Indeed. That's why I have been asking under their comment section. Even with all the neglience, there were once I got a trader who's willing to move funds from a offsore exchange to regulatory one to trade, I still thought about backpack.
So I wanted to discuss with their growth team, how could the trading fee be optimized, and never got a reply too while they are giving 40/50% rebate to loads of random chinese kols who don't seems to have trading volume.
The team and the supporter were only replying to the message when I comment the good thing about backpack.
Based on all the interaction I saw and had regarding BP on X, got a feeling the team is not really competent on promotion and can't take critisim. That has further rose my doubt in acquiring clients.
Having been working at both CEX and DEX, therefore, I can confidently say that retails rarely give attention to regulotry framwork of the exchanges itself, therefore doesn't make it really interesting/special for the retails.
But I do stand by your points, offshore exchange are taking shortcut and they will be facing even more accusations in the future, and I do believe the offshore exchange will eventually fall including Binance. The space will be left for mostly Perp DEXs, and regulated exchanges. (As you can see from all the CEXs pushing this way, they are building their perp dexs, and trying to get the license wherever they can with their own entity. Perp DEX is basically the new version of offshore exchange to aviod legal issues.)
And that's why I think what make backpack especially interesting. One of the few exchanges got most license in the best area (EU/USA/JP, and list goes on) and focus on RWA.
To answer your questions, I wanted to allocate 20-50k for BP spot when it was 0.7, and I am still ready to allocate. Cuz I think they are in a very good position, good support from solana eco, as they solana need the exchanges of their own to list the toke in favor of them, RWA is the next boost engine and great license.
But still, the volume and real trade doesn't come from soly being good positioned. Lots of founders/team are assuming their product is good enough, and users come automaticlly and that is not the case at all. (That's why I mentioned Hashkey before)
My only doubt from all the questions listed in the post, was just one thing, how are backpack going to get customers, so far, from my experience base on their product, they are not ready to getting any meaningful one, can also be seen from their stats. and I wanted to know how the team is prepared for it. If I have ever gotten an decent answer from the team memeber or their post, I shall be aped in already, but still, no answers. So I am still closely watching it.
Have sent this not only him but also comment under Armani/Growth team memeber in CN & EU. No reply still.
Product wise I dont think Backpack as an superior one, given their liquidity especially after the TGE and very limited pairs.
what you have mentioned for 1:1 redemption and tradifi brokerage transfer, user could already redeem and transfer the stock that bought at Bitget and Binance to IBKR, and the stock bought at their platform could already serve as margin, the sametime getting the diviend. I do not think it is anything special nowdays for offshore users.
To your another 2 points,
EU users is very hard to get transferred, given the effort you can see from kraken and Bybit. (p.s. BG/Bybit and some offshore exchanges has won EU market mainly due to its affiliate marketing, and I don't think this could be applicaple anymore to BP, given the regulatory reason and the TGE has hurt loads of affiliates' confidence in the team)
US users, I couldn't say much about it, just my assumption, they might be interested in Perp+stock, but for legal route, isn't Kraken/coinbase/robinhood better place?
I found it is quite hard to understand very realisticlly where could volume and users from.
@basq0x@Backpack I have been asking mutiple times - bp team and supporters month ago, no one has answered.
Not to start a fight, but genuinly wondering what could be the real volume/edges coming from. That time I already find all the license bp gotten were impressive
https://t.co/ccxQBe9lGm
Genuine questions regarding the bp,
- Given the regulatoory frame, the three biggest markets I would assume;
1. Europe, OKX/Kraken/Bitpanda(Robinhood) and loads of local exchanges got the both mica and MiFID II licences. Bybit tried to be fully compliant with the europe, but turn out they failed. Kraken spent such a large budget here but didn't worked out too
2. US, Indeed most of the US users are accessing HL with VPN. But give cex nature of bp, coinbase/kraken/Kalshi/polymarket already got the license or at leaset exempt from having one.
let alone better team from HL are trying access the us market legally, Lighter is also on the way and with partnership of RH. (btw, the one who use vpn to access Hyperliquid, I assume they will continue to use no matter what new products come to the market)
3. Offshore exchange, Binance, Bybit, Bitget. I don't think anyone can overtake them in near future.
I fully convinced bp can pump way more, given the current FDV &MC, crime pump doesn't take that much of money. But just wanted to know, what would be the competive advantages here across these 3 markets, cuz I don't see any real edges in gaining customers, this way the price pump wouldn't be sustainble at all.
P.S. I was one of the early user on bp, ever since TGE, I stopped using it anymore, kept track of development, find all the license bp got are impressive, but just don't think these justify bp could be an top player.
@nobraintrader1 I was actually using Avax a while back, when I still have the revolut crypto cards, it was the cheapest network to use there.
Other than that, everything are incredibly expensive.
LoL
Claude essentially abstracts away many steps that require background knowledge. This lowers the barrier to entry enough that even a ragtag crew of finance-bros now has the ability to dabble in the types of activities normally out of their reach.
-Citrini research
@ConstanceWaing It’s quite normal. Cryptocurrency is officially and publicly forbidden. Almost every banks in China even have crypto is a scam slogan on the entrance