ambidextrous father, pilot, and attorney replacing politicians with representatives to upgrade U.S. electric grids. encounter “Yeshua” daily in cold and breath
Day 687. Wednesday, behind closed doors, they pick the Speaker for our House. No cameras. No public. No you. Congress froze your voice in 1929 and now each member "represents" 760,000 strangers. That's not a democratic republic. That's a cartel with a flag pin. Uncap the House.
@MassachusettsXY@UncapTheHouse@edfischman The 1929 Apportionment Act used a fixed number not a ratio. A ratio was proposed in the only amendment in the bill of rights not yet passed. A ratio is the appropriate method.
This is true. We've had the House fixed at 435 members by law since the 1929 Permanent Apportionment Act. But the only limits in the Constitution are that every state must have at least one member, and a member must represent at least 30,000 people. Currently they all represent about 760,000 people.
So a simple federal statute could expand the House a little, or massively. Makes you wonder why the democrats haven't tried to do this already - and then you recall that it would diminish the power of every member of the House, and left or right, they don't want that.
@Bubblebathgirl You can keep the Electoral College and still fix the imbalance she's describing. Those state totals track House seats, and a 1929 statute froze the House at 435. Lift the cap and the gap between big and small states starts to close. Uncap the House.
@PodSaveAmerica If only two parties have a real shot, look at the map they compete on. Districts of about 760,000 people are huge, expensive, and hard for anyone new to enter. Grow the House and you shrink that barrier. Uncap the House.
@chucktodd@AdamKinzinger Agree on the diagnosis. One correction: Congress stopped growing the House in 1911 and locked the cap in 1929, not 1930. Large districts make gerrymanders easier and neighbors harder to hear. Uncap the House.
The first proposed amendment to the Constitution, what almost became the First Amendment in the Bill of Rights, was about the size of the House, ensuring it expands over time.
There's a reason our Founders thought it was so vital.
The Electoral College reflects the fact that the US is a republic. The Founders wanted a constitutional system based on the consent of the governed, but they wanted filtering mechanisms so that the will of the people would be channeled towards the public good. And they wanted the role of the states respected.
The EC also guarantees that in an “extended republic” like the US, a candidate cannot just run up the score in one region of the country.
In our time, the EC serves to produce a clearer and more decisive winner (see, eg, Bill Clinton winning 43% of the popular vote but a strong majority in the EC) and focuses election administration in individual states, which reduces complexity in a close race.
We should be doing more to bolster federalism and the role states play, not further weaken them.
There is no reason to change the Electoral College.
@edfischman@MassachusettsXY@UncapTheHouse So why would you meddle with that by creating a new incentive to move to the place with cheap land and bad weather?
The solution is easy, don’t base the uncap on the size of a state. Pick a ratio and go.
@ChrisCillizza That gap is structural. One House member now speaks for about 760,000 people. In 1911 it was about 210,000. People don't obsess over Congress because Congress is too far away to obsess over them. Uncap the House.
@ChadPergram The Senate was built to slow things down. The House was built to hear the people. A 1929 law froze that chamber at 435, and today one member speaks for about 760,000 people. If the worry is the public's will, start by letting the people's chamber grow. Uncap the House.
@FischerKing64 That's the incentive, on every side. A 1929 statute protects the power of the people already in the room. In 1911 a member spoke for about 210,000 people. The House belongs to the public, not the incumbents. Uncap the House.
Disagree. You are changing the incentives, and incentives drive outcomes. This would create one incentive for people to move to one state, not many different states. Republicans have repeatedly noted the influx of undocumented immigrants to blue cities. The solution is easy. You want 1/550,000.
@edfischman@MassachusettsXY@UncapTheHouse You apparently didn’t read what I said. Don’t use a state’s population for the denominator or you create an incentive to flood that state with more people. Fix the denominator in law, not the census.
I live in Wyoming and am deeply familiar with the Wyoming rule or Wyoming 2 rule. Using a states population creates perverse incentives to move people to that state. No thanks.
1/500,000 is much cleaner. You can use the state as a reference when coming up with the denominator, but it should be fixed in statute, not subject to the next census.
The Wyoming rule creates perverse incentives for people to move to Wyoming. The ratio should be fixed, not movable.
Uncapping the House fixes the electoral college because its numbers are based on the number of reps. Increasing the number of reps makes the electoral college more granular.
Thank you for attending my TEDx talk