran_archist@RealDianeYap So you generalized a response to the OP's question, and are critiquing my response because it was a specific rebuttal, rather than a general answer. That's on you.
@gran_archist@RealDianeYap I honestly have no clue what you're trying to argue now. Are you saying these words don't have negative connotations? Are you saying that mentioning a job is hard connotes praise, and isn't that the circular reasoning you seem to be implying?
@gran_archist@RealDianeYap Read her post. "Who else would do a job that pays nothing and gets you denigrated as a lazy complainer or neurotic, responsible for all tasks that men find beneath them?" I responded there are people (my family) who don't fit your framing. Where does your generalization enter?
@gran_archist@RealDianeYap I will agree with you on that, that internet articles and blogs are just more anecdotes. Unfortunately there are no direct statistical sources or scientific polls about subgroup views of stay at home moms. Only indirect results like more men support SAHMs than women do.
@gran_archist@RealDianeYap You're being purposefully obtuse. She clearly chose words with highly negative connotations. I'm not going to be gaslit into agreeing that she posted this as a neutral question on people's view of SAHMs. It's a leading and loaded question, full stop.
@gran_archist@RealDianeYap You are welcome to, but this conversation was: OP frames SAHM negatively. I respond not everyone sees it negatively. You say, but you're not representative, see the comments, which was a non sequitur.
@gran_archist@RealDianeYap If that's all you have to say about it, your listener is right to think you're denigrating it. If you say, it's backbreaking but rewarding work, that's different. She didn't.
@gran_archist@RealDianeYap I said "this poster is denigrating stay at home moms" and used her words as evidence. You said "feminists don't dunk on stay at home moms" and offered random X comments as high quality evidence.
@mathelirium Nothing to do with mathematicians I think. It's any highly educated and comfortable profession (in this case heavily protected in the ivory tower) facing real competition for the first time and whining about it. People who struggle to advance in the real world have no sympathy.